Changes For Round 2

[_RT_]

OK guys suggest the changes you want to make for the game against the Cats. Be warned though don't start with the out Wallace in Sheedy crap as it will be deleted. Just stick to making changes to the side that will run out.

Out: Cousins Raines
In: Rance Polo

 

[Rough_Edges]

just bruising for raines from all accounts..

 

[trashos mob]

out: mcmahon, cousins, raines
in: polo, thompson, rance

 

[1980]

Out deledio

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Off the top of my head..

OUT: Cousins, Raines*(if not, pick another player, by all means), Jackson, McMahon, Browne
IN: Polo, Thomson, Graham, Rance, Post

 

[abcxyz]

As bad as the team was, when the ball was there to be won, Edwards wouldn't put his head over it.

He's a young fella with alot of skill (who needs to work on his finishing), but that was a glaring issue at times. He's about 5-7kg too light and we have bigger bodies that offer some more at the fundamental level.

Will be a good player in the future, but at the moment we don't have the luxury of playing some-one who cannot contest a hard ball (especially against the Cats at Skilled Stadium next week).

There probably were worse, but for me his limitation were obvious.

 

[thecotch]

OK guys suggest the changes you want to make for the game against the Cats. Be warned though don't start with the out Wallace in Sheedy crap as it will be deleted. Just stick to making changes to the side that will run out.

Out: Cousins Raines
In: Rance Polo

Out: Simmonds (he's becoming a joke), mcmahon (disgrace of a footballer), tambling, schulz, edwards.
In: polo, someone else, someone else, someone else, someone else.

 

[krustyman]

out. edwards, mcguane, mcmahon, cousin (inj)

 

[Tigerballs]

In - Hislop, Rance, Polo, King, Thomson
Out- McMahon, Jackson, Cousins, Thursfield, Edwards

 

[TorresIsGod]

While I do agree you guys will make a few changes, not sure the 4, 5 or even 6 changes will be made.

Obviously Cousins will miss and most likely Raines.

But what on earth happened to your basic skills? I've seen a lot of Carlton games over the last 6 seasons (and we've been bad), but I don't think I've ever seen us play that bad.

 

[tony_montana]

the 2 greatest words in the english language

de fault
de fault
de fault

 

[thecotch]

While I do agree you guys will make a few changes, not sure the 4, 5 or even 6 changes will be made.

Obviously Cousins will miss and most likely Raines.

But what on earth happened to your basic skills? I've seen a lot of Carlton games over the last 6 seasons (and we've been bad), but I don't think I've ever seen us play that bad.

yes you have. dont kid yourself.

 

[strauchy]

OUT: injured Cousins, Browne, Mcmahon ( absolute disgrace!)

IN : Thomson, Graham, Rance


I dont undestand what the hell we are trying to do with Mcmahon. Mcmahon is one of the worst footballers ive ever come across! so why the hell does he get games? ill tell you why, because he got games for the buldogs and Wallace used to coach him. But that doesnt matter anymore! Mcmahon is so bad its actually a joke and i say keep him out for the rest of the year. keep him to the reserves until we need him which is very unlikely. he honestly hasnt dont anything for us at all except accumulate some cheap possesions. Bring thomson in permanently for McMahon because he looks more classy and a better natural footballer.

as for most of our other players, dont worry too much because the team peformance as a whole was absolutely pathetic! the only player who looked like trying was Richo.

Riewoldt needs to learn how to kick and we need more games like that from Morton. we need to develop Morton /Riewoldt into the S. Johnson type.

Carlton didnt win the game tonight, we lost it.

 

[Bojangles17]

out. edwards, mcguane, mcmahon, cousin (inj)

mcguane, are you kidding, thought he was only winner fevola had only 3-4 shots at goal...from a team total of ~30 fair effort i would have thought...recovered well after dropping a sitter

out :edwards, cuzz , mcmahon raines
in Polo, rance, thomo, king/hislop/collins

 

[krustyman]

mcguane, are you kidding, thought he was only winner fevola had only 3-4 shots at goal...from a team total of ~30 fair effort i would have thought...recovered well after dropping a sitter

out :edwards, cuzz , mcmahon raines
in Polo, rance, thomo, king/hislop/collins

fev was on one leg, and mcguane butched all his possessions especially early. moore wasnt much better.

 

[the ranger]

out: cousins, raines, mcmahon, browne
in: polo, thomson, rance, graham

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Guy/ Girls the fact of the matter is tactically, skill level wise and collectively tonight we were disgracefull.
Leading into the game we were the worst side in the AFL game plan wise and selection wise we picked a side based on reputation rather than form. What else could we expect from a side that wasn't good enough to play finals in 08 ???

 

[Danog]

In - Rance, Polo, King, Thomson
Out - McMahon, Cousins, Edwards, Raines

 

[tigerz18]

out: mcmahon, cuz(inj), schulz, edwards(unfortunately, as i like him), jackson, tambling(he should never play again, he never chases and never gets out of first gear)

in: rance, thompson, hughes, post, polo, hislop.

 

[TimeFor11]

KING!!!!!! WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU PEOPLE THINKING??????

What was wrong with us tonight? Our skills dropping easy marks overhead.

What is wrong with King? as above.

Sure he can tackle etc. but no hope he should come in.

Rance only certainty in.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Polo is a must inclusion this week. How this guy misses out time and time again.. who knows.

Typical though, we play against Geelong (likely to get thumped) and he'll be out against the Bulldogs in Round 3.

 

[Barnzy]

Out: Richmond Football Club

In: Coburg Football Club

At least we might have more of an excuse when we lose by 150 points next week.

 

[budge11]

Bad luck tonight guys Head up

 

[sante]

I'm gutted, angry, disappointed and embarrassed.

Changes? We could drop half of them.

 

[gaelictiogar]

out: mcmahon, cousins, raines
in: polo, thompson, rance

Agreed.....not that it makes any difference. It is just moving the deckchairs on the stricken ship.