Preview Changes: R9 v Western Bulldogs

[Scorpus]

Didn't watch a ton of the game to get a good read on it. However Poholke is obviously not up to it.

Difficult to say who should come in. Likely only Hartigan is ready

OUT: Poholke, Otten
IN: Murphy, Hartigan

 

[jenny61_99]

Out: Anyone who is slightly injured.
In: Anyone who isn’t.

 

[Drummond]

Out: Mackay, Otten, Poholke.
In: Literally anyone who can walk

 

[GreyCrow]

I shall make a comment after the injury report

I cant see McGovern getting up from 2 bad head clashes

 

[Bearded Clam]

Out: gooch, poholke, Mackay, otten

In: Murphy, Wilson, someone other than Mackay I don’t care who, Hartigan.

 

[RePete]

Not a lot of player ready by the looks of things.

Vs Bulldogs:
Out: Poholke
In: Knight

Would be tempted to rest Gallucci this week as well for Hampton coming off a 6-day break

VS Melbourne
Out: Otten, Gallucci and whoever shits the bed over the next 2 weeks/next person to do hammy
In: Hartigan, (hopefully) Milera and Sloane - If one doesn't come up - maybe Gibson

Vs Giants or Freo the week after:
Out: Greenwood
In: Brad Crouch


With a bit of luck we should have near our best team on the park soon. Some of the fill-ins have been good, but in general we are lacking; missing some of our stars.

 

[TRP1996]

OUT: Poholke, Otten
IN: Murphy, Hartigan

This.

If Gov and Tex also go out with injury (or we want to drop Mackay- hey, I can dream- or Gooch) is there anyone left to come in? Fogarty? Wilson?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Really depends on who is available.

Murphy for Polholke is probably the only player available from the sanfl.

We have Hartigan, Knight & Milera listed as being 1-2 weeks away. Hartigan needs to.come back via the sanfl given how long he has been out. Hopefully Milera & or Knight are ok to come back in as could do with both.

 

[footy4ever]

Firstly, who’s still injured? Just 2 of any of those guys back and we win that showdown. Probably only needed one in fact.

Who got injured?

But definitely wont see Milera and Sloane.

Hartigan? Night? Murphy?

Think Tex will miss. Jacobs could be iffy. Both spent time off the ground with injury.

Out:
Tex - the Fog
Poholke - Murphy

 

[GROTTO]

Not a great sign when the changes thread starts hours after the finish of our last game.

 

[Tex Danger]

Not a lot of player ready by the looks of things.

Vs Bulldogs:
Out: Poholke
In: Knight

Would be tempted to rest Gallucci this week as well for Hampton coming off a 6-day break

VS Melbourne
Out: Otten, Gallucci and whoever shits the bed over the next 2 weeks/next person to do hammy
In: Hartigan, (hopefully) Milera and Sloane - If one doesn't come up - maybe Gibson

Vs Giants or Freo the week after:
Out: Greenwood
In: Brad Crouch


With a bit of luck we should have near our best team on the park soon. Some of the fill-ins have been good, but in general we are lacking; missing some of our stars.

Greenwood should not be a pre meditated out. As much as he is being criticised for that last clearance, fact is without his last few minutes we lose by 3 goals. Was the one who stood up in the centre when we needed it and got us back to where we were and while with be benefit of watching from outside and replays etc you can say he made an error in that last play, he again was the one to get his hands on the ball

 

[latinoheat]

Out: Poholke
In : knight or Milera (whichever one is fit).

I’d also like to see Wilson get a run possibly for Kelly

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Not a lot of player ready by the looks of things.

Vs Bulldogs:
Out: Poholke
In: Knight

Would be tempted to rest Gallucci this week as well for Hampton coming off a 6-day break

VS Melbourne
Out: Otten, Gallucci and whoever shits the bed over the next 2 weeks/next person to do hammy
In: Hartigan, (hopefully) Milera and Sloane - If one doesn't come up - maybe Gibson

Vs Giants or Freo the week after:
Out: Greenwood
In: Brad Crouch


With a bit of luck we should have near our best team on the park soon. Some of the fill-ins have been good, but in general we are lacking; missing some of our stars.

Lol, Brad Crouch.

Nice comedy...

 

[pjcrows]

Not a lot of player ready by the looks of things.

Vs Bulldogs:
Out: Poholke
In: Knight

Would be tempted to rest Gallucci this week as well for Hampton coming off a 6-day break

VS Melbourne
Out: Otten, Gallucci and whoever shits the bed over the next 2 weeks/next person to do hammy
In: Hartigan, (hopefully) Milera and Sloane - If one doesn't come up - maybe Gibson

Vs Giants or Freo the week after:
Out: Greenwood
In: Brad Crouch


With a bit of luck we should have near our best team on the park soon. Some of the fill-ins have been good, but in general we are lacking; missing some of our stars.

Brad Crouch?

 

[RePete]

Greenwood should not be a pre meditated out. As much as he is being criticised for that last clearance, fact is without his last few minutes we lose by 3 goals. Was the one who stood up in the centre when we needed it and got us back to where we were and while with be benefit of watching from outside and replays etc you can say he made an error in that last play, he again was the one to get his hands on the ball

He has been good, but has his flaws. Way I see it - when Brad Crouch is 100% ready to go and we have a healthy team - then one of our mids has to go. CEY and Greenwood the prime candidates. I choose Greenwood because although he gets a good number of clearances and does some really flash stuff - he doesn't get a super lot of it, his clearnaces are often inaffective hack-forwards kicks and he doesn't run very hard. Think CEY's bigger body is more benefical to our team and compliments the rest of our mids better. That being said, may not be bad to rest one of CEY, Greenwood, Douglas. Need to make sure these players burn out come the pointy end of the season. Will be a good problem to have anyway.

 

[jenny61_99]

Not a great sign when the changes thread starts hours after the finish of our last game.

They normally do.

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

In: Murphy, Hartigan, Knight
Out: Otten, Poholke, Gallucci

 

[earlsta]

Lol, Brad Crouch.

Nice comedy...

They’ll wheel him out through the banner in a wheel chair

 

[Crowked]

I want to see what Wilson has. I think long term Poholke and Gallucci have potential. I have a feeling Wilson might be a better option right now. I also think it’s time to bring back Murphy.

In : Wilson, Murphy
Out: Gallucci, Poholke

Don’t think anyone on the injury list will be available.

 

[TRP1996]

In: Murphy, Hartigan, Knight
Out: Otten, Poholke, Gallucci

Is Knight fit?

 

[hey shorty]

Hard to know who is going to come in. Gooch and Poholke looked well off it but what can we bring in ??

Milera - Automatic in if he's fit.

Wilson - Better kick and has the body size

ROB - Sauce will need a spell. Good game to bring him in.

Murphy - Looks a senior player.

Hartigan - Comes in if fit, Otten is 4th choice.

Reality is we aren't making 5 changes, particularly if everyone got through tonight fit. Even if it's just Milera for Poholke, Hartigan for Otten and Murphy for Gallucci we are a better side.

Mackay will stay in because our coaches go on the last few weeks, not the game tonight which is regular David. I'd be happy for Poholke to stay in, and play him as a midfielder that he is, but Wilson is ahead of him IMO

 

[SES SA]

Hartigan - Otten
Milera - Mackay
Knight - Polholke

I have a feeling none will be ready to go and nothing on earth will make the Crows keep Mackay out for more than token SANFL time, but DEAR GOD do the first two need to go.

 

[hey shorty]

Oh and Knight if available comes into calculations.

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Is Knight fit?

Honestly, no idea. If not, then give Wilson a run. Not a mid as he has the turning circle of a mack track but his raking foot could be a weapon across HB/Wing.

 

[SES SA]

They’ll wheel him out through the banner in a wheel chair

He'll still be able to keep his feet better than Otten.