Who would you replace him with tho, amiright
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Changes for Round 6 v Adelaide
- Thread starter xInfected_Virus
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Fraser
Love Darling, but he should have never ever ever ever ever EVERRR gone to the hub.
Hopefully he returns to us in Perth.
Just have a dreadful feeling we’re going ro break Adelaide’s drought.
... like we broke the Suns’ drought. Although at least the Suns have shown some fight.
last year we barely beat Adelaide. We got lucky that Sloane went off injured. Otherwise we’d have lost.
Really worried about this game. The embarrassment would overpower the disappointment.
... like we broke the Suns’ drought. Although at least the Suns have shown some fight.
last year we barely beat Adelaide. We got lucky that Sloane went off injured. Otherwise we’d have lost.
Really worried about this game. The embarrassment would overpower the disappointment.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Dark Sharks
Premium Kent
INB4 the Suns turn into a complete shambles again and we were one of the only 3 (Freo & Adelaide) teams to play them as a powerhouse with freakshow Rowell.
Mickey Ablett had Brander as the best KPD in his draft year with Oscar as his best KPF.
Watching him over the last 2 years, I saw him playing better in defence.
In terms of developing a wingman, here is as novel idea.
If we want a winger, how about we start by drafting an outside midfielder! Novel approach.
XON is as close to an outside winger that might be close to trialling. Foley falls into the failed category with Ainsworth from what I have seen
- Jun 14, 2015
- 3,669
- 4,106
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Cameron and Jetta to come in i dont want to bring in Brander because we will be way too slow and cumbersome
Where as Waterman is a good gut runner, has a good pair of hands, kicks goals and is a selfless player
Where as Waterman is a good gut runner, has a good pair of hands, kicks goals and is a selfless player
Young agile KP defender being developed as the defensive wing man role that Masten played?
Its not hard to see what we are doing is it? It's pretty logical actually. People are sooking because the entire team have been playing crap and Brander is the new whipping boy as he is playing a low possession role.
Brander plays a kick and a half behind play, guards the space, intercepts defensively when he can (and has) and provides an outlet from defense as a marking option.
If the game plan is to persist with the defensive wing then I'm fine with Brander playing that role.
If we ditch that tactic and want a more attacking, running and pressure winger then Brander isn't that player.
If they leave Waterman out and bring in Brander, I’ll crack. Nothing against Brander, but he’s just... out of place (albeit improving weekly).
Last year’s final when we lost Rioli last minute - why did they bring in Petch ahead of Cameron as an emergency? Cameron wasn’t injured yet as was still playing WAFL.
At times, the match committee just appears not to want to win. Especially since the final stages of last year and all this year (till last week’s selection). Dropping Oscar Allen against Port Adelaide of all teams takes the cake.
No confidence till team selection announced. Shouldn’t be the case.
I also think we could learn a thing or two from Brisbane, who’ve done well to never rely on individuals.
Last year’s final when we lost Rioli last minute - why did they bring in Petch ahead of Cameron as an emergency? Cameron wasn’t injured yet as was still playing WAFL.
At times, the match committee just appears not to want to win. Especially since the final stages of last year and all this year (till last week’s selection). Dropping Oscar Allen against Port Adelaide of all teams takes the cake.
No confidence till team selection announced. Shouldn’t be the case.
I also think we could learn a thing or two from Brisbane, who’ve done well to never rely on individuals.
Dark Sharks
Premium Kent
They aren't leaving Waterman out cob, you can relax. The fans would riot.
I think our MC can be a bit too slow at times and tend to make dumb mistakes they really don't need to, before "learning" from them.
Blind Freddy could see Allen was better option to partner Naitanui than Hickey, and yet they went and made that dumb mistake and backflipped a week later.
Last year we carried Vardy for weeks and weeks and weeks hoping he would come good, longer than necessary, before eventually putting a line through him.
I think Petch is at the point now where he's been given enough chances to show improvement, and hasn't. Considering Cameron hardly did anything wrong, he's got to be the next cab off the ranks to come in for Jones. The only thing preventing that from happening would be his fitness.
My guess
IN : Brander, Cameron
OUT : Shuey, Jones
I think our MC can be a bit too slow at times and tend to make dumb mistakes they really don't need to, before "learning" from them.
Blind Freddy could see Allen was better option to partner Naitanui than Hickey, and yet they went and made that dumb mistake and backflipped a week later.
Last year we carried Vardy for weeks and weeks and weeks hoping he would come good, longer than necessary, before eventually putting a line through him.
I think Petch is at the point now where he's been given enough chances to show improvement, and hasn't. Considering Cameron hardly did anything wrong, he's got to be the next cab off the ranks to come in for Jones. The only thing preventing that from happening would be his fitness.
