Preview Changes: R10 v Melbourne

[Scorpus]

Hard to say with our tendency to get injuries at training. But as it stands right now (and there are some unlucky players)

OUT: Otten, Gibson, Murphy
IN: Brown, M. Crouch, Milera

Poholke stays in after today's effort. Hard call between him and Murphy.

Otten out for Brown
Gibson stays in if Crouch isn't ready
Murphy stays if Milera isn't ready

I'm assuming Tex, Knight and others will not be ready

 

[Shaz2012]

Gibson stays. Give him a shutdown role again.

 

[Scorpus]

Gibson stays. Give him a shutdown role again.

Was Gibson tagging? Macrae had a game high 36 touches

 

[androidtommy]

Seed wearing a jacket and limping a bit. Anyone see what happened?

 

[fourhorseman]

Hard to say with our tendency to get injuries at training. But as it stands right now (and there are some unlucky players)

OUT: Otten, Gibson, Murphy
IN: Brown, M. Crouch, Milera

Poholke stays in after today's effort. Hard call between him and Murphy.

Otten out for Brown
Gibson stays in if Crouch isn't ready
Murphy stays if Milera isn't ready

I'm assuming Tex, Knight and others will not be ready

Huh????? Who said M.Crouch, Brown and Milera will even be available? You have added in players and started a thread based on nothing.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[dogs105]

Seed wearing a jacket and limping a bit. Anyone see what happened?

Sounds like awareness...

 

[Cincinnatus]

Hard to say with our tendency to get injuries at training. But as it stands right now (and there are some unlucky players)

OUT: Otten, Gibson, Murphy
IN: Brown, M. Crouch, Milera

Poholke stays in after today's effort. Hard call between him and Murphy.

Otten out for Brown
Gibson stays in if Crouch isn't ready
Murphy stays if Milera isn't ready

I'm assuming Tex, Knight and others will not be ready

Huh????? Who said M.Crouch, Brown and Milera will even be available? You have added in players and started a thread based on nothing.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Certainly feels tricky to count on anything until Thursday afternoon the way we are going but there isnt really anything wront with speculating....thread happens every week.

 

[Apsaalooke]

Seed wearing a jacket and limping a bit. Anyone see what happened?

Dare I say the big H?

 

[jo172]

Was Gibson tagging? Macrae had a game high 36 touches

No good ones though

 

[twiggy4PM]

Will depend if we have anyone fit enough to play

 

[Shaz2012]

Was Gibson tagging? Macrae had a game high 36 touches

I saw him marking him tightly but he didn’t seem to be on him the whole game. I just think that we need to see what kind of weapon Gibson’s tag can be for us. If he pulls up ok, now is the perfect time to give him a run of games and let him do what he does best. Look at how effective it was on Dusty last week. We need to see if we have a player that can do that job.

 

[Scorpus]

No good ones though

Well he did also have 10 clearances, 13 tackles, 4 inside 50s, 5 score involvements and 25 contested possessions.

Didn't look like he was tagged either

 

[Squiba]

Seed wearing a jacket and limping a bit. Anyone see what happened?

 

[Viva la Mattner]

Out: Murphy, Gooch

In: Brown, M.Crouch

Hopefully Knight and Milera back in SANFL

 

[Redleg Crow]

Wait to see who is available.

 

[GreyCrow]

I saw him marking him tightly but he didn’t seem to be on him the whole game. I just think that we need to see what kind of weapon Gibson’s tag can be for us. If he pulls up ok, now is the perfect time to give him a run of games and let him do what he does best. Look at how effective it was on Dusty last week. We need to see if we have a player that can do that job.

It wasn't tight. Loose as fuh. Gave him a metre and more. Tried to close to shut the space but it wasn't a hard tag. Gibson also got the ball so that's a good thing

 

[Deaneus!]

Everyone put in, so I’ve got no melt about players trying

Down to who’s available and what’s best for the team

 

[Geoffa32]

I thought Gibson was playing a tag role.
But was bad at it.

He would be first out for me.

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

 

[Vader]

Seed wearing a jacket and limping a bit. Anyone see what happened?

I noticed he was already had the tracksuit top on before they went down into the change rooms.

 

[Crows I Am]

K

Sounds like awareness...

Jacket awareness...

 

[Shaz2012]

It wasn't tight. Loose as fuh. Gave him a metre and more. Tried to close to shut the space but it wasn't a hard tag. Gibson also got the ball so that's a good thing

Ok. I was referring to a couple of contests where he was tight. Other than that I didn’t think Gibson was on him. If he was he was smashed.

Don’t think you can judge Gibson or Hartigan harshly. They were immense to come in and hold their own given the circumstances. Thought both were important contributors.

 

[Crows I Am]

Changes threads are so hard these days with no idea who will be coming back from injury and who will injure themselves at training during the week. Hopefully Milera is nearing a return would be great to get him back. Think M Crouch and Brown may miss a couple but who knows really.
Wasnt too many that deserved to be dropped after tonight.

 

[conVINCEd]

Murphy > Poholke.

 

[WetCrow1991]

I noticed he was already had the tracksuit top on before they went down into the change rooms.

Seed hates the cold.

 

[GreyCrow]

Ok. I was referring to a couple of contests where he was tight. Other than that I didn’t think Gibson was on him. If he was he was smashed.

Don’t think you can judge Gibson or Hartigan harshly. They were immense to come in and hold their own given the circumstances. Thought both were important contributors.

I am not smashing Gibson , as I said he also got the ball a bit. I do agree that both he and Hartigan played above themselves in a tight contest rather than having the luxury of the SANFL to run into some touch