No Opposition Supporters CAS hands down guilty verdict - Players appealing - Dank shot - no opposition - (cont in pt.2)

Status
Not open for further replies.

vaughany

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Mar 23, 2002
Posts
10,373
Likes
4,938
AFL Club
Essendon
Not a ridiculous concept at all. If you're already a fringe player like, say, Tayte Pears and then you cop two years on the sidelines- it'd be hard to see him getting back. That's basically his AFL career done.
Fair enough about players like Pears...maybe I'm delusional but I haven't accepted that players will potentially get bans. Simply can't fathom it. If bans were placed upon our players the legal team surely would fight it?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Jade

Smug lives here.
Joined
Jul 8, 2008
Posts
32,928
Likes
48,353
AFL Club
Essendon
Fair enough about players like Pears...maybe I'm delusional but I haven't accepted that players will potentially get bans. Simply can't fathom it. If bans were placed upon our players the legal team surely would fight it?
My opinion is close to yours. I simply can't see how a successful ban sticks - the case is far too flimsy.
 

Doss

Super Moderator
Joined
Aug 1, 2011
Posts
70,952
Likes
96,306
AFL Club
Essendon
Thread starter Admin #22,129
There is no way known any Essendon player will be banned. Absolutely no way. This will fizzle out with a whimper, not end with a bang. I'm not sure how this talk of 2 year bans and Infraction notices has crept back in to the possible scenarios but it is not going to happen.
Right now it's still a possible scenario. I don't think it's especially likely, but until this court business is sorted, we really cannot say for sure that we're in the clear.

Obviously, it goes without saying that I hope we are and that all this talk is moot. Null and void.

Fair enough about players like Pears...maybe I'm delusional but I haven't accepted that players will potentially get bans. Simply can't fathom it. If bans were placed upon our players the legal team surely would fight it?
I'm sure they'd fight it. It'd get very messy indeed.
 

caboose

Club Legend
Joined
Jun 3, 2007
Posts
2,562
Likes
1,393
Location
At home
AFL Club
Essendon
It's not just about Hird. It's the entire football department, of which Hird is only a part.
And Hird is the "part" (if you want to put it that way) who has already been given a suspension. Others haven't received one. My comments above singled out Hird precisely on that basis - and I'm really not sure how that's not bleedingly obvious, to be honest.

And who is claiming he's suffered no penalty?
There are numerous posts on here that would have you believe he still potentially needs to take a personal whack for something many of us would argue that he's minimally responsible for, at worst ie effectively disregarding the point that he's already copped a major penalty that he shouldn't have.

I might be getting you confused with somebody else as I've got a poor connection ATM and can't be bothered trawling through the thread. But I'm pretty sure it was actually you who said something like "the club will have no credibility if the players are sidelined while the coaches hang around". Well, sorry, but in case you hadn't noticed, our senior coach has already been sidelined while all the players and other coaches have 'hung around'.
 
Joined
Mar 25, 2007
Posts
34,705
Likes
18,586
Location
Bottom of the pack
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Arsenal
There is no way known any Essendon player will be banned. Absolutely no way. This will fizzle out with a whimper, not end with a bang. I'm not sure how this talk of 2 year bans and Infraction notices has crept back in to the possible scenarios but it is not going to happen.
People getting sucked into the sheer weight of knobgobbler bullshit from Barrett and co.

Nothing's changed.
 

84859300

Premiership Player
Joined
Nov 5, 2010
Posts
3,016
Likes
3,926
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Packers, Bucks, Pens, M's, Chelsea
People getting sucked into the sheer weight of knobgobbler bullshit from Barrett and co.

Nothing's changed.
I hear you Ben, but this is a two horse race and funnier things have transpired when it comes to dealing with the law.

The points I raised against Harlequin's post was just trying to provide balance to her points. I think, above all else, all Essendon supporters are of the wish that no action takes place and that we are found to clear of all charges and accusations.

But as much as the HTB is 100% certain that we will receive infractions, without seeing reason...I don't think that anyone on this side of the fence should be 100% certain of a clear outcome either.
 

cymarak

Go Gators !
Joined
Aug 7, 2009
Posts
2,977
Likes
4,007
Location
Over it. All of it.
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
49ers, Gators
There is no way known any Essendon player will be banned. Absolutely no way. This will fizzle out with a whimper, not end with a bang. I'm not sure how this talk of 2 year bans and Infraction notices has crept back in to the possible scenarios but it is not going to happen.
Last year the idea of us being kicked out of the finals was debated at length, ridiculed and derided. Until it happened...

