Changes for round 2

[Pipefitter]

No point dropping any kids, we just gotta play em. Our "senior" players wont be around by the time this club has turned around.

 

[stickman11]

I think 8 Changes is required:

B: Bell Frawley Holland
HB: C Johnson Martin Rivers
C: Mclean Bruce Moloney
HF: Dunn Newton Sylvia
F: Robertson Neitz Green
Ruck: P Johnson Jones McDonald
Inter: Morton Meeson Davey Wheatley
Emer: Bode Warncok Buckley

In: Dunn Sylvia Meeson Frawley Holland Rivers C Johnson Martin
Out: Weetra Buckley Garland Yze White Carroll Pettard Miller

* This backline is much stronger than comparing to round 1
* If Davey can't permform, then I think its time to try Maric.
* Ben Holland have a good record against the dogs. Bring him in.
* Try Martin instead of Carroll. Carroll is useless.
* Drop White and try P Johnson & Meeson. Sooner or later it will happen because White cant ruck forever.

Comments?

Rather kick out Holland and have Petterd in that defensive half.

Might stick with Garland if he was moved forward.

 

[Obeanie1]

Is Whelan injured or playing in the two's getting match fitness?

Picked him as a smokey in DT

 

[CowboyFromHell]

Is Whelan injured or playing in the two's getting match fitness?

Picked him as a smokey in DT

Playing in the twos getting match fitness. He should be back next week.

 

[yeoy16]

out-
bruce carroll green miller robertson weathley white (soft dosent work hard enoght) yze mcdonald (just a footballer too old slow) neitz (cant get a kick too old too slow play him last 2-3 rounds as a swan song)

in-
bartram bate bode dunn frawley meesen rivers syliva jamar grimes



play the kids

 

[CowboyFromHell]

I think 8 Changes is required:

B: Bell Frawley Holland
HB: C Johnson Martin Rivers
C: Mclean Bruce Moloney
HF: Dunn Newton Sylvia
F: Robertson Neitz Green
Ruck: P Johnson Jones McDonald
Inter: Morton Meeson Davey Wheatley
Emer: Bode Warncok Buckley

In: Dunn Sylvia Meeson Frawley Holland Rivers C Johnson Martin
Out: Weetra Buckley Garland Yze White Carroll Pettard Miller

* This backline is much stronger than comparing to round 1
* If Davey can't permform, then I think its time to try Maric.
* Ben Holland have a good record against the dogs. Bring him in.
* Try Martin instead of Carroll. Carroll is useless.
* Drop White and try P Johnson & Meeson. Sooner or later it will happen because White cant ruck forever.

Comments?

That backline is FAR too tall, especially against the Dogs. Bring in Frawley and Rivers, but also bring in Whelan and Bartram to go with Bell and Petterd to counter the smalls. Martin isn't ready and Chris Johnson is freaking rubbish.

Dunn and Sylvia on to the flanks is a good move, but I'd like to see Robbo get the arse. White is a 50/50 for me, but I don't think Bailey will go that far... yet.

 

[KTLK]

As for Carroll he needs to stay in as he is our best fullback for the time being.

(Thank you for your comments: Please bear this in mind that Nathan Carroll has been given stacks of opportunities and as the result of this, he can't perform and deliver. If the club wish to see improvments in the backline for good future run, then dumping Carroll is the correct move. Sticking with Carroll in the defence is crazy these days and can caused problems and frustrations)

 

[CowboyFromHell]

As for Carroll he needs to stay in as he is our best fullback for the time being.

(Thank you for your comments: Please bear this in mind that Nathan Carroll has been given stacks of opportunities and as the result of this, he can't perform and deliver. If the club wish to see improvments in the backline for good future run, then dumping Carroll is the correct solution. Sticking with Carroll in the defence is crazy these days and can caused problems and frustrations)

I agree. Plus Carroll has no brain in that head of his so the sooner he goes, the better. I'd like to see Warnock get an extended run in the ones, he's got a good size body and he's got more height than Carroll. Let's face it - he can't do any worse!

 

[Crimson Azure]

For me I think the more relavent question is who deserves to stay in the team?

That is a very short list.

From yesterday I didn't see many players who earnt a recall next week.

Nathan Jones showed heart & a strong desire to win the ball, but our skills were like a local U15's team.

When we can say that Paul Johnson was our best player we are in trouble.

