Opinion Changes for next week vs GW$

[Dez!]

Why take guys out who are in form, just for the sake of changes... Frawley, Watts, Gysberts, should be the only possibly changes.
Recon Moloney, Sylvia would be the only ones who were well below the standards set by Neeld.

It's not for the sake of changes, it's rather simple.

- I'd prefer somebody that can damage the opposition whereas Joel MacDonald simply cannot.
- I don't know about you but I'd prefer Frawley at full back than Dunn.
- No point having Magner in the team if he's just going to be the sub, let him play full games at Casey.
- Bate doesn't have a future at Melbourne, too slow for the midfield and not big enough up forward.

By all means list your ins and outs then all-knowing one.

 

[Blackas87]

In: Gysberts, Couch, Frawley, Fitzpatrick
Out: Magner, Moloney, Bail, Bate

Would like to see Watts, Nicholson and Martin come in but a game at Casey first.

 

[Demon 16]

In: Couch, Evans, Gysberts
Out: Bate, Bail, Magner

 

[SPC 98]

It's not for the sake of changes, it's rather simple.

- I'd prefer somebody that can damage the opposition whereas Joel MacDonald simply cannot.
- I don't know about you but I'd prefer Frawley at full back than Dunn.
- No point having Magner in the team if he's just going to be the sub, let him play full games at Casey.
- Bate doesn't have a future at Melbourne, too slow for the midfield and not big enough up forward.

By all means list your ins and outs then all-knowing one.

What so you don't think that if Frawley was fit last week that Dunn would have still played the same role in the backline and maybe Rivers or Garland would have went forward considering we had no real target...

As for Bate, i could name a lot worse, he was okay on the weekend and worked his guts out.

As for Joel Mac, who else do we have that is damaging. The only back man with elite foot skills is Strauss. I love Frawley, but on this years form, wouldn't be having wet dreams over him pal!!

 

[CTHORANGE]

In: Evans , Gysberts

Out: JMac , Mystery Injury

 

[Deemanding]

In: Fitzpatrick, Gysberts, Evans

Put: Mystery Injury 1, Mystery Injury 2, Magner

 

[Bluelegs]

In: Martin if available, otherwise Fitzpatrick, Watts if available, otherwise Gysberts, Frawley
Out: Garland, Moloney, Bate, if mystery injury add Fitz as a definite in.

Edit: Sounds like Couch is a likely call up

Tom Couch - 29 disposals (15 kicks, 14 handballs), 3 marks, 5 tackles
Tom had an excellent game. His work-ethic set a great example for his teammates and he was rewarded with a high possession count. He has significantly improved his spread from a contest and his use of the ball. His form will certainly place pressure on players in the AFL team.

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/7415/newsid/144482/default.aspx

 

[fushy]

In: Martin if available, otherwise Fitzpatrick, Watts if available, otherwise Gysberts, Frawley
Out: Garland, Moloney, Bate, if mystery injury add Fitz as a definite in.

Edit: Sounds like Couch is a likely call up



http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/7415/newsid/144482/default.aspx

Going by the player review, Fitz wont get in as they say he needs to get more consistent

 

[Ghost of Grinter]

I'd like to see Couch get a full gig in the middle against GWS.

Not just for the benefit of my supercoach either.

 

[fushy]

I'd like to see Couch get a full gig in the middle against GWS.

Not just for the benefit of my supercoach either.

Same, but i just want him to play so i can see him in the flesh haha

 

[Dez!]

Going by the player review, Fitz wont get in as they say he needs to get more consistent

He'd be up there with Couch in the B&F, how much more consistent can he be?

 

[fushy]

He'd be up there with Couch in the B&F, how much more consistent can he be?

I am just going off the mfc.com.au review

"Jack needs to be consistent every week to push for AFL selection, as he certainly has many positive attributes in his game."

 

[Dez!]

I am just going off the mfc.com.au review

"Jack needs to be consistent every week to push for AFL selection, as he certainly has many positive attributes in his game."

I know, you mentioned it so I just quoted the post.

There is no possible way they can ignore a game like he had on the weekend.

 

[tasmanlvr]

Some news through that Patton, Cameron and Shiel will miss. With Patton and Cameron out I think we'll need to reshuffle our defense a little bit. Tomas Bugg might become someone who plays up forward. Giles might be moved inside 50 as well to provide a bit of height and they might bring back Brogan to make the move work. That means I think Sellar should come out purely for team balance - dunno if him and Fitzpatrick (provided he comes in) in the forward line would work.

Also, looks like Greene, Adams, Palmer and Junior could come back - I think Greene is their best midfielder, and I reckon we should put McKenzie onto him to curb his influence. With Bugg probably moving into the forward line Junior might get the job on Jones. With Palmer I think he'll play a head-to-head role with Trengove. Adams... not sure - still learning with this mob.

 

[ThePuppetMaster]

Ward is their best mid - but he'll be out injured again.

 

[Tulip]

I think we all know who Jordie will tag to be honest.

 

[Captain Jack]

I think we all know who Jordie will tag to be honest.

Record low kicking efficiency between the two of them, surely.

 

[Bluelegs]

Some news through that Patton, Cameron and Shiel will miss.

Tanking

 

[Dez!]

Record low kicking efficiency between the two of them, surely.

Jordie kicks?