Then we bent over for 'governance' and many were certain that was the end of the matter. Until it wasn't...

The moral of the story - as a group, we don't have a strong record in accurately predicting what will happen, especially as there are forces and agendas at play we don't understand / don't know about.
 
Last edited:

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Joined
Mar 25, 2007
Posts
34,705
Likes
18,586
Location
Bottom of the pack
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Arsenal
Last year the idea of us being kicked out the finals was debated at length, ridiculed and derided. Until it happened...

Then we bent over for 'governance' and many were certain that was the end of the matter. Until it wasn't...

The moral of the story - as a group, we don't have a strong record in accurately predicting what will happen, especially as there are forces and agendas at play we don't understand / don't know about.
This time we're dealing with actual courts and things like laws and evidence and justice and stuff. Revolutionary concepts for certain organisations I know, but such are the times.
 

DapperDon

Waiting for Essendon to arrive
Joined
Oct 4, 2006
Posts
29,533
Likes
43,589
AFL Club
Essendon
That's the threat they've used in the past. The government then forces the unrelated codes, NRL & AFL, etc, to sign up, threatening a withdrawel of federal funding.

Everyone makes threats down the chain.

EDIT: It was originally in a brendan schwab article that my phone isn't letting me link for some, typically annoying phone reason. Was from the Age. Should be easy to google.
This is simple enough to get by on, Australia sue WADA for blackmail and wala, WADA crawl back into their holes.
 

2one2

Premiership Player
Joined
May 30, 2012
Posts
3,441
Likes
5,224
AFL Club
Essendon
Just like they have 13000 emails and text messages and the ones worth leaking are 4 or 5 including "sounds good m8" and "you know my thoughts on supplements etc"

We have a lot of the full picture. If judge Downes thinks they can work some magic with their TB4 case, well okay then, but I think we've seen most of what there is. The sadists on the HTB seem to think they are keeping some sort of secret weapons as some sort of game with the players, that it's going to be more than TB4 etc

All pretty laughable. In summary, yeah there's not much more evidence
 

IggypopsTshirt

Premiership Player
Joined
Jun 27, 2013
Posts
3,300
Likes
8,304
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
NYGiants NYRangers Yankees
As I have said before, what was done remains the same, irrespective of the outcome of the SC/INs.

The case against the players will be decided by legalities.

The outcome of those legalities etc in no way enlarges or diminishes what Hird, Thompson, Goodwin, Reid etc have done or are responsible for.

You should judge how you view their roles now, and not let the final outcome distract you.

If the players get off, it doesn't make anyone more innocent, it just means we dodged a bullet based on the legalities. If the players are suspended, it doesn't make anyone more guilty, it just means we got done on the legalities.

In my view, Hird is innocent of all wrongdoing. He has the character, loyalty and competence of a leader that is rare, and not to be discarded, and the club owes him a huge debt of gratitude for what he has borne on its behalf for the last 12 months.

There is no way I can accept that we should have some sort of clean out, for the sake of appeasing the masses, or even for the sake of making a new start, when that would mean sacrificing those who have stood tall and done so much for our club through this crisis.

FFS show some solidarity and strength of character, and support Hird, Thompson and all those at the club who have steered us through this to the best of their ability.
Let me say firstly that I'm happy for Hird to return because I don't believe players will receive IN's.

BUT......

How on earth can the outcome not be important? If it is found players were administered normal saline and Dank ripped the club off, everyone apologises and we move forward unscathed. That is a very different scenario from Dank not being aware of the updated status of TB4 and the subsequent inadvertent doping of our entire list while keeping the head coach informed every step of the way. The fallout from this would be catastrophic for the EFC.

Whether you like it or not; If it is established that the head coach of a football club was actively involved with the sports science program that resulted in numerous players being administered banned substances and subsequently banned from competition for 2 years and the head coach was kept updated in meetings and via text message of the progress of the program; that coach will no longer have a job irrespective of whether his name is James Hird, Jesus Christ or Idi Amin. It really is as simple as that.

If the players are banned the club is gone. Financially ruined. Onfield prospects will be smashed for a decade at least. The EFC reputation ruined and name forever tainted. Our sponsors will jump ship immediately. Yet the outcome is immaterial? WTAF??
If this unlikely set of circumstances eventuate, anyone who has played a part in the destruction of the club should be publicly flogged for their role in the debacle.

