Chances round 1 debutants

[Ray Donovan]

With the season fast approaching and our second JLT hitout another good side in Adelaide up next?

Are we seeing any yet to debut firming or chances for round 1?

I really like parfitt although with an experienced squad and the speed of early season rounds seems like a more outside chance ?

Tom Stewart another

 

[catempire]

Nil - $1.20
Stewart - $3
Any other - $20

Assuming no significant injuries.

 

[bulletproof]

Nil - $1.20
Stewart - $3
Any other - $20

Assuming no significant injuries.

A price for just Zach Guthrie please?

 

[catempire]

A price for just for Zach Guthrie please?

You've zeroed in on the smokey I like so I can't do better than $25.

He was $1000 before JLT #1.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Big trip to Perth for R1, I'd say the only possibility JLT form pending is Stewart. All others not for a big interstate trip.

 

[BORIS332]

Club debutants: Zach Tuohy & Aaron Black.

League debutants: no one, but best chances are Cunico, Stewart, Parfitt (in that order).

 

[you pick one]

Nil - $1.20
Stewart - $3
Any other - $20

Assuming no significant injuries.

Just to get a bead on Stewart what prices Bews, Mackie and Thurlow for rd1?

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Club debutants will be tuohy and maybe black.

In terms of 0 gamers i think the only one a genuine chance is stewart although we have a lot of competition for defender spots.

I like zach guthrie but i think he will need to wait a bit.

 

[catempire]

Just to get a bead on Stewart what prices Bews, Mackie and Thurlow for rd1?

$2, $1.20 and $2

 

[you pick one]

$2, $1.20 and $2

Yeah all fit it will be tough for Stewart first up to break in to the side ,no bad think though he'll get his chance at some stage if not rd1

 

[ChookNorris]

Waybill

 

[Turbocat]

I think we need to check back after the JLT is finished. There are spots there if someone can perform above the norm. Not to mention , injuries can occur.

At this stage my bet would be zero afl debutants.

 

[Ray Donovan]

B. A.Mackie T.Lonergan J.Kolodashnij
H.B .Z.Tuohy L.Henderson J.Thurlow
C. M.Duncan J.Selwood. C.Guthrie
HF. Motlop. Taylor. Menzel
F. Mcarthy Hawkins Lang
Foll. Smith. Dangerfield. Menegola
Inter. Blicavs Stanley Cockatoo
S.Selwood

Emg. T.Ruggles A.Black. J.Cowan

T.Stewart. Parfitt. Bews Z.Guthrie

I have them rated for rd 1 something along the lines of this.

Mackie - questionable ( ruggles ) Stewart

Black. - in conversation jlt form ?
If he is in does Stanley, Lonergan, Smith who misses Blic or extra tall in ?

S.Selwood - no lock injury wise ( Cowan, parfitt) Z.Guthrie

C.Guthrie ( calf ) - bews - Cowan - GHS

Realistically injury or incredible jlt form will push in I might have a nibble for $10 on parfitt just I case a menzel, McCarthy doesn't come up or selwood

 

[Ray Donovan]

Club debutants: Zach Tuohy & Aaron Black.

League debutants: no one, but best chances are Cunico, Stewart, Parfitt (in that order).

Cunico interesting saw a bit of vfl last season keen to see more

 

[Biggy_Boy]

I don't think any kids should be in the round 1 lineup unless significant injuries pile up between now and R1. If the side is serious about contending for a flag, then young players should really have to be producing at a high standard to earn a spot.

 

[David the Cat]

2e, Black and Stewart....for Round 1

Parfitt, Gardner, ...maybe ZGuthrie, Narkle....and Jones!!! (biased view) to get exposure later on in the season......

Outsiders......Abbott, House and Cunico in reverse order...

 

[Hamingja]

League debutants: no one, but best chances are Cunico, Stewart, Parfitt (in that order).

I have more chance debuting round 1 than Cunico.....

 

[goyoucatters]

I have more chance debuting round 1 than Cunico.....

Welcome to our board, Tom Stewart!

 

[Partridge]

Think if it's anyone I'd nominate Parfitt.

Stewart to me has too much competition ahead of him for that part of the ground.

 

[BORIS332]

I have more chance debuting round 1 than Cunico.....

Hence why I said "no one."

 

[Ray Donovan]

Think if it's anyone I'd nominate Parfitt.

Stewart to me has too much competition ahead of him for that part of the ground.

From what I saw Mackie is still light years in front in that taller utility role and can play multiple positions. Forward wing and I don't even know if Mackie is in

 

[David the Cat]

From what I saw Mackie is still light years in front in that taller utility role and can play multiple positions. Forward wing and I don't even know if Mackie is in

After his 20 + possessions and 10 marks last week, he's likely to be picked early on. Seemed to be playing the sweeping role rather than hard defensive role...be interesting to see if he can bring enough to the table this year.

 

[Hamingja]

Hence why I said "no one."

Yeah but you had Cunico as more of a chance than Stewart or Parfitt.

I'd favour no debutants at this point too but Stewart and Parfitt would both have a chance if they play well in the next two pre season games while Cunico I'd give buckleys.

 

[Hamingja]

Stewart to me has too much competition ahead of him for that part of the ground.

Since they aren't playing Bews as defender it might come down to Stewart v Ruggles for a spot. Not impossible for Stewart to overtake Ruggles in the next couple of pre season games, he'd want to play a lot better than against the Hawks mind you.

 

[David the Cat]

Since they aren't playing Bews as defender it might come down to Stewart v Ruggles for a spot. Not impossible for Stewart to overtake Ruggles in the next couple of pre season games, he'd want to play a lot better than against the Hawks mind you.

Actually, I thought Stewart was pretty good v Hawthorn.

Yes...a couple of horrendous errors that cost us goals, and ultimately the win ...but he'll learn from that and hopefully a little counseling from Scarlo and the kid will re-set.

Will be watching him and Ruggles closely v Adelaide. I hope Eddie is playing to really test them out...