Remove this Banner Ad

Prediction Changes v GCs

What hilarious changes will we make this week?

  • Out: RO'B, In: Jacobs

    Votes: 36 35.0%
  • Out: CE-Y

    Votes: 50 48.5%
  • Out: Jenkins

    Votes: 61 59.2%
  • Out: Kelly

    Votes: 26 25.2%
  • Out: Murphy

    Votes: 71 68.9%
  • In: Stengle

    Votes: 57 55.3%
  • In: Himmelberg

    Votes: 31 30.1%
  • In: The FOG

    Votes: 23 22.3%
  • Out: Mackay

    Votes: 26 25.2%
  • In: Gibbs

    Votes: 66 64.1%
  • In: Wilson

    Votes: 9 8.7%
  • In: Greenwood

    Votes: 87 84.5%

  • Total voters
    103

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

How the **** does Murphy stay in as a small forward?

We keep our shitty defensive structure.

Our selectors are shit, stupid and gutless

We are obviously pretty far behind the better teams, Essendon are flogging North, Norths only win was against us.

We will not make up ground without trying different tactics and set ups. Himmelberg for Jenkins is about 25% there.
 
We've made the absolute minimum amount of changes.

1 senior player dropped. Couldn't leave Greenwood and Gibbs in the SANFL so needed a further two omissions. Luckily someone got injured and there was a young player to drop. Job done!

Zero risks taken. Plenty of issues left unaddressed

I barely get angry anymore.

They're ****ing weak - this is a cultural issue now, so heavily ingrained that it's a waste of time to even expect meaningful changes.

Pathetic.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Jesus what the hell are we doing with Gallucci

Yeah look if he’s fallen behind the Lachie Murphy we saw making a fool of himself against North, we’ve thrown a first round pick in the bin there.

It was an absolute no-brainer for Gooch to come in, even without the Jones injury.
 
These are the changes we've made since round 1. We've lost three games since then

Out: Doedee (knee), Jones (concussion), Douglas (ankle), Jacobs (knee), Jenkins
In: Ellis-Yolmen, Greenwood, Hartigan, Himmelberg, O'Brien

We've made ONE unforced change and our forced changes include bringing in Hartigan and CEY :huh:

Absolute w***ers.
 
Oh good, we’ve made the slowest team in the league even slower. This will end well.
Done nothing for our lack of forward pressure. 3 tackles in F50 last week now we're even slower.

Stengle really needed to come in. What was the point of recruiting all this pace if we're never going to use it?
 
Solid changes, will be 1 more weather dependant
 
Done nothing for our lack of forward pressure. 3 tackles in F50 last week now we're even slower.

Stengle really needed to come in. What was the point of recruiting all this pace if we're never going to use it?
One thing Stengle doesn't do is defensive pressure.

Frankly I'd like someone to score goals
 
Commentators absolutely tearing strips off North Melbourne during the half time break here

"Embarrassing" repeated a few times.

Just how bad are we?
 
If we brought in Gallucci he would have played forward pocket and have 7 touches, 1 behind and 1 tackle.

I mean he's clearly a midfielder/wing in the SANFL but that's the reality of the situation.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

I'm torn on Murphy.

He made some shocking mistakes, but he was also one of the ONLY players we had who was actually trying to make shit happen.

Sure, it didn't come off for him, and he looked stupid, but at least he was having a red hot crack.

If he is a defender, as has been suggested, then I'd love to see us play him in the bloody role that he is suited to.
The problem is the mistakes he's making are fundemental things, especially against the Roos. Dropping easy marks, not being able to bounce the ball properly, simple things he's stuffing up.
 
Whilst I agree with the dropping of Jenkins, we’ve made our team even slower again which I didn’t think was possible. I don’t understand how we’re content with running first round talent such as Gallucci in the SANFL yet persist with Murphy in the AFL, mind blowing!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 
Is it too early to start a changes vs Saints thread? LOL

Out: Hartigan, Kelly, Mackay, Murphy, Ellis-Yolmen

In: Sholl, Fogarty, Gallucci, Jones, Stengle

Would be equally happy for B Davis or McHenry to be one of the ins. The team balance is completely ****ed.
 
Jesus what the hell are we doing with Gallucci
Getting him up to AFL fitness levels I would think, missed a fair chunk of training and we don't have access to his G.P.S. numbers....the fitness staff do. Gallucci will be no different to Greenwood in that regard, when he's ready he'll be an in, Greenwood's best SANFL game was by far and away his last game and he's straight in.
 
These are the changes we've made since round 1. We've lost three games since then

Out: Doedee (knee), Jones (concussion), Douglas (ankle), Jacobs (knee), Jenkins
In: Ellis-Yolmen, Greenwood, Hartigan, Himmelberg, O'Brien

We've made ONE unforced change and our forced changes include bringing in Hartigan and CEY :huh:
Out: Match committee
In: Accountability
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Because we have shit coaches and selectors.
The problem is Pyke locks players into roles during the preseason, especially with youngsters, which gives him the "team balance" excuse to fall back on. We could easily replace Mackay or Atkins with Gallucci and not lose much, but oh, Gallucci is a small forward and team balance won't allow that sort of change.
 
Done nothing for our lack of forward pressure. 3 tackles in F50 last week now we're even slower.

Stengle really needed to come in. What was the point of recruiting all this pace if we're never going to use it?
We seem unable to drop players out of the side indefinitely, or replace them with young blood.

I'm trying to think of a crows player who was in the 22 that has been dropped permanently to make way for a younger recruit in the last decade. (I'm sure there are some)

We give them one or two games a year when someone is injured, then straight back out again to keep players like McKay and Douglas in for "team balance"
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom