No Opposition Supporters CAS hands down guilty verdict - Players appealing - Dank shot - no opposition - (cont in pt.2)

Status
Not open for further replies.

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Bombermania

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Dec 18, 2007
Posts
8,102
Likes
4,010
Location
Counting premiership cups
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Non that play Essendon
How can you guarantee? Spoken to them? Asked their opinions?
I suspect quietly many have lost some respect over what has happened, I know many here and at the Blitz are still defending Hird but I suspect most of it is purely down to his time as a player.

This is why Hirdy and the club taking a break from one another for a short period of time whilst the club focusing on rebuilding might be in the best interest of everyone in the medium to longer term.
 

boncer34

Inaugural Steward
Joined
Jul 11, 2005
Posts
40,461
Likes
40,226
Location
Baghdad
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Melbourne Storm
I suspect quietly many have lost some respect over what has happened, I know many here and at the Blitz are still defending Hird but I suspect most of it is purely down to his time as a player.

This is why Hirdy and the club taking a break from one another for a short period of time whilst the club focusing on rebuilding might be in the best interest of everyone in the medium to longer term.
Suspecting is very different from guaranteeing
 

DERO

NOBODY PUTS BABY IN THE CORNER
Joined
Jan 22, 2013
Posts
12,221
Likes
16,165
Location
The Ivory Tower
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Mitcham FC
I own the business that offered to put the money up, the Age reporter who interviewed Foggy (a ripping bloke by the way) is a friend of mine and the person instrumental in getting everything organised, printed and delivered is a business associate. So yeah, I can guarantee it.
 

boncer34

Inaugural Steward
Joined
Jul 11, 2005
Posts
40,461
Likes
40,226
Location
Baghdad
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Melbourne Storm
I own the business that offered to put the money up, the Age reporter who interviewed Foggy (a ripping bloke by the way) is a friend of mine and the person instrumental in getting everything organised, printed and delivered is a business associate. So yeah, I can guarantee it.
Gone from many to a couple.

Cool.
 
Joined
Sep 2, 2008
Posts
46,976
Likes
26,053
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Essendon
So yeah. I went from helping orchestrate (in a very minor way as Simeon and Nick did a power of work but I did make the original offer to finance it) stand by Hird to being extremely happy to see the back of James Hird once I was fully informed.

It is a she, Madeline Heffernan and normally she writes for the business section.
Oh my bad.
 

DERO

NOBODY PUTS BABY IN THE CORNER
Joined
Jan 22, 2013
Posts
12,221
Likes
16,165
Location
The Ivory Tower
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Mitcham FC
Thought I had deleted that. Ha ha.

You guys can think what you like and that is fair enough but I can honestly say my opinion on J Hird changed abruptly when I became better informed. FWIW, I have heard everyone from past premiership captains to fathers of current players that initially supported SBH (one actually signed a metal version at Windy Hill) who are happy that he is no longer there. Make of that what you will.
 

sameolds33

Premiership Player
Joined
Feb 11, 2016
Posts
4,137
Likes
2,508
AFL Club
Essendon
Those sorts of banners are exactly the reason we are a laughing stock and will be used (successfully) to highlight how far some Essendon supporters have their heads up their arses. It is embarrassing. Accept we did something wrong and move on. It is possible to still support the players while you are doing that.
The players still say they are innocent. They were there. Fine if you don't think they are but also fine for other supporters to believe them.
 

Bombermania

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Dec 18, 2007
Posts
8,102
Likes
4,010
Location
Counting premiership cups
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Non that play Essendon
Thought I had deleted that. Ha ha.

You guys can think what you like and that is fair enough but I can honestly say my opinion on J Hird changed abruptly when I became better informed. FWIW, I have heard everyone from past premiership captains to fathers of current players that initially supported SBH (one actually signed a metal version at Windy Hill) who are happy that he is no longer there. Make of that what you will.
I think I am in the same boat as you, I love Hirdy as a player but there are aspects of the evidence which just doesn't sit right, I ask myself the question, if this saga was at another club would I be defending it sticking the boot in and the answer is sticking the boot in just based on the evidence put forward by the club and people around the club.
 

