Opinion Changes v Hawthorn

[Eagle Wrath]

Redden provides leadership and a hardened body .

Yes he is older and lacks the little pace he once had . He is still averaging 22 touches 6 marks 5 tackles 4 clearances

If SPS was averaging those numbers we would be creaming ourselves

Redden adds more to the team than gaff and shuey atm . By all reports he is a great team man also

I wont argue he offers more Gaff. Most of the team do at this point. But Shuey offers a hell of a lot more.

Theres a reason Mitchell slapped the coffee out of Reddens hand that final and Mitchell wont be putting a seconds thought into Reddo tomorrow, except like Gaff on how to exploit him.

 

[CursoryMercenary]

Extremely frustrated at how Rotham has been treated this season. Certainly deserves a spot ahead of Edwards. Was B.O.G again for us in the reserves smashing today.

On SM-G981B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[ziad]

Extremely frustrated at how Rotham has been treated this season. Certainly deserves a spot ahead of Edwards. Was B.O.G again for us in the reserves smashing today.

On SM-G981B using BigFooty.com mobile app

He had no real impact just stats. His disposal and decision making is bad by WAFL standards. Harry took 20+ marks in the WAFL and he isnt great. The reality is that most of our players are good WAFL players but not great match winning WAFL players.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

I just want to know whether Rotham’s form in different roles will see him utilised differently by Simpson, or whether his next chance will be as third tall down back yet again. I’m thinking the latter.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Now I know you must be Simmo or related to him.

Yeah mate, and the eleven posters that agreed with me are all related to him too.

 

[Goroyals22]

Now I know you must be Simmo or related to him.

Top 5? He is more likely top 2 and fighting barass possibly to win it

 

[BeornJ]

I wont argue he offers more Gaff. Most of the team do at this point. But Shuey offers a hell of a lot more.

Theres a reason Mitchell slapped the coffee out of Reddens hand that final and Mitchell wont be putting a seconds thought into Reddo tomorrow, except like Gaff on how to exploit him.

Yeah Redden drinking that iced coffee with extra icecream during the final was stupid

 

[Biggie]

Now I know you must be Simmo or related to him.

Because he thinks one of our consistent mids is likely to be in the top 5 in the B&F?

Pull back on the “you must be related” bullshit and post constructive arguments thanks.

 

[DanWCE]

Because he thinks one of our consistent mids is likely to be in the top 5 in the B&F?

Pull back on the “you must be related” bullshit and post constructive arguments thanks.

 

[Quinz]

Coffee is for closers

 

[Biggie]

Coffee is for closers

Correct

Thread closed