Preview Changes: Round 16 v Western Bulldogs

[Scorpus]

Out: Hartigan (hamstring), Beech, Kelly, Mackay
In: Doedee, Seedsman, Gallucci, Cameron

Doedee is playing a blinder today in the SANFL according to the stats sheet.

Beech is not AFL quality. Kelly is not AFL quality. Mackay is not SANFL quality.

Lynch in instead of Gallucci if he is fit too

 

[marty36]

Out: Hartigan (hamstring), Beech, Kelly, Mackay
In: Doedee, Seedsman, Gallucci, Cameron

Doedee is playing a blinder today in the SANFL according to the stats sheet.

Beech is not AFL quality. Kelly is not AFL quality. Mackay is not SANFL quality.

Fanbois fanbois fanbois


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[latinoheat]

Out: Hartigan (hamstring), Beech, Kelly, Mackay
In: Doedee, Seedsman, Gallucci, Cameron

Doedee is playing a blinder today in the SANFL according to the stats sheet.

Beech is not AFL quality. Kelly is not AFL quality. Mackay is not SANFL quality.

Lynch in instead of Gallucci if he is fit too

Spot on IMO

 

[DD#23]

Fanbois fanbois fanbois


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

I've always been critical of others using the ignore function, but you truly have so little value to offer the board you're making me consider it.

 

[marty36]

Poor performers today

Greenwood Milera gov beech Atkins tex Sloane (was ok but needs to provide more as does tex)

Definetly need some toughness if cheney has a good game has to come in Thommo needs to be part of the mid for toughness don't bring in soft arses


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Paladin]

I like Kelly but he always looks backwards first. I dont think losing Hartigan will hurt in his current form. Talia stepped up and got to more contests and Kelly can play taller and bring in Seed to help with ball movement from the back. Too big as it was.

 

[Paladin]

Poor performers today

Greenwood Milera gov beech Atkins tex Sloane (was ok but needs to provide more as does tex)

Definetly need some toughness if cheney has a good game has to come in Thommo needs to be part of the mid for toughness don't bring in soft arses


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

You didnt notice Greenwood kept Cripps under control in the second half? It was crucial.

 

[FantasticShirt]

Hartigan and Beech definitely out.

Otten probably first in for Hartigan. Cameron available?

 

[Scorpus]

I've always been critical of others using the ignore function, but you truly have so little value to offer the board you're making me consider it.

A bit like Kelly. Enjoys the backwards handpass.

 

[Glenno23]

Beech and Harto my only 2 certain outs right now. 1 for injury and 1 for not being up to it

Wouldn't be adverse to 1 or 2 more changes, but reckon they may stop at 3 changes max. Maybe Kelly out

 

[SES SA]

Beech - Lynch (if fit)
Hartigan - Doedee
MacKay - Cameron

I really doubt that they will drop MacKay, because they will look at his stat line rather than his actual impact on the game.

 

[SloaneysDanger]

We won't make 4 changes after a win, this club doesn't do that.

Out: Hartigan, Beech
In: Lynch, CC

I don't think we need to bring Cheney or Doedee in against a small Dogs forward line.

 

[marty36]

The hell does this even mean? Why don't you offer some insight into selection? And maybe try using the English language and not misspelling every second word like in a standard Marty post yeah?

Mackay actually played ok


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[dplggr47]

OUT: Hartigan (inj), Beech, Kelly, Milera
IN: Doedee, Lynch, Cheney, Seedsman (or Cameron if fit)

 

[SydCrow]

Can Doedee play CHB?

 

[marty36]

You didnt notice Greenwood kept Cripps under control in the second half? It was crucial.

He gave us nothing you struggle with honesty don't you no point in playing favs he shouldn't be dropped he will learn but he has had two ordinary ones

Call a spade a spade man


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Crowked]

So when does Milera have to earn his spot? Has to be on the edge IMO. Just doesn't do enough. Hasn't for a long time now.

 

[Shaz2012]

Out: Hartigan (hamstring), Beech, Kelly, Mackay
In: Doedee, Seedsman, Gallucci, Cameron

Doedee is playing a blinder today in the SANFL according to the stats sheet.

Beech is not AFL quality. Kelly is not AFL quality. Mackay is not SANFL quality.

Lynch in instead of Gallucci if he is fit too

A KPD and a small defender for one small defender?

Hartigan has to be a straight swap for either Keath or Otten. I would be going Otten as he started the season very well as a defender.

The issue with Mackay is the same as it ever was. He simply is still best 22. Its not his fault our list isn't stronger than it is. They won't drop him after todays game where I thought he more than held his own. But I would personally prefer if we put games into Gallucci instead. Or Seedsman when he gets back to full fitness.

Milera needs to go and find some footy. I would give him a couple of weeks in the SANFL then give him back his gold pass in a few weeks.

Out: Hartigan, Kelly, Beech, Milera
In: Otten, Doedee, Menzel, Cameron

 

[Scorpus]

Can Doedee play CHB?

Lever can. If not, time to find out.

 

[SydCrow]

Lever can. If not, time to find out.

Levers not big enough I reckon

 

[Scorpus]

A KPD and a small defender for one small defender?

Yep. Restructure the defence, we're not playing a tall team. Otten isn't very good, Keath isn't ready.

Kelly's position shouldn't exist. Add in more rebound with Seedsman instead.

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

Out: Hartigan (hamstring), Beech, Kelly, Mackay
In: Doedee, Seedsman, Gallucci, Cameron

Doedee is playing a blinder today in the SANFL according to the stats sheet.

Beech is not AFL quality. Kelly is not AFL quality. Mackay is not SANFL quality.

Lynch in instead of Gallucci if he is fit too

I hate to day DMac was better than Milera

 

[Scorpus]

I hate to day DMac was better than Milera

Who cares when we know Mackay isn't AFL quality?

Drop Milera as well but first correct the team by selecting AFL-standard players

 

[TheLeftFist8]

Poor performers today

Greenwood Milera gov beech Atkins tex Sloane (was ok but needs to provide more as does tex)

Definetly need some toughness if cheney has a good game has to come in Thommo needs to be part of the mid for toughness don't bring in soft arses


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

We smashed Carlton in clearances despite Jacobs ineptitude and terrible centre set ups...why do we need Thompson?

Spot on that Atkins and Milera were disgusting...however Mackay was also poor (don't just say he got 21 touches, he was crap)...one of those 3 has no higher ceiling so Mackay should be out.

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

Beech and Hartigan for starters.

Milera has been off it for a while now.

Kelly just too slow to think, doesn't have afl reflexes.