I support the Essendon footy club, not individuals. It gives the "cult" accusations weight when we have people willing to watch the players go down but happy to have those who contributed to their downfall maintain their positions. It won't matter who the coach is if the worst outcome occurs, the team and club will be beyond salvage.
 
Joined
Jul 7, 2013
Posts
10,780
Likes
17,739
Location
Margaritaville
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Liverpool FC
Moderator #22,144
Some others disagree. They see it not as Hird accepting 'full responsibility'...more Hird accepting some responsibility.



There's no trust in business, unless you work with family and even then; that'd debatable. The governance issue has raised that there should have been many more checks in place by many more people for this to function correctly. The fact that we don't have facts x, y and z to slap on the table to nip the drama in the bud, is some of the main frustrations by supporters.



You're right, there was an email that stated this. But there was also another email asking people to use their UN skills to keep Dr Reid at bay. This could be seen as ambiguous.



Granted. But neither were Wallis, Hamilton and the rest. They have been put off for the poor processes in the club. People are questioning on how some go, but others stay. Falling on the sword can be honorable, but it can only hide sins of others for so long.
I agree with your points.

I am of the opinion that opinion pieces as in Phatprick, KB, Caro, Dumien etc have muddied the waters.

They want a scapegoat and James Hird is the head they want. Why who the **** really knows.

I don't want to be part of a Club that burns it's staff whether they be the CEO or the person that washes our kits.

But I do want this to end. As does everybody here.
I want this to end with no further collateral damage.

Our boys have had enough
 

cymarak

Go Gators !
Joined
Aug 7, 2009
Posts
2,977
Likes
4,007
Location
Over it. All of it.
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
49ers, Gators
Let's all keep in mind that whether players are suspended or not does not prove whether doping did or did not occur - it may just be decided on the basis of who has the better legal / PR team.

Using the overall outcome of this process to judge actions - rather than directly judging the actions themselves - is flawed IMHO.
 

The Prosecutor

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 13, 2011
Posts
9,379
Likes
11,409
AFL Club
Essendon
Let's all keep in mind that whether players are suspended or not does not prove whether doping did or did not occur - it may just be decided on the basis of who has the better legal / PR team.

Using the overall outcome of this process to judge actions - rather than directly judging the actions themselves - is flawed IMHO.
As opposed to what? Ignoring two years suspensions, Hird's noted complicity, Hird 'accepting' that he has to take responsibility and that Hird ultimately was very much in a position of responsibility for the players?

Deciding based upon the outcome of a thorough investigation that culminates in a hearing is far from a flawed process. If that is, then everything is flawed and can't be judged
 

rumply

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Apr 11, 2002
Posts
16,758
Likes
16,364
Location
Under Her Eye
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Iggles, 76ers
Highly doubt there is any 'smoking gun'/'secret weapon' or other such gob smacking evidence that ASADA are sitting on. Their late move to obtain affidavits from some witnesses & gather further evidence(lol) from the Mckenzie interview with Dank only helped reinforce that their case is purely a circumstantial one & one which should not be enough to secure IN's going by what is known about ADVRP evidence requirements.
 
Last edited:

scottmclaren

All Australian
Joined
Aug 23, 2013
Posts
654
Likes
757
AFL Club
Essendon
Bullshit.

Just because you haven't seen their briefs doesn't mean no evidence exists.
Chances of more damning evidence existing is so small it's essentially bullshit. If you've read everything in the public domain then the most likely state of affairs is not much has changed since last August.

ASADA has stated as much in the Federal court already.
 

pepsi

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Feb 4, 2008
Posts
10,298
Likes
9,941
Location
Maribyrnong
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Man Utd, Atlanta Hawks
The NFL are a very dodgy organisation (see their suppression of concussion research recently) but this is one thing they're certainly better on. The problem is that Australia isn't a big enough country in WADA's eyes for us to get away with telling them to bugger off. America is, and thus can. WADA threatens our government with exclusion from the Olympics if national sports don't sign to the code. They can't do that wirh Amercia, because the olympics without America would be a farce.
I think that is a huge downfall of American sports/FIFA.

How many NBA, NFL players and players playing in epl, la liga, bundesliga have been found guilty of doping in the last 5 years.

Would not surprise me if the number is less than 10.

And considering those leagues pretty much have the most money and prestige associated with them, there is a huge amount to be gained from enhancing ones performance.

American sport is littered with performance enhancing use in my opinion, but gets completely swept under the carpet, nothing to see here etc.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom