Opinion Changes V Dees

[frenchconnection]

No side in the league can carry Priddis, Hutchings, Redden and McGinnity in one side so I think 2 of them need to go.

Hutchings for Sheed
Redden or McGinnity for Jetta
McKenzie for Brown - has Brown played his last game for the club? - Has no role.

Has everybody forgotten about Nelson? Notice he's not getting much of a mention to be recalled. At least he's got some hunger for the ball and did well in a tagging role.

 

[Eastern Rangers]

Giles and Lycett is a horrible idea. At least Brown can compete at ground level.

 

[kranky al]

If people still think mcginnity brings anything to the table you have no footy nous. Without a doubt one of the worst players in the league.

Out mcginnity hutch redden

In sheed duggan nelson

Maybe emac for barass or schofield.



Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

Nobody thinks macginnity brings anything more than pressure from below in the wafl on out of form players - in case you hadnt notice we dont have many east perth players bashing down the doors. Add that to a lack of hunger from a few in the best 22 and voila - mcginnity

Hes an object lesson not the object.

Mcgoo is depth who can be thrown around a bit and USUALLY shows some mongrel.

The fact that hes playing says more about where we are at this year than anything else

 

[ArdentEagle]

Hutchings for Adamson
McGinnity for Karpany
Schofield for Emac

Brown stays in as he can at least provide pressure around the ground.

 

[JackOutback]

Is Sheed ready yet for AFL. He has been out for a long time and has only had 2-3 weeks back at WAFL. From my understanding was tagged heavily yesterday and did not set the world on fire.

There's only six games left in the regular season and he could be a valuable contributor come finals time. Melbourne at home is the kind of game where we an carry him into finding form.

 

[Athlete]

Seriously, it is time. The lad is tough in the clinches, runs hard into space and hits up targets.

Agree time to reward consistent very good performances.Sheed not ready, Duggan having the same problem finding the ball in his WAFL games.

 

[ziad]

Given the average performance we just saw and the apparent good form of those in the WAFL, here's a silly yet satisfying swing of the sword:

In: Emac, Jetta, Sheed, Nelson, Giles
Out: Schofield, McGinnity, Redden, Hutchings, Brown

Adamson as emergency at the very least please.

the apparent good form of those in the WAFL is more imaginary that real based on all stays are reports

 

[WCErevival]

Is Sheed ready yet for AFL. He has been out for a long time and has only had 2-3 weeks back at WAFL. From my understanding was tagged heavily yesterday and did not set the world on fire.

3 games now at WAFL which is enough. And yeah he was tagged yesterday in rubbish conditions but he wont be tagged at AFL level. He was a regular in our team last year and if we want him going for finals and the last few games against top opposition we should play him now. He has to be better than the Hutch and Redden combo.

 

[frenchconnection]

There's only six games left in the regular season and he could be a valuable contributor come finals time. Melbourne at home is the kind of game where we an carry him into finding form.

Okay, maybe you're right. Perhaps use him on limited minutes if he starts blowing out. In an ideal world just think he could do with one more game in the WAFL before being recalled.

 

[frenchconnection]

Agree time to reward consistent very good performances.Sheed not ready, Duggan having the same problem finding the ball in his WAFL games.

I wonder why Duggan has fallen off the way he has this year. Has he just got the second year blues which appears to be quite prevalent amongst young players.

 

[new breed]

IN - Jetta , Mackenzie

OUT - McGovern ( thumb inj ) Priddis ( quad inj )

If Pridda does miss then Redden gets his chance maybe

 

[SpaceClef]

I wonder why Duggan has fallen off the way he has this year. Has he just got the second year blues which appears to be quite prevalent amongst young players.

Been facing east in pics

EDIT: actually I think he's just been hanging out with Redden too much

 

[WCErevival]

I think Duggan needs more time to gain some strength. He still looks like a kid out there.

 

[Ok Boomer]

Karpany is our saviour.

In - Karps, Sheed, Jetta
Out - Redden, Hutchings, Ginners.

 

[Karim Abdul Yeo]

Has everybody forgotten about Nelson? Notice he's not getting much of a mention to be recalled. At least he's got some hunger for the ball and did well in a tagging role.

Yeah! I still do not understand why simmo got rid off him. One of the few guys with hunger and aggression.

 

[DickDunn]

Out: McGinnity, Brown, Redden
In: Jetta, Mackenzie, Sheed

 

[daddy_4_eyes]

Duggan is very bottom age, only scraped into his draft year by 3 weeks. Probably a fairer comparison would be to this years draftees, so I don't think he's doing too bad.

 

[Marlin01]

Nelson has been dropped a few times now and can consider himself very unlucky every time.

 

[JA56]

Out: In:
McGinnity Karpany
Redden Sheed
Hutchings Nelson

Butler Barrass Sheppard
Hurn McGovern Wellingham
Gaff Priddis Masten
Hill Darling Lecras
Cripps Kennedy Karapany

Ruck: Lycett Yeo Shuey
Int: Brown Sheed Schofield Nelson

 

[Godfather32]

Out: Redden, Hutchings, McGinnity
In: Nelson, Adamson, Emac
McGovern to the forward line for a game or two

 

[Winky]

Giles is more of a number 2 ruck than Mitch bloody Brown.

Giles is a plodder.

 

[Athlete]

Out: Redden, Hutchings, McGinnity
In: Nelson, Adamson, Emac
McGovern to the forward line for a game or two

Agree adds some pace ,strength ,and ,experience.

 

[The Stid]

Out: Hutchings, McGinnity, Brown, Redden
In: Karpany, Adamson, Nelson, Jetta

I can imagine the quality of the melts the facebookers will have if the above IN'S and OUT'S happened. Even though they'll probably all be dropped in favour of those coming out this week for the Collingwood game next week.

 

[Godfather32]

Out: Hutchings, McGinnity, Brown, Redden
In: Karpany, Adamson, Nelson, Jetta

I can imagine the quality of the melts the facebookers will have if the above IN'S and OUT'S happened. Even though they'll probably all be dropped in favour of those coming out this week for the Collingwood game next week.

Who backs up Lycett in the ruck?

 

[The Stid]

Who backs up Lycett in the ruck?

Yeah, nah. Good point. Forgot about that, Journeyman instead of one of the above IN'S.