- Joined
- Aug 9, 2009
- Posts
- 17,580
- Reaction score
- 12,915
- Location
- Manchester
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth Demons, Liverpool
I don't think we would have beaten them either.
Fremantle and Sydney were cooked. Then there was North.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Soccer Notice Image
FA Cup Semi-Finals ⚽ 2026 FIFA Series A - Socceroos friendlies ⚽ Europa - Rd of 16 ⚽ The Matildas x 2026 Womens Asia Cup ⚽ Conference League - KNOCKOUTS! ⚽ Conference League - Rd of 16 ⚽ Socceroos Internat'l Friendlies ⚽ Champs League - League Phase ⚽
I don't think we would have beaten them either.
Stop relying on your memory. Richmond finished 5th
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Well you'd think Vardy is out then because there's no need to elevate Mcinness if he isn't
So it looks like we're officially going to the bottom of the well with our ruck stocks
Good luck Fraser, you'll need it
Jimmy_the_Gent you're voodoo doll strategy has come to fruition
That team was 8-0 playing a 1-7 Collingwood at the MCG in 2005. They lost. Couldn't beat Sydney at the SCG. Lost by over 70 points at Kardinia Park. Lost a home final going in as heavy favourites. Lost at home in the last when a win would have won the minor premiership. Lost to 13th placed Brisbane at home. Gave up a 36 point lead at Docklands to Essendon.
People forget that champion teams don't play as champions all the time. The win on the last day covers all sins.
We win last year and the GWS game becomes folklore. Proof of a team that can win against the odds. We win in 2015 and our QF against Hawthorn becomes club legend. They beat us 5 weeks earlier but we got them when it mattered, bouncing back like great sides do.
The middle stretch of 2006 from Round 10-16 could have lost us a chance at a flag. We went 4-3 with all wins being under two goals, including those two massive comebacks. In fact we were down at 3QT in 10 out of 11 weeks from Round 6-16 (round 9 we were up by a point).
Incidentally, for anyone interested. Since Simpson has been our coach
Interstate away games
Hawthorn 8-9 (47% win rate)
West Coast 17-16-1 (50% win rate)
Geelong 9-7 (56% win rate)
Compared to their win rates at home or local away games
Hawthorn goes from 49-15 (76.6%) a drop of about 30% when playing away interstate
West Coast goes from 32-10 (76.2%) a drop of about 25% when playing away interstate
Geelong goes from 42-16-1 (71.1%) a drop of about 15% when playing away interstate
*theres probably a game or two wrong, I've been half looking at this while doing other things.
I don't think we would have beaten them either.
Incidentally, for anyone interested. Since Simpson has been our coach
Interstate away games
Hawthorn 8-9 (47% win rate)
West Coast 17-16-1 (50% win rate)
Geelong 9-7 (56% win rate)
Compared to their win rates at home or local away games
Hawthorn goes from 49-15 (76.6%) a drop of about 30% when playing away interstate
West Coast goes from 32-10 (76.2%) a drop of about 25% when playing away interstate
Geelong goes from 42-16-1 (71.1%) a drop of about 15% when playing away interstate
*theres probably a game or two wrong, I've been half looking at this while doing other things.
I think we could have beaten the Hawks in 2013 Grand Final.
Karpany and Mcinness are certainties to be added to the 22 that played FremantleAt the risk of posting about the actual thread topic, sounding from Simpsons's presser that there'll be no changes to the side today, but that McInnes and two other emergencies will travel as cover for Vardy, Duggan and anyone else who might not get up. Mutimer will retain his spot.
As a guess I'd say Hutch and Karps for the other two seats on the plane.
Yep he tall ......Just saw Vardy and yeo at the airport checking in. Did not realise how tall yep is. He isn't far behind Vardy.
Not sure if serious....in fact I'm sure you are joking.
I think Simmo was talking earlier in the week about Jetta getting another shot.Karpany and Mcinness are certainties to be added to the 22 that played Fremantle
Take your pick of Hutchings, Jetta, Schofield or Mackenzie for the last seat
Yeah. I suggested Geelong and hawthorn to you.
You implied you would be waiting a long time.
Be interesting to find out how many of those wins were against "good" sides away for hawthorn and geeelong.