Remove this Banner Ad

Prediction Changes Round 14 vs Geelong

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just on jack Williams he is closing in on 2m tall was 195cms last year when drafted and still growing . Not even 19 until the end on the year.

Josh Bruce is an undersized key forward like darling .

Jack Williams is not overly quick but not slow either . What he does have is a massive tank already .

Your right about being 2 + years away but once he fills out he will be more that Hawkins type power forward to complement allen the more athletic forward .

Jack is already kicking at least a goal a game in league as an 18 year old to go with 5 marks and 8-10 hitouts .

Really promising signs
2m with a big tank is very hard to match up on - great signs
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I was looking at this fixture and realised I really don't want to go to the game. The team is at such a low ebb, that I can't see any positives out of watching. It would be different if we had a bunch of highly rated young players in their to develop, but given most of them are out injured, it's just a bit sad.
 
Yeah comparing him to Tony Notte when drafted means he’s guaranteed to follow the exact same trajectory.
 
I was looking at this fixture and realised I really don't want to go to the game. The team is at such a low ebb, that I can't see any positives out of watching. It would be different if we had a bunch of highly rated young players in their to develop, but given most of them are out injured, it's just a bit sad.
Strange things happen after a bye
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Play the kids if they’re at least in a position to be able to compete. E.g Hough, Culley in a couple of weeks, Luke Edwards last year.

Don’t play skinny undeveloped kids who need a year or two of development just for the sake of playing the kids. At worst, you’ll break them. At best you’re setting them up to fail. Stick a skinny 18 year old KPF in the side against a strong team in what’s a certain loss and it doesn’t matter what he does for the rest of his career, some posters will still say “I saw him play at the SCG and he was terrible, he’s not an AFL footballer”.

Not mentioning any names.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

WCE board: play the kids!
Also WCE board: he too little!

Am I doing this right

No, you aren't.

Since Simmo has been at the Eagles we have given AFL debuts to significantly (20%) less players than the AFL average. Even the BODE's gave debuts to more players (36). So, yes, Simmo shoud play the kids more than he has.

Our 2018 year shows you can play some kids and still be competitive.

However, only a small portion of AFL players debut in the year they were drafted unless they are mature age. So no, Simmo shouldn't play developing KPPs that aren't yet physically developed enough to compete at AFL level.


Year of Debut
Avg. debuts per AFL club
AFL debuts for WCE
2021​
5.2​
3​
2020​
7.3​
6​
2019​
4.3​
3​
2018​
5.3​
8​
2017​
5.2​
2​
2016​
4.5​
2​
2015​
4.8​
5​
2014​
4.6​
3​
41.2
32
 
No, you aren't.

Since Simmo has been at the Eagles we have given AFL debuts to significantly (20%) less players than the AFL average. Even the BODE's gave debuts to more players (36). So, yes, Simmo shoud play the kids more than he has.

Our 2018 year shows you can play some kids and still be competitive.

However, only a small portion of AFL players debut in the year they were drafted unless they are mature age. So no, Simmo shouldn't play developing KPPs that aren't yet physically developed enough to compete at AFL level.


Year of Debut
Avg. debuts per AFL club
AFL debuts for WCE
2021​
5.2​
3​
2020​
7.3​
6​
2019​
4.3​
3​
2018​
5.3​
8​
2017​
5.2​
2​
2016​
4.5​
2​
2015​
4.8​
5​
2014​
4.6​
3​
41.2
32

Guessing we’ve probably made up that 9.2players shortfall this season.
 
Why not start playing him?

On SM-G925I using BigFooty.com mobile app
I think the concensus is he need to fill out. I havent seen enough of him to comment but if he is relying on his tank he probably needs to learn his craft in the WAFL. A game or two later to give him motivation for the pre season would he a good idea. As an aside if he has growen so much as reporte since the draft he may be finding his feet so to speak.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top