Remove this Banner Ad

Prediction Changes V Essendon

  • Thread starter Thread starter avishka5
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

This is our injury list:

Hamish Brayshaw (knee) test - Played on the weekend
Jack Darling (ankle) 5 weeks
Malcolm Karpany (ITB friction) TBA
Eric Mackenzie (toe) test - Played on the weekend
Tony Olango* (ankle) test - Played on the weekend
Daniel Venables (ankle) 2-3 weeks

That is 3 on the injury list and a sore JK with only one of those as a best 22 with Venners on the fringe.

As long as we dont get any more injuries we should look good heading into the finals.

Shuey and Ryan looked rusty as hell but which is no surprise as they not played for a while ( Shuey 5 and Ryan 8) but they should be better for it.
Yep some fans were bagging Shuey have short memories, he missed 5 weeks and played a red hot team like Sydney. He will be better for the run same for Ryan.
 
Out Nelson Sheed Cripps Brander
In ah chee Hutchings Barass Ainsworth

WE needed more mids v Sydney. Nelson is not giving us enough and I am a big fan of Sheed but he was lamentable. Cripps is not kicking enough goals for a small forward and we already have Lecras Willie and Ryan. Lycett and Nic can spend more time forward
 
In: Ah Chee, Petrucelle
Out: Sheed, Brander

Nelson did plenty of good things against Sydney, deserves to keep his spot. Jetta firmly on notice

Defensively nelson wasn't great, there small forwards kicked a few. Jetta kicking out from goal relieves hurn, that kick that hit masten was awesome. WE know he needs to be more but he is there to allow us to release hurn, I would pick him ahead of nelson at this stage
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Bringing in two guys off a five-day break, including one 19 year old who's in his first AFL season and has played only one senior game? Yeah that'll go well.

Breaks are overrated. Sydney had a 6 day break, beat us off a bye. Fremantle did the same to Carlton. Ainsworth has a tank, ahchee is building fitness, both could play this week.
 
Honestly don't see the point of dropping Brander now.

We brought him in against Sydney: a super hard task. Now we drop him at home against easier opposition?

May as well stick with him till Darling gets back and find out if he has what we need.

We don't need to start chopping and changing after one close loss to a good team.
 
Honestly don't see the point of dropping Brander now.

We brought him in against Sydney: a super hard task. Now we drop him at home against easier opposition?

May as well stick with him till Darling gets back and find out if he has what we need.

We don't need to start chopping and changing after one close loss to a good team.

I think the only reason could be wet weather. If it's wet on Thursday I'd like to see:
- Ah Chee for Brander
- Barrass for Nelson
- Hutchings for Sheed

If Kennedy comes out (and it's wet) then I'd be happy to back Brander in (rather than bring in McInnes).
 
Don’t drop Brander after only one game.

The way my Boy Jarrod Brander played below his knees in the wet conditions East Perth V West Perth should allay all fears that being a tall will limit his ground running and his skills below his knees, if it rains.
Those who watched that game will back this up.

Similarly I watched him down at Moss Street earlier in the year when EP v EF in the wet slippery conditions earlier in the year. JB played very well at ground level and from memory kick 3 goals.

JB has a big tank and runs far and wide all day hence the comparisons to him and Saint Nick Riewoldt , rain won’t hamper his efforts.

Whilst his 5 possessions were nothing spectacular last Friday I would like to see him get another game.

As a general comment our ball movement into the forward line against Sydney was “so shit” you would be a hard task master to pay out on the forwards based on that delivery .
 
I think the only reason could be wet weather. If it's wet on Thursday I'd like to see:
- Ah Chee for Brander
- Barrass for Nelson
- Hutchings for Sheed

If Kennedy comes out (and it's wet) then I'd be happy to back Brander in (rather than bring in McInnes).
Yep agree, Achee is the big body that can play in the guts, Hutch/or petrcacellue love his pace, Barras definitely shows how critical he is to the team, it made Hurn, Gov and Shep defend alot more one on one.
 
Yep agree, Achee is the big body that can play in the guts, Hutch/or petrcacellue love his pace, Barras definitely shows how critical he is to the team, it made Hurn, Gov and Shep defend alot more one on one.

I think Ah Chee is a good 7th forward (who would end up spending a lot of time running through the middle). Can provide an option out of the backline, and also play a role around the clearances.
 

Remove this Banner Ad


Didn't one of the players say something about Darling being fine in a tweet on the Monday after the Saints game, then nek minnit = out for 4-6 weeks?
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Gotta stick with Brander now. You need to give him a chance to regain confidence this week. It's always hard to beat Sydney, in Sydney, on their Auskick size oval, after a break and bringing back a few players.

People argue that the break freshens players, but it really disrupts momentum.

Out: Sheed, Nelson
In: Ah Chee, Partington
 
Last edited:
People who don't want Hutchings in this week, would love to hear why you wouldn't want him in to tag?

Their prime movers in the midfield this year are Zerrett and Heppell (not sure on his fitness this week after concussion) - both have struggled to break a tag or to lift under close attention this year.

Other than these two there's mostly yoof picking up the slack, other than some honest triers in Myers and Devon Smith.

For most matches I'm pretty keen to back Sheed's development over Hutch, even if he stinks it up a bit sometimes. But the benefits of shutting down one of their better mids this week is wayyy too promising to pass up.
Hutchings tagging should be a good thing as he also gets his share of the ball. The problem is that more often than not, he then turns it over. So, in effect he is stopping one of the opposition guns from getting as much ball and then doing their job for them by giving it to one of their team mates. There have been games where his disposal has been more effective and as he gives his absolute all you can't help feeling hopeful that form will continue but...sigh! Oh well at least he is a competitor and can run and tackle and make position around the ground. Not a bad player but when there are several options you tend to go with the ones that use the ball well...….except for one well known player of course.
 
Defensively nelson wasn't great, there small forwards kicked a few. Jetta kicking out from goal relieves hurn, that kick that hit masten was awesome. WE know he needs to be more but he is there to allow us to release hurn, I would pick him ahead of nelson at this stage
Nelson was in our top 5 and has been good this year.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom