Cats v Hawks: Who is in trouble?

[BF Tiger]

Lewis on Selwood, very early, behind play and only shown on replay at quarter time?

Motlop on Mitchell, ran through him with a little force I the first quarter?

Hodge on Selwood, was it 3/4 time, punch in the ribs/kidneys on the back?

Ruggles tummy tap on Rioli, or Rioli for staging, in the third quarter?

Anything else?

 

[Liger]

Lewis on Selwood, very early, behind play and only shown on replay at quarter time?

Motlop on Mitchell, ran through him with a little force I the first quarter?

Hodge on Selwood, was it 3/4 time, punch in the ribs/kidneys on the back?

Ruggles tummy tap on Rioli, or Rioli for staging, in the third quarter?

Anything else?

Lewis - one week, hawk allowance and finals = fine
Hodge - top bloke = what punch?
Ruggles - Rioli gets a certificate from the Lindsey Thomas School of Acting

 

[Skeppersap]

Lewis should be a guaranteed suspension. How many did Selwood get for a similar incident against Guerra? 4 weeks? Guerra played the next match too!

But...................its all good.......Mark Evans!

 

[Skeppersap]

Would love to see someone post the Selwood - Guerra and the Lewis - Selwood incident side by side.

He must go for that strike!

 

[Willo_]

Wouldn't expect any suspensions

Maybe a fine to Lewis and Ruggles?

 

[Seedsfan]

Lewis and Hodge should get one, but they won't

 

[Desslok]

Sam Mitchell appeared to strike Scott Selwood in the face down in the members pocket early in the 2nd half. Was at the game .. did they catch that one on the coverage? (was at the game)

 

[Micksy]

More of a pushing action.

 

[BF Tiger]

Sam Mitchell appeared to strike Scott Selwood in the face down in the members pocket early in the 2nd half. Was at the game .. did they catch that one on the coverage? (was at the game)

More of a pushing action.

And open handed? With insufficient force?

 

[Micksy]

And open handed? With insufficient force?

In play and an unavoidable part of contested footy.

 

[Bonkers000]

I know it was a head clash but the bump selwood gave to hodge in the first was enough to make hodge leave the ground bleeding. Could be looked at.

 

[TBoyleSuperstar]

No one. Little in any of them, so move on. Fines at most.

The Niggle and the hits added to the theatre of the game. No one got hurt, you move on.

 

[HairyO]

I know it was a head clash but the bump selwood gave to hodge in the first was enough to make hodge leave the ground bleeding. Could be looked at.

And Burgoyne on Porko. Both will be unavoidable collisions.

 

[winty]

Lewis on Selwood, very early, behind play and only shown on replay at quarter time?

Motlop on Mitchell, ran through him with a little force I the first quarter?

Hodge on Selwood, was it 3/4 time, punch in the ribs/kidneys on the back?

Ruggles tummy tap on Rioli, or Rioli for staging, in the third quarter?

Anything else?

Wasn't the only kidney punch Hodge dished out last night. Gave one to Hawkins after Blicavs' goal in the 3rd quarter too.

 

[GreyCrow]

No blood #PlayOn

 

[The A Team Van]

Who watches that game of footy and comes away from it wanting people suspended for minor niggles?

 

[LongBomb]

Why does Hodge always hit blokes with their back turned?

 

[TBoyleSuperstar]

Why does Hodge always hit blokes with their back turned?

Just following the precedent that Motlop set with the kidney punch on Mitchell early in the 1st?

I'm not a fan of the hit from behind, it's hardly tough. But there were plenty of times it happened last night from both sides. Heaps of niggle.

 

[McOrist]

Sam Mitchell appeared to strike Scott Selwood in the face down in the members pocket early in the 2nd half. Was at the game .. did they catch that one on the coverage? (was at the game)

I was in that part of the ground and saw it too -surprised it hasn't been mentioned before this.
Probably won't go much further due to the Hawthorn 'insufficient force' rule.

 

[Mningasimisonda]

There were niggles, but nothing that stood out as being outright reportable. I'd be happy if they just let it go this week. It was tough contest and great spectacle, but not overly dirty, so why make reports to discourage that?

 

[Paul Kersey]

Look, it's the weekly Geelong nutcase fan Hawthorn MRP rant thread.

 

[Gavin Excell]

Look, it's the weekly Geelong nutcase fan Hawthorn MRP rant thread.

Yeah its great

 

[asanque]

Who watches that game of footy and comes away from it wanting people suspended for minor niggles?

Complete flogs. Easily identified in this thread.

 

[giggler99]

Lewis may get a week, depending in what mood the MRP are in I wouldn't be surprised he escapes with a fine. The footage shown is very grainy, would like to see another angle.

The rest should all be cleared or at worse cop a small fine.

 

[Wild Bill]

Just saw the ruggles punch. Not sure how he dosen't get a week. The precedent has been set with stomach punches.