Opinion Changes v Hawthorn

[MAXIMUM GRUNDAGE]

Sure, I still think that Fitzpatrick offers a lot more than Sellar at the moment.

Leigh Williams (even in his present condition) would offer more than Sellar right now.

 

[Eth]

Trengove must be on thin ice.

He has to produce a big one this week, he has been pathetic so far.

You're joking.

 

[Bluelegs]

Trengove must be on thin ice.

He has to produce a big one this week, he has been pathetic so far.

Certainly hasn't been his best. I wouldn't say pathetic.

 

[ThePuppetMaster]

He's hardly been pathetic v2j.

Average, sure... but there's a difference between the two.

 

[Blackas87]

Can't see why Watts and Jurrah shouldn't come in.

Watts was dropped and then came out and performed so strait back in for me. Jurrah played well in first game back should now come strait into the side.

In: Watts, Jurrah, Bennell
Out: Sellar, Dunn, Bail


Would like to see Tapscott play as a defencive forward, Davey to run with Rioli and Bennell to play as a small forward.

 

[MAXIMUM GRUNDAGE]

Can't see why Watts and Jurrah shouldn't come in.

Watts was dropped and then came out and performed so strait back in for me. Jurrah played well in first game back should now come strait into the side.

In: Watts, Jurrah, Bennell
Out: Sellar, Dunn, Bail


Would like to see Tapscott play as a defencive forward, Davey to run with Rioli and Bennell to play as a small forward.

I did consider Jurrah as an in (starting sub), but we've only got a 6 day break and I feel he needs another 2-3 weeks, as he dropped off in the second half. The upcoming court case will be a distraction, and I feel he won't be able to fully focus on football until that is out of the way.

 

[CowboyFromHell]

About as much chance of Scully not being a dog as there is of Jurrah playing this week. These threads shit me sometimes, the amount of stupid ins borders on insanity.

 

[stretcharmstrong]

Starting to detect a faint odour of troll about v2j

 

[viney_2_jurrah]

You're joking.

Far from joking.

name me one good game he has played.

name me one positive thing he has done to impact a game.

He has been woeful.

 

[CowboyFromHell]

Starting to detect a faint odour of troll about v2j

It's just tap_my_scott back with another alias. He will be gone soon enough.

 

[Tulip]

Been unshackled:

Out: Sellar
In: Fitzpat

Bail perhaps out, got a feeling we'll see Watts like we saw Davey

 

[Tulip]

He has been woeful.

Troll B. Correct

Trenners will lift though

 

[WWSD]

Can't see why Watts and Jurrah shouldn't come in.

Watts was dropped and then came out and performed so strait back in for me. Jurrah played well in first game back should now come strait into the side.

In: Watts, Jurrah, Bennell
Out: Sellar, Dunn, Bail


Would like to see Tapscott play as a defencive forward, Davey to run with Rioli and Bennell to play as a small forward.

On current form, Rioli will eat Davey.

 

[Tulip]

Good thing Rioli rarely stays to form

 

[Spirit of 39]

Fitzy has well and truly earnt his spot and MUST play this week for Sellar. This kid is a serious talent and the more he is playing the better he is getting. The people at Casey are wrapt with him.

 

[SuburbanMe]

Nah Sellar MUST Stay because:

Sellar plays because he has a crack, lays tackles, provides a contest and gives Jamar a chop out in the ruck, something Clark won't do at all this year as it's more than clear where Neeld wants to play him and therefore we need a second ruck. I would much rather take Sellar to Geelong than Watts right now.

 

[CowboyFromHell]

Nah Sellar MUST Stay because:

So in two separate threads you, rather than talk the topic, want to play one-upmanship? I admitted, in both, that Sellar was awful so in this case you are making yourself look petty and childish. Not good form mate.

 

[SuburbanMe]

So in two separate threads you, rather than talk the topic, want to play one-upmanship? I admitted, in both, that Sellar was awful so in this case you are making yourself look petty and childish. Not good form mate.

It's called Right of Reply. Would you like me to start a thread with all of your "smart" remarks about my comments on how Riv moves and What i see Jetta being if given more game time?

& Nah mate - you look like the fool here. Cop it on the chin and move on.

 

[CowboyFromHell]

Would you like me to start a thread with all of your "smart" remarks about my comments on how Riv moves and What i see Jetta being if given more game time?

Nah mate - you look like the fool here. Cop it on the chin and move on.

I already did if you had bothered to read both threads.

Your other comments were far, far different from this discussion. Huge difference.

 

[SuburbanMe]

I already did if you had bothered to read both threads.

Your other comments were far, far different from this discussion. Huge difference.

They were different, and you twisted them to fit your agenda.

As I said earlier - It's called right of reply. Sorry lil fella - had to be done.

Now instead of arguing with me here - allow the discussion to