DERO

NOBODY PUTS BABY IN THE CORNER
Joined
Jan 22, 2013
Posts
12,221
Likes
16,165
Location
The Ivory Tower
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Mitcham FC
I think I am in the same boat as you, I love Hirdy as a player but there are aspects of the evidence which just doesn't sit right, I ask myself the question, if this saga was at another club would I be defending it sticking the boot in and the answer is sticking the boot in just based on the evidence put forward by the club and people around the club.
Hird was an amazing player... My only extremely slight criticism is that he was always was just a little bit unaccountable.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Bombermania

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Dec 18, 2007
Posts
8,102
Likes
4,010
Location
Counting premiership cups
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Non that play Essendon
The players still say they are innocent. They were there. Fine if you don't think they are but also fine for other supporters to believe them.
I think there are two difference issues, the players clearly didn't set out to chest but there was a program put in place that had Hird's full support, we only need to see some of the emails put forward. Hirdy appeared to be close to Dank the Wank and still seems to hold a positive view of him.

I judge people by their actions more than their words and some of Hirdy's actions seem questionable.
 

Bombermania

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Dec 18, 2007
Posts
8,102
Likes
4,010
Location
Counting premiership cups
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Non that play Essendon
There is a difference between being guilty and being adjudged guilty. There's no two ways about that.
WADA have an ironclad rule that the sports person controls what goes into their body and whilst I understand that and most here would however it is in effect taking a sledgehammer to a walnut yet this same body has been found wanting in regards to athletics and doping. Just pathetic.

Also where was the outrage last summer when Serena Williams called for a coffee mid-way though a match, nothing just crickets, now I am not saying she should have been punished but the twelve month suspension is rubbish.
 

60sbomber

Club Legend
Joined
Jul 4, 2011
Posts
1,732
Likes
1,868
Location
Frankston
AFL Club
Essendon
I suspect quietly many have lost some respect over what has happened, I know many here and at the Blitz are still defending Hird but I suspect most of it is purely down to his time as a player.

This is why Hirdy and the club taking a break from one another for a short period of time whilst the club focusing on rebuilding might be in the best interest of everyone in the medium to longer term.
That is revisionist nonsense. By revisionist, I mean that you are re-evaluating Hird in the light of the guilty verdict handed down to the players.
I said a very long time ago that the final outcome would be determined by legalisms (definition of burden of proof, willingness of CAS to make assumptions etc etc), and that how Hird acted, and how the players acted, should not be judged by what is the final outcome.
And it is true.
Hird did no wrong. The players did no wrong. The fact that CAS found the players guilty says a lot about the WADA code, and what WADA and CAS combined found necessary and desirable to guard against future potential drug use by a sporting team. It does NOT, in my estimation, give me cause to revise what I believe the players, and Hird, are, and that is innocent victims of a dubious, and possibly deceitful program run by Robinson and Dank.

My respect for Hird remains. I actually respect him more than I did as a player as a result of how he has conducted himself over the last 3 years.
Hird and the club are taking a break from each other because of the answer to the question that Hird asked prior to his relinquishing the coaching position, which was "Do you think that the club will ever be treated fairly while I am coach?". The answer was "No".
The general public will try to revise this to Hird leaving in disgrace. He didn't. He left because the public, the press, and the AFL made it impossible for the club to get "clean air" as long as he was still there, such was their need to blame him.

So don't include me when you say many have lost respect for him over what has happened. I think I have a very good understanding of what has happened.
 

60sbomber

Club Legend
Joined
Jul 4, 2011
Posts
1,732
Likes
1,868
Location
Frankston
AFL Club
Essendon
. Unfortunately those on the outside think we look silly because of this and I am inclined to agree. Taking a "not guilty" banner to a march in support of our banned players is a stupid idea as they are not innocent.
I don't care who thinks we look silly.
I am long past appeasing opposition clubs, opposition supporters, and media critics.
The players have been found guilty, but they are not guilty.
It is hard for those who have a respect for the legal process to understand this attitude.
What you should try to remember is that the legal processes you respect and abide by are not what was used to bring down the guilty verdict on these players.
The process used was the WADA code, and the outcome of its process is very much short of justice, and what a court would find.
It is the misfortune of the players that they were never able to have access to a proper court and a proper process of hearing the case, using the legal principles you and others respect. Had they been able to, they most certainly would not have been found guilty.
So don't transfer the respect you have for the legal system and its findings to what has happened to the players here.
The players ARE innocent, no matter what WADA and CAS have found.

