Hartigan can’t kick - doesn’t matterIt's pretty typical of Adelaide to look at what a player can't do and not be able to get past it
Butts might get outbodied occassionally. So that means he cannot be played under any circumstances.
What about all the good things he does? Agile for a big bloke, decent closing speed, quality intercept mark, good distribution...? Will improve quickly if given exposure at a higher level? To us none of that matters. He might get outbodied. The end.
Fogarty's tank? The end.
What about all his good stuff? Doesn't matter to us.
We need to learn how to formulate and understand pros and cons lists.
Atkins soft - doesn’t matter
Douglas slips over - doesn’t matter
Just depends on the player I suppose and whether they’ve played 50 games or more