Changes v Collingwood

[simmo_bc]

how about asking Phil Anselmo, ex Pantera, if he wants a game? someone to fire the lads up.

I still think Ryder and Lobbe look lost in the same team together.

I am warming to the idea of giving someone like harvey a crack in the AFL - can't see why not, they said Krakouer wasn't AFL match ready one week and picked him the next.

 

[RossFC]

There comes a point where you need to make changes

IN: Sam Gray

 

[PatientMental]

Out: Everyone but Gray, Westhoff, Hombsch and Wingard.
In: 18 players who give a shit.

 

[DazzaTys]

Jonas for Clurey
Broadbent for Amon
Schulz for Harvey

Love the changes, spot on.

 

[Capital Power]

With little now but a slim mathematical chance of playing finals this year, its time to assess who on our list is part of our next premiership team. Trouble is, as many have said, there aren't a lot in the twos with their hands up right now. It's also time to give some of the established players a chance to recover some form and confidence.

We need to persist with Lobbe and Ryder, although they have yet to hit any kind of synergy.

Clurey in for Jonas, Amon for Impey, Trengove for Broadbent. Krak sub, give Moore a few games to determine whether he's going to make it or not. Butcher for Schulz if suspended, for the same reason. It would seem the line is already drawn through Mitchell, and I can't find a place for Sam Gray. New boots and a role further forward for Pittard, too many momentum killers from him.

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

IN: Sam Gray

Don't even joke about that. If that happened i dont know what i would do

 

[FishingRick04]

You know. I almost want Jacko to ruck a whole game just to see some aggression at the contest. Even though we all dint want hi rucking. At least he will attack

 

[cortez]

Out: wife and kids
In: Thursday night beers and footy

 

[ClintEastwood]

I need to watch the replay first, but for now...

Jonas 100% must go.
Monfries, Shulz, Lobbe, Broadbent, Pittard should all be in danger too.

 

[tim cotrill]

yet we'll see the same side next week so what's your point lol?

 

[port always]

Stewy aint going anywhere...Highest disposal efficiency in the team and from what I could see played every position including Full back when Bobby was dragged,...good attack on the ball and SMART..Moorey is a worry and Hoons defensive work is non existent...For me

Out Schulz ( suspended ) Moore

In Trengove Neade (which mans Ryder full forward and Lobbe to 80% ruck)

Guaranteed

 

[RossFC]

Can only see at most 4 players out.

Jonas due to form.

Schulz and Broadbent possibly suspended.

Bobby Carlile was subbed out is he injured?

 

[LFC2010]

Out - Schulz (SUS) we should expect 1, maybe 2. More likely 2 going on past sanctions. (not that I'll agree with it, but understand at the same time cause of the end result)
In - Anyone who can kick a goal edit: Anyone who can kick full stop

Out - Jonas
In - Clurey

Sadly Pittard has to stay until White comes back from Injury.
then Pittard goes.

 

[ClintEastwood]

Hoons defensive work is non existent...For me

Glad I'm not the only one.

 

[LFC2010]

Can only see at most 4 players out.

Jonas due to form.

Schulz and Broadbent possibly suspended.

Bobby Carlile was subbed out is he injured?

Broadbent wont get suspended, it'll be most likely a fine only, and it's all it deserves.
Who was the Richmond player that interfered with Trengove when he got injured in that game, pretty certain he only got a fine, and that contact was much more severe than what Broadbent did.

 

[WHOME]

Out: Impey, Jonas, Ebert, Carlile, Lobbe, Monfries, Schulz, Broadbent
In: Neade, Amon, Clurey, Trengove, Harvey, Young, O'Shea, Palmer (yeah I know, some of these guys aren't ready for AFL, but can they honestly be any worse than the outs, and if they are at least most of them have an excuse)

 

[drcollossimo]

yet we'll see the same side next week so what's your point lol?

snap I thought the same thing Kern YOUVE been picking the same core 18 relentlessly all year!

 

[drcollossimo]

Can only see at most 4 players out.

Jonas due to form.

Schulz and Broadbent possibly suspended.

Bobby Carlile was subbed out is he injured?

Bob looked like he pulled a heart muscle

 

[FallingLiefs]

Impey being dropped after his last 3 games before this is lunacy.

 

[RussellEbertHandball]

WE play in the SANFL on Saturday and AFL on Thursday night. Ken will not bring in more than 1 player who plays on Saturday after only a 5 say rest, despite being the fittest team in the land.

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

Glad I'm not the only one.

i agree. im not really a hoon fan like the rest of the people here. but he is young, so ill hold judgement for now

 

[Ljc_86]

Out: Schulz
In: Redden

4th man up!!!


Seriously though, I'd probably drop Moore and jonas for trengrove and Mitchell.

 

[ClintEastwood]

i agree. im not really a hoon fan like the rest of the people here. but he is young, so ill hold judgement for now

I'm not against the kid, I think he may have potential, but a few things he did tonight (or didn't do), really pissed me the hell off.

 

[Forzaport]

Surely Jonas can't play next week. How can a player fall so far so quickly?

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

People dropping impey make me laugh