Prediction Changes for Collingwood - Rd 19

[PAFC66]

Marshall isn't fit to tie Hoff's bootlaces.

Don't @ me Marshall lovers.

Remember how s**t Tom Hawkins was for years... Let's have some hope

 

[TeeKray]

Remember how sh*t Tom Hawkins was for years... Let's have some hope

Hawkins had his breakout game in the 2011 grand final, the end of his 5th season. He kicked 62 goals and was AA/B&F the next year. It's Marshall's 5th season as we speak ...

 

[Sleezy]

McKenzie will play on De Goey and make him his b*tch for a second time, just like he made a second King brother his b*tch last week.

Nah, De Goey's a mid now donchyaknow? It'll be Wines that rips him to shreds this time.

 

[afl2004]

Hawkins had his breakout game in the 2011 grand final, the end of his 5th season. He kicked 62 goals and was AA/B&F the next year. It's Marshall's 5th season as we speak ...

he was in a generational team with peds and did he deal with he parents dying?

 

[MALTSY]

You’d think if Hartlett, Orazio and Robbie get back in before finals (with no more injuries touch wood)- Bonner and Woodcock, and probably Ladhams will be the ones out anyway - so whether Lienert plays or not now probs doesn’t matter.

Edit/ and Motlop


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

What about the Jones boy?

 

[Powerade 08]

Hawkins had his breakout game in the 2011 grand final, the end of his 5th season. He kicked 62 goals and was AA/B&F the next year. It's Marshall's 5th season as we speak ...

Also Hawkins was a late bloomer. Most good key forwards have a breakout year i.e. 50 goals+ in their 3rd or 4th season.

McKay and B.King doing it this year, Georgiades and the other King are probably next up.

 

[TeeKray]

he was in a generational team with peds and did he deal with he parents dying?

His mother actually did die but it was a little later in his career ...

 

[Astronema]

Godd Marshall is undroppable, die mad nerds

 

[yepits2020]

So a defender and a guy in his debut game? You couldn't have proven my point better if you tried.

Sorry. I need to learn how to make it obvious I am showing sarcasm. But I take your point about Collingwood,s forwards, but still ……

 

[chiwigi]

Unpopular opinion but I don’t think Mayes is a good choice as sub. I think a higher intensity player like McEntee is a better pick - Hartlett would be ideal in the role as we get closer to finals.

Mayes seems to struggle with the pace of the game when he comes on. His goal against Sydney was an awesome moment but if Lloyd had held a simple mark we would have all been lamenting how easily Mayes was pushed out of that contest.

He’s (Mayes) an awful choice as sub. No stand out features at all and not particularly good anywhere.
A worse choice is Frederick as sub!

Now, if you’re talking Hartlett or Marshall I’m listening.

Marshall is perfect sub material!

 

[power09]

Bad luck to the Marshall haters.

well we all lose

 

[Daylight2nd]

Bonners going to stay in the side isn’t he? Don’t care if he had one good game (out of many) last week, this guy isn’t in our ideal team come finals and needs to make way for someone who’ll improve the team, especially with finals so close

that game against Melb, when he was dropped, and back "7" was Jonas, McKenzie, Burton, Clurey, Aliir, DBJ and Lienert, gave him yet another reprieve.

the ball movement from defence was awful in that game.

for team balance it's now fairly clear there has to be some "attacking flair" in the back lines. Bonner and Bergman are now the incumbents, but agree Bonner's well documented defensive weaknesses would be a concern, come finals.

Who's going to put their hand up to replace him? Lachie Jones? Hartlett?

Ideally it's Houston, in my opinion, assuming he's no longer needed in midfield. It's a shame he hasn't been at his best since shoulder injury - he's clearly carrying the injury (until post season surgery?)