I think a "not guilty" banner at the march is the very essence of what is required.
I am marching, not only because I support the club and its endeavours to move on from what has been imposed on it, but because I believe the players have been victimised, wrongly, very wrongly, and I want them to know that I believe this, and that there are thousands of Essendon supporters out there who believe their suspensions are wrong, not just that we sympathise, and will accept them back after they have done their time.
 

scythe

Club Legend
Joined
Apr 11, 2011
Posts
1,409
Likes
956
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Auburn Tigers, Newcastle United
I don't care who thinks we look silly.
I am long past appeasing opposition clubs, opposition supporters, and media critics.
The players have been found guilty, but they are not guilty.
It is hard for those who have a respect for the legal process to understand this attitude.
What you should try to remember is that the legal processes you respect and abide by are not what was used to bring down the guilty verdict on these players.
The process used was the WADA code, and the outcome of its process is very much short of justice, and what a court would find.
It is the misfortune of the players that they were never able to have access to a proper court and a proper process of hearing the case, using the legal principles you and others respect. Had they been able to, they most certainly would not have been found guilty.
So don't transfer the respect you have for the legal system and its findings to what has happened to the players here.
The players ARE innocent, no matter what WADA and CAS have found.

I think a "not guilty" banner at the march is the very essence of what is required.
I am marching, not only because I support the club and its endeavours to move on from what has been imposed on it, but because I believe the players have been victimised, wrongly, very wrongly, and I want them to know that I believe this, and that there are thousands of Essendon supporters out there who believe their suspensions are wrong, not just that we sympathise, and will accept them back after they have done their time.
Agreed. Dero, I can respect your stance, but I can't get on board with it. I feel strongly enough about the players' innocence that I wouldn't be doing due diligence by failing to take an opportunity to stand up and say something, regardless of what anyone else thinks. In the words of a great man: here I stand, I can do no other.

And in the interests of refraining from derailing this thread any further, I'll leave it at that.

EDIT: Looks like this whole conversation got moved to where it should be. Doss, would you do the honours.
 

Bombermania

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Dec 18, 2007
Posts
8,102
Likes
4,010
Location
Counting premiership cups
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Non that play Essendon
That is revisionist nonsense. By revisionist, I mean that you are re-evaluating Hird in the light of the guilty verdict handed down to the players.
I said a very long time ago that the final outcome would be determined by legalisms (definition of burden of proof, willingness of CAS to make assumptions etc etc), and that how Hird acted, and how the players acted, should not be judged by what is the final outcome.
And it is true.
Hird did no wrong. The players did no wrong. The fact that CAS found the players guilty says a lot about the WADA code, and what WADA and CAS combined found necessary and desirable to guard against future potential drug use by a sporting team. It does NOT, in my estimation, give me cause to revise what I believe the players, and Hird, are, and that is innocent victims of a dubious, and possibly deceitful program run by Robinson and Dank.

My respect for Hird remains. I actually respect him more than I did as a player as a result of how he has conducted himself over the last 3 years.
Hird and the club are taking a break from each other because of the answer to the question that Hird asked prior to his relinquishing the coaching position, which was "Do you think that the club will ever be treated fairly while I am coach?". The answer was "No".
The general public will try to revise this to Hird leaving in disgrace. He didn't. He left because the public, the press, and the AFL made it impossible for the club to get "clean air" as long as he was still there, such was their need to blame him.

So don't include me when you say many have lost respect for him over what has happened. I think I have a very good understanding of what has happened.

I am judging Hirdy on how he has conducted himself based on his interviews and the evidence which I admit hasn't always been fully covered by the dears in the media.

I agree with you that the players are innocence but my issue with Hirdy isn't so much about quilt but rather the way he explains things, he has claimed that he will tell the full story yet what I have heard comes across as questionable and at times little more than buck passing and most damming of all he seems to hold a positive view of Dank the Wank, now if I was in his shoes, no way would I have a nice word to say about Dank the Wank.

The players were found guilty due in large part to the view of WADA & CAS that the sports person is fully and totally responsible for what is in their body, regardless of circumstances, this is largely to combat the East German athletics and Chinese swimmers scenario and totally ignores the nature of AFL clubs.
 

EnolaGay

Premiership Player
Joined
Oct 2, 2012
Posts
3,971
Likes
6,019
Location
Adelaide
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Boston Celtics, Miami Dolphins
I am still of the opinion that the James Hird Academy needs to be renamed - It's a bad look for the club.
Agreed - how about "The Dean & Steve Academy for Kids That Need to Grow Massively Unnaturally Quickly"?
 

efcboy

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Oct 2, 2007
Posts
10,178
Likes
7,767
Location
Essendon
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Arsenal
The March is a waste of time and money. The organisers are advising potential participants to not stand by their belief that the players are innocent. What a joke.

This year is a gap year. Forget what anybody else says - they just want bums on seats and income. And they want us the mug supporters to cough up the money.

I'd advise everyone to stand for what you believe in. Anything else and you are wasting your time and money.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom