Opinion Changes v giants

[fronkalicious]

Out - Gardner
In - trengove

Out - gowers
In - McLean

Out - Lloyd
In - liberatore

Out - jong
In - west

Out - vandermeer
In - Schache

I want to see Naughton go back.

FB: Williams Keath Crozier
HB: JJ Naughton Daniel
C: Richards Macrae Lipinski
HF: McLean Bruce Bonti
FF: west Schache Wallis
R: Trengove Dunkley Smith
IC: libba, suckling, Dale, English

No more bullshit Drink

 

[Virgin Dog]

Out - Gardner
In - trengove

Out - gowers
In - McLean

Out - Lloyd
In - liberatore

Out - jong
In - west

Out - vandermeer
In - Schache

I want to see Naughton go back.

FB: Williams Keath Crozier
HB: JJ Naughton Daniel
C: Richards Macrae Lipinski
HF: McLean Bruce Bonti
FF: west Schache Wallis
R: Trengove Dunkley Smith
IC: libba, suckling, Dale, English

No more bullshit Drink

Strongly disagree on Jong and Vandermeer. Both were among the few who could hold their heads up high today. Jong was close to our best

 

[weltschmerz]

FB: Williams Keath Crozier
HB: JJ Trengove Duryea
C: Macrae Smith Lipinski
HF: Dale Bruce Wallis
FF: Weightman Naughton McLean
R: English Bont Libba
Int: Suckling LeYoung West Vandermeer

 

[Kermit]

Out - Gardner
In - trengove

Out - gowers
In - McLean

Out - Lloyd
In - liberatore

Out - jong
In - west

Out - vandermeer
In - Schache

I want to see Naughton go back.

FB: Williams Keath Crozier
HB: JJ Naughton Daniel
C: Richards Macrae Lipinski
HF: McLean Bruce Bonti
FF: west Schache Wallis
R: Trengove Dunkley Smith
IC: libba, suckling, Dale, English

No more bullshit Drink

Agree with Gardner & Gowers - just not at AFL level
Lloyd had a shocker but he wasn’t alone.
Thought Jong did pretty good - given that there was no easing him back though the VFL - would keep him in.
Vandermeer showed a bit and deserves another run - whether that’s against GWS, I’m not sure. We need Libba and Trengove in - badly.

 

[fronkalicious]

Strongly disagree on Jong and Vandermeer. Both were among the few who could hold their heads up high today. Jong was close to our best

Jong’s s**t and should never play.

Vandermeer was poor. How he plays ahead of guys like West and McLean is a joke.

 

[Leon]

Anyone know what the go is with Tory Dickson?

 

[adogsfan5]

In: McLean, West, Wood, Young, Trengove.

Out: Gardner, Gowers, JJ, Dale, English

 

[Dog 36]

Out - Gardner
In - trengove

Out - gowers
In - McLean

Out - Lloyd
In - liberatore

Out - jong
In - west

Out - vandermeer
In - Schache

I want to see Naughton go back.

FB: Williams Keath Crozier
HB: JJ Naughton Daniel
C: Richards Macrae Lipinski
HF: McLean Bruce Bonti
FF: west Schache Wallis
R: Trengove Dunkley Smith
IC: libba, suckling, Dale, English

No more bullshit Drink

Yep don't disagree.

But I would like to find a place for Cordy or Sweet especially for GWS.

 

[FoochPackage]

English must be dropped. Lack pf agression from a ruckman is unacceptable. Get Sweet in.

 

[lachy]

In: McLean, West, Wood, Young, Trengove.

Out: Gardner, Gowers, JJ, Dale, English

Given Wood is still injured he wont be back. Would swap Wood with Sweet and JJ with Lloyd

On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Boyd oh Boyd]

Out: Gardner, Suckling, Dale, Gowers, Lloyd

In: Le Young, La Young, Weightman, West, McLean

 

[Bulldogs85]

In Trengove , Libba , Weightman, McLean

out Gardner, Lloyd, Gowers, Dale

 

[Mattdougie]

Out - Daniel Gardner Gowers Lloyd Dale Suckling Jong

In - Weightman West Sweet Cordy Libba McLean Duryea


Williams Cordy Keath
Crozier Naughton Duryea
Richards. Libba. McRae
Lipi Sweet. McLean
West. Bruce Wallis
English. Bont. Smith

Dunkley Libba Weightman Vandermeer

 

[Northernsoul74]

I’m worried that it really doesn’t matter all that much who we bring in as the issues run much deeper.

 

[Doggies_13]

Out:

Gardner - not up to it
Gowers - offers nothing
Dale - soft and not anywhere near last years form

In:
Young - give him the chance in one position (kpd) to develop
Trengove - English desperately needs help
Weightman - need speed and a spark in the forward line.

B: Williams young suckling
HB: crozier keath JJ
C : macare Bont Vandermeer
Hf: Lloyd naughton Richards
F: weightman Bruce English
R: Trengove smith Dunkley
Int: lipinski Jong Wallis Daniel

 

[TommyD13]

OUT
Gardner- s**t
Gowers- s**t
Dale- weak as piss
Lloyd- weak as piss
JJ- weak as piss
Suckling- weak as piss
IN
McLean- not s**t
Dickson- not s**t
Libba- not weak as piss
West- not weak as piss
Cordy- not weak as piss
Trengove- not weak as piss

 

[adogsfan5]

Given Wood is still injured he wont be back. Would swap Wood with Sweet and JJ with Lloyd

On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

JJ doesn’t deserve another gig next week

 

[cecil]

Out: Gardner, Jong, Gowers, Lloyd
In: Trengove, Libba, Wood, Maclean

FB: Wood, Trengove, Crozier
HB: Williams, Keath, JJ
C: Richards, Bont, Macrae
HF: Daniel, Naughton, Lipinski
FF: Wallis, Bruce, Dale
R: English, Dunkley, Smith
INT: Libba, Suckling, Vandermeer, Maclean

Gardner, Jong and Gowers to never return.
Daniel to go back to his 2016 role kicking into 50. He is holding up our ball movement down back.
Macrae to play more outside minutes. Smith needs to stay in the center to provide xfactor.
Trengove to be FB. Keath isn't a lockdown defender.
Trengove and Libba are hard at it, and Wood is a natural leader. Both qualities we currently lack and will need vs GWS.
Lloyd has some credits, but has far off it today. Dale has more upside and gets another go, and Wallis was our best forward.
Richards needs to play on the wing every game this year.

 

[Hobdog]

Reckon it almost doesn’t matter who comes in to play forward or back because when we get towelled up at the contest we fall apart everywhere else.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Mattdougie]

Anyone know what the go is with Tory Dickson?

He is 31 and breaking down we do not need to go to that well again

The year is cooked just play the kids Now

 

[lachy]

Out - Daniel Gardner Gowers Lloyd Dale Suckling Jong

In - Weightman West Sweet Cordy Libba McLean Duryea


Williams Cordy Keath
Crozier Naughton Duryea
Richards. Libba. McRae
Lipi Sweet. McLean
West. Bruce Wallis
English. Bont. Smith

Dunkley Libba Weightman Vandermeer

Issue's with this MD Jong was in our best 3. We lost which shows why this is an issue.. not a fan of his but no way is he dropped

Dureya and Libba are both injured. Delete them add Trengrove keep Jong and agree

On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[hatescaptcha]

We need to bring in some enthusiasm and energy. Weightman has it. We could do worse.

In: Weightman
Out: Gowers

In: Schache
Out: Dale

In: Cordy / Le Young (if they actually play him in his actual position in the backline)
Out: Gardner

Really want to drop Lloyd as well. But I feel like he’d get a free pass.



Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Mattdougie]

Issue's with this MD Jong was in our best 3. We lost which shows why this is an issue.. not a fan of his but no way is he dropped

Dureya and Libba are both injured. Delete them add Trengrove keep Jong and agree

On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Jong is in his last year surely and his body will break down So why waste games on him? For the same reason I think they move Suckers and Dicko on.

This year is done so play the kids. I only put Libba in coz he has mongrel that no one else does or I’d finish him up too unfortunately

I’d legit play Libba or Duryea injured before Gowers or Dale

 

[VitalDread]

Out: Bad defence
In: Good defence

 

[cherrypie]

In: Sweet, Libba, McLean
Out: Gardner, Lloyd, Gowers

Naughton to defence (I've been strong on him staying forward but we seriously lack options), Sweet to add aggression in the ruck and English to spend more time forward. Tims marking was decent tonight and I think he can provide more in this setup.

Lloyd and Gowers were both terrible, Dale also poor but swapping 3 forwards at once is probably a stretch.