Remove this Banner Ad

Changes v Brisbane

Do you think Scott Thompson WILL come in this week?


  • Total voters
    95
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

  • Thread starter
  • Moderator
  • #55
We have 2 games to form an opinion and I want to see those players that failed us in both dropped.

Don't care what people say about Menzel or milera performan, if I see either or both bare the brunt of the selection committee, I'm done.

Milera was a top 5 player for us tonight
 
We all know deep down come thursday david mackay will be named on the wing in the starting 18.
Not this week. Not after that performance. The last couple of games have obliterated any brownie points he'd built up at the start of the season... I can't possibly see how there aren't 3-4 changes this week, and one of them has to be Mackay.
 
I generally agree with your posts, but no he didn't. Granted, a few were awful, but not at all close to 'every single possession' - and I made note of his performance closely.

Please post video of a kick or handball that hit a target. He had 11 touches. In my opinion all of them were either clear errors or placed teammates under unnecessary pressure. Maybe I missed one.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Moderator
  • #61
Why Otten instead of Jenkins? I'm intrigued as to why people are thinking this. Jenkins has been pretty bad since he's come back from injury.

Because Otten is too slow to play AFL football
 
I generally agree with your posts, but no he didn't. Granted, a few were awful, but not at all close to 'every single possession' - and I made note of his performance closely.
No. Every single one. And that's not even counting missed tackles or fumbles
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Please post video of a kick or handball that hit a target. He had 11 touches. In my opinion all of them were either clear errors or placed teammates under unnecessary pressure. Maybe I missed one.

You know I'm not going to put myself the horror of that game again just to dig up a video. You've got to trust me on this, in that I clearly recall some effective possessions.
 
Please post video of a kick or handball that hit a target. He had 11 touches. In my opinion all of them were either clear errors or placed teammates under unnecessary pressure. Maybe I missed one.
He didn't have a great game disposal wise, but there were pussies out there that plainly gave up, they were waiving the white flag, behaving like embarrassing scared little kids.

Despite his poor execution, Menzel didn't give up nor did he back down.

I would drop a number of these weak ass clowns over him who have embarrassed us over the course of these two weeks.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Pyke needs to make at least 4 changes.

Jenkins for Lever - Otten fwd, Jenkins is back to where he was when he was fighting for a spot with McKernan
Hampton for someone - CEY was better than this ****
Menzel out blew his shot at AFL and bad haircut. Anyone in
MacKay for Wigg, I don't care if Wigg butchers every kick at least he wont crap himself when theres a contest
 
I say with Sloane getting tagged and it hurting our power out of the clearences we need to move Smith into the guts. Play Wigg at half back and add Smithers foot power in where we need it.

May as well.... i don't see anyone else stepping up to the plate
 
Pyke needs to make at least 4 changes.

Jenkins for Lever - Otten fwd, Jenkins is back to where he was when he was fighting for a spot with McKernan
Hampton for someone - CEY was better than this ****
Menzel out blew his shot at AFL and bad haircut. Anyone in
MacKay for Wigg, I don't care if Wigg butchers every kick at least he wont crap himself when theres a contest
Spot on.

Out: Jenkins, Menzel, MacKay, Hampton
In: Lever, Greenwood, Wigg, Beech

Bottom line is those boys wouldn't do any worse than these spuds who played tonight and disgraced themselves and their club. Menzel is a waste of talent, Jenkins is a waste of a body that big, MacKay is a waste of space and Hampton is just not playing well enough.
 
Has anyone seen Charlie Cameron since round 4? That tackling pressure...gone!

OUT: Cameron, Otten, MacKay
IN: Greenwood, Lever, Poholke (does the club see him closer to ready than Gallucci?)

LUCKY: Jacobs (you had no ruckman to play against and tap straight down every time FFS), Jenkins (could be him not Otten), Hampton, Kelly (get fit Cheney/Doedee), Hartigan. Menzel have a few games to settle.
Our lack of selection changes over the years leaves us with a lot of players with 0 AFL game players outside of this team, so how many changes can you make after two pathetic performances?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Changes v Brisbane

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top