 

[KTLK]

I agree. Plus Carroll has no brain in that head of his so the sooner he goes, the better. I'd like to see Warnock get an extended run in the ones, he's got a good size body and he's got more height than Carroll. Let's face it - he can't do any worse!

Thanks CFH for your support. About Warnock, how is he performin in the Zebras?

I agree that give Warnock a go because his height, pace and age is better than Carroll.

 

[Crimson Azure]

I agree. Plus Carroll has no brain in that head of his so the sooner he goes, the better. I'd like to see Warnock get an extended run in the ones, he's got a good size body and he's got more height than Carroll. Let's face it - he can't do any worse!

I agree with you agreeing, Carroll needs to spend more time trying to be a footballer & less time trying to look like the last of the Mohicans.

If he wants to draw attention to himself let it be because of his play not that ridiculous lions mane he has.

 

[CowboyFromHell]

Thanks CFH for your support. About Warnock, how is he performin in the Zebras?

I agree that give Warnock a go because his height, pace and age is better than Carroll.

To be honest I have no idea. From all reports yesterday from a good mate who saw the first half of the Sandy practice game we were up 100 to 22. So I guess he couldn't have been that bad. Apparently Dunn was dominating in the middle and had 3 goals, Rivers, Bartram and Whelan looked great down back and even Dutchy kicked a few. So I'd say Warnock was doing alright as well, so why not give him a crack?

 

[KTLK]

To be honest I have no idea. From all reports yesterday from a good mate who saw the first half of the Sandy practice game we were up 100 to 22. So I guess he couldn't have been that bad. Apparently Dunn was dominating in the middle and had 3 goals, Rivers, Bartram and Whelan looked great down back and even Dutchy kicked a few. So I'd say Warnock was doing alright as well, so why not give him a crack?

Absoultely. Thanks CFH

 

[melbournemartin]

That's funny. I thought that Grimes was injured for the next month and a half.

 

[CowboyFromHell]

That's funny. I thought that Grimes was injured for the next month and a half.

He is.

 

[melbournemartin]

He is.

Ah. The trolling post that I was referring to has obviously been deleted.

 

[CaptainDavey]

FB: Frawley Carroll Bartram
HB: Bell Rivers Petterd
C: Dunn Jones Bruce
HF: Davey Newton Sylvia
FF: Robertson Neitz Green
R: White McLean McDonald
INT: Johnson Moloney Morton Buckley

That's my team for anyone interested. Stiff for Wheatley to miss out. Yze I have a feeling won't be dropped though given his saving grace will most likely be the fact he's in the leadership group. That said, don't be surprised to see Buckley or Morton make way for him....Unfortunately

 

[melbournemartin]

That's nearly our strongest possible side.

 

[ExTasDeeMan]

In: A Jakovich, D Cuthbertson, R Jackson

Out: D Neitz, R Robertson, A Yze

 

[Magnificence]

out-
bruce carroll green miller robertson weathley white (soft dosent work hard enoght) yze mcdonald (just a footballer too old slow) neitz (cant get a kick too old too slow play him last 2-3 rounds as a swan song)

in-
bartram bate bode dunn frawley meesen rivers syliva jamar grimes



play the kids

Out Bruce !!!! are u crazy

 

[CowboyFromHell]

In: A Jakovich, D Cuthbertson, R Jackson

Out: D Neitz, R Robertson, A Yze

Throw in Tingay, Schwarz, Lyon pre-injuries, the hardness of Viney, the class of G. Lovett and the defending abilities of Ingerson and Seecamp and we are starting to look half decent...

 

[Flashhh]

IN: Rivers, Sylvia, Frawley, Whelan

OUT: Yze, Morton, Wheatley, Carroll

 

[Flashhh]

I agree with you agreeing, Carroll needs to spend more time trying to be a footballer & less time trying to look like the last of the Mohicans.

If he wants to draw attention to himself let it be because of his play not that ridiculous lions mane he has.

I agree with you agreeing with someone agreeing. Carroll is a joke, the only reason people got excited about him in '06 was because of a few good games but since then he has been absolutely rubbish and the only reason I like him was because of the time Gehrig tried to take him on in the 2006 EF and Chopper took him down and let gehrig limp off like a girl but besides that he should not be getting a game.
I cant work out for the life of me why they arnt playing James Frawley or even giving Warnock a run.

 

[demonfan9]

Post removed

Can someone delete this wankas post?

EDIT - Thanks, Marns.

 

[Marns]

Yes.