Preview Changes round 9 vs West Coast Eagles

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Ahh bleddy knew it. Matt Crouch a few weeks back was listed as 1-2 weeks..well here we are 2 weeks later and now it seems the injury is on another seetback and its not 1-2 weeks at all..I am expecting him to be listed as an indefinite soon and we will be lucky to see him this year
Tex is not going West so one particular poster got it wrong again.
 
Listening to Nicksy's presser it's looking like Vader might be wrong about us not going hard in the MSD. Bailey Lambert might be it given Nicksy seems to favour looking for more nip up forward.
I'm quite happy to be wrong on this one!
 
Yeah I wouldn't rush him back. Hamill had most of the year off although he had a previous concussion as well from memory. We are finishing bottom 3 so why rush him back. Yeah I was serious he isn't critical to our team. He is a developing small pressure forward who is still finding his feet. Not exactly a star of our team.
I know you are a very passionate supporter
I questioned your seriousness because in your ORIGINAL post
1. You suggested Knarlin Ned needed 3 weeks off. Neither you and I belong to the Crows medical team and concussion specialists follow the protocols
2. You suggested that Ned was not important to our team. Well he has demonstrated that he is
Growing and developing
He is going to be hard to replace

Regards
 
Any other morsels from the presser? I'll be disappointed if we don't have at least 1 debutante.

Sounded like Frampton in. Jones a possibility also.
 
Any other morsels from the presser? I'll be disappointed if we don't have at least 1 debutante.
I posted the presser on the previous page, sounds like we're going hard in the MSD if the players we have interest in are available at our picks.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Ahh bleddy knew it. Matt Crouch a few weeks back was listed as 1-2 weeks..well here we are 2 weeks later and now it seems the injury is on another seetback and its not 1-2 weeks at all..I am expecting him to be listed as an indefinite soon and we will be lucky to see him this year
Do you know how injuries actually work?
 
Long term I think that's how I would like it but would rather thilthorpe not have the 2nd defender at this point. I also like frampton cause he can crash a pack which we don't otherwise have. I saw your other post on Mcadam and statistically he had his best games prior to being dropped. I think it was the emotional reaction from the giants loss that made him a scape goat. The only thing is like you mentioned if he comes back in we probably can't play Frampton/ berg
Frampton>>>>>>>>>>Berg...
but not by much 😜
 
Do you know how injuries actually work?
Absolutely, but like Mutineer notes it is recovery from surgery. But it is getting the feel of the of the Brad Crouch fiasco where he was listed for 3 weeks, come three weeks he is listed for another 2 weeks, then come that 2 weeks he is then listed for another 3 weeks..
 
Listening to the presser now. Nicks mentions bringing in players that are 'showing our team values at SANFL level, and playing with confidence that deserve to come into the team..'

He then went on to say that they were doing team selection after the presser.

Sounds to me like a debutante.

edit: Chayce Jones & Frampton unlikely but are close. From having listened the whole presser it sounds like they haven't actually finalised the team at all.
 
Last edited:
Soft option.

McAdam has been seven shades of sh*te, but it's what you'd expect us to do.

Are you really this dumb? McAdam is a small/medium sized forward who is available to be selected when we literally have no other depth options available.

He will come in, and rightly so, along with a shuffle of other players.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top