Changes - Round 18 vs Brisbane

[Ochre]

Wasn't A. Selwood on Thompson? A bloke who has been averaging like 40 possessions a week. And Selwood kept him to practically nothing.

Selwood kept him to 28, his past month before that was 28, 32, 32 and 28.

 

[Gizza]

Selwood kept him to 28, his past month before that was 28, 32, 32 and 28.

Oh, not that fantastic then. I just remember the commentators at one point in the game commenting on how well he was being held. Perhaps the floodgates opened later in the game.

 

[Boozetown]

Long time reader, rare poster. Can't believe some of the uninformed biased opinions on here. Lynch and hams will not be dropped, Adam selwood won't either as he offers a contest back, forward, or middle. There is 18 on the field not every player can be top 10. Shuey and hill will come in two will go out and unfortunately for our overly reactive posters it probably won't be team players like a. Selwood or mcginnity as they have proven themselves with effort (not skill) in multiple positions.

 

[Chris_6678]

Hams had 3 goals he will not be dropped!

 

[Hairy Lager]

Bay is that way. Trolling your own?

Out: Newman, Hams
In: Shuey, Hill

This is from radio commentary mostly, so I could be wrong.

Sorry just tring to get a funny comment out of HB, he usually has something more to add than" right".... but it obviously backfired...to be expected after that loss...Jezz...no sense of humour on the WCE site tonight. I know I am not so funny either. Sorry

 

[Butler]

Hams may have kicked 3 goals but didn't 2 of them come late? His defensive pressure is horrible for a small forward. He won't get dropped but i can't wait for Lecras and co to return and push him out of the side.

Don't understand why people want Newman out either. His chasing and tackling is very good and he is perfectly suited to being the sub.

In: Hill, Shuey
Out: Mcginnity, one of the defenders.

Masten should also be given longer stints in the middle.

 

[Gizza]

Hams had 3 goals he will not be dropped!

2 were in junk time though.

 

[Lewis28]

Out- McGinnity, Newman, Brennan
In - Hill, Shuey, Dick

Brennan unlucky but I think we have too many HBF at the moment and for me it's him or Sheppard and I think at this stage Shep offers a bit more.

 

[larrikin]

There's some great discussion in this thread, there's some humour, and there's also some incredible hyperbole.
We're cool with all of those things, what we aren't cool with is WCE fans eating their own. Be respectful, have fun and you'll be fine.

 

[new breed]

I thought Newman showed a bit again , real competitor I lke the look of him . When Newman gets on a run he could kick multiple goals one day !

Brad Dick could come in, but Swans were thrashed with no pressure for EF , Dick kick goals running free into the goal sqaure .

 

[FLETCH41]

Strongly disagree with the notion of dropping Adam Selwood..he had a shank but hey so did a few other players! Why drop him after a poor game when others aren't? I thought he wasn't that bad!

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Smith Weedon Brown Dick. Strijk three for mine.

 

[Alexwce]

OUT: Rosa, McGinnity, Newman
IN: Hill, Shuey, Dalziell/Stevenson

 

[Eastern Rangers]

I thought Newman showed a bit again , real competitor I lke the look of him . When Newman gets on a run he could kick multiple goals one day !

Brad Dick could come in, but Swans were thrashed with no pressure for EF , Dick kick goals running free into the goal sqaure .

In the long term he will be one of our more dangerous midfielders/ forwards. But at the moment he's only getting games because of injuries.

On Hams, he was poor today as he's been all season. Isn't really a small forward, he can't find space when eye plays forward of centre and he goes to ground so easily.

 

[footballfreak]

Out: Mcginnity, Butler
In: Shuey, Smith

 

[WCFaithful]

Smith Weedon Brown Dick. Strijk three for mine.

maybe he was trying to wash it

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Out: Newman, Brennan
In: Hill, Shuey

B: Waters, Glass, Schofield
HB: Hurn, MacKenzie, A.Selwood
C: Rosa, Kerr, Gaff
HF: Masten, Lynch, Sheppard
F: Cox, Darling, Hill
R: Naitanui, Shuey, S.Selwood
I: Priddis, Butler, McGinnity
S: Hams
E: McInnes, Brennan, Newman (Smith, Swift, Stevens, Stevenson, Dick, Brown etc etc)

What I expect will happen more than what I would like to happen.

 

[bodazoka]

You all know McGinnity will keep his spot right?

In: Hill, Shuey
Out: Newman, Brennan

 

[Biggie]

Wonder if Shuey comes straight back in after his lack of discipline?

Just a thought, be gentle

 

[sTeeL]

Who needs a mid that can win a clearance hey.

 

[HoneyBadger35]

You all know McGinnity will keep his spot right?

In: Hill, Shuey
Out: Newman, Brennan

He will, but these threads are more about hopes and dreams and innocence and less about the skull crushing realisation that my once favourite player is not even close to best 22 anymore and needs to be dropped.

Brennan unlucky in the above.

 

[bodazoka]

He will, but these threads are more about hopes and dreams and innocence and less about the skull crushing realisation that my once favourite player is not even close to best 22 anymore and needs to be dropped.

Brennan unlucky in the above.

Haha I like it.

Yeah... Either Brennan, Butler or A.Selwood out for Shuey.

 

[Biggie]

Who needs a mid that can win a clearance hey.

 

[Belltower]

Out - lack of desperation and intensity
In - the opposite

Out Mcginnity
In Shuey

I think we need to refresh the side and make a few changes but I can't decide who to drop. Depends on the availabilty of Hill/Smith etc. We have a plethora of defenders but have allowed over a 100 points in the last 2 games, maybe bring in a few more mids and change it up more often with priddis and scott spending more time on the bench to freshen them up.
Other candidates for being dropped are Butler (was good but is not desperate enough), brennan, newman,rosa, hams(kicked 3 goals but laid 1 tackle). The lack of pressure in the forward line overall is disappointing, Darling who is our best chaser laid none.

 

[larrikin]

Wonder if Shuey comes straight back in after his lack of discipline?

Just a thought, be gentle

A clearance winner with class and poise should definitely play WAFL.