My guess
IN : Brander, Cameron
OUT : Shuey, Jones
bh90210fan
Norm Smith Medallist
- Sep 4, 2017
- 9,623
- 11,121
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Banned
- #263
Brander just needs to tidy up his short - mid range kicking and he’ll be good for us. Jettas drop in DE combined with Branders nervous kicks going forward in the first few games hurt us. Last week we were clinical skill wise in our back half so id be loathe to change anything down back. Thinking this week it’ll likely be Brander and Cameron to come in for Shuey and Jones. We should win this week and if we’re up and about it should give Brander some needed confidence
Adelaide have gone home to SA already. They'll play us travelling like a normal away game, with their Round 7 game back at home.
I was a big fan of Duggan playing further up the ground last week and I think with our glut of small defenders it might finally be time to do away with that ultra defensive wing and go with two attacking options.
Hurn Barrass Nelson
Cole McGovern Sheppard
Gaff Kelly Duggan
Cripps Darling Waterman
Ryan Kennedy Cameron
Naitanui Yeo Sheed
Allen, Redden, Brander, Ah Chee
- Redden to play in the guts
- Persist with Brander as a wing rotation but allow him to spend some more time as a KPP to help him get into the game
- Jetta to play in the scrimmage this week with him as a hopeful inclusion for the Derby
Hurn Barrass Nelson
Cole McGovern Sheppard
Gaff Kelly Duggan
Cripps Darling Waterman
Ryan Kennedy Cameron
Naitanui Yeo Sheed
Allen, Redden, Brander, Ah Chee
- Redden to play in the guts
- Persist with Brander as a wing rotation but allow him to spend some more time as a KPP to help him get into the game
- Jetta to play in the scrimmage this week with him as a hopeful inclusion for the Derby
Also fking lol I just realised my av is still Brant from the last WereDocker game
The wily weagle
Premiership Player
- Oct 16, 2014
- 3,288
- 7,541
- AFL Club
- West Coast
This. So much this. We seem to have a mild obsession with taking kids that havent played as midfielders (particularly half back flankers) and trying to turn them into midfielders. Or, taking midfielders and trying to play them on the half forward flank. I look at our list and the lack of young quality mids coming through the ranks and developing in the seconds is a huge, huge worry.
It has to be our number 1 priority from next year (we gave away our first round pick this year to the cats):
-draft actual midfielders
-play them in the midfield
-develop young onball talent and desperately improve our young midfield depth
I didn't really consider him likely until Shuey mentioned his name this morning, but I wouldn't mind seeing Hammer Brayshaw come in. Looked good through the WAFL late last year. The knock on him is his speed, but we're facing a slow midfield this weekend.
If ever Simmo wanted to replicate that infectious energy of youth from last weekend, I think this would be how he does it. Hammer is one of those best Clubman types, loved by all, happy, fun bloke. Looked unlikely to get a shot with the likes of TK coming in. But a midfield opening has presented itself.
Should he get the nod he absolutely must be played in the guts though. We can't try to ease him in out of position. Do what we did with Ainsworth and start him at the first CBD.
If ever Simmo wanted to replicate that infectious energy of youth from last weekend, I think this would be how he does it. Hammer is one of those best Clubman types, loved by all, happy, fun bloke. Looked unlikely to get a shot with the likes of TK coming in. But a midfield opening has presented itself.
Should he get the nod he absolutely must be played in the guts though. We can't try to ease him in out of position. Do what we did with Ainsworth and start him at the first CBD.
"There was an eruption just before match sim started, so I think Simmo did announce who is playing but I can’t tell you who that is sorry."
www.westcoasteagles.com.au
Would suggest a debutant I would think. Reid or Brayshaw given that's who the article goes on to talk about.
Selection intrigue grows for Crows clash
West Coast has a host of options to choose from to replace hamstrung pair Luke Shuey and Jamaine Jones for Saturday's meeting wtih Adelaide
Would suggest a debutant I would think. Reid or Brayshaw given that's who the article goes on to talk about.
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
RookiePick
Hall of Famer
- Aug 13, 2014
- 30,585
- 55,397
- AFL Club
- West Coast
"There was an eruption just before match sim started, so I think Simmo did announce who is playing but I can’t tell you who that is sorry."
Selection intrigue grows for Crows clash
West Coast has a host of options to choose from to replace hamstrung pair Luke Shuey and Jamaine Jones for Saturday's meeting wtih Adelaide
Would suggest a debutant I would think. Reid or Brayshaw given that's who the article goes on to talk about.
Miguel Sanchez
Snide Shooter
XON another possibility. Surprised Treacy isn’t being talked about as an inclusion but I guess his training form isn’t on par with the others.
JordanWCE
Norm Smith Medallist
With how well liked he is at the club, I wouldn't be surprised to hear it's Brayshaw.
You’re 100% correct. He’s just the easy whipping boy at the moment. He’s doing fine for a tall guy that’s played 7 games in really tough conditions as you mentioned.
We need to pump games into him at the moment, but he’s clearly not ahead of JK or JD up forward and Barrass & Gov down back. But he’s fit enough to play That roaming Masto role which we obviously rate internally as being important to our setup.
The Brander at 25-50 games is going to be a completely different prospect. We just have to get him there, and hope that another club doesn’t take the spoils.
Smells like a Debut.
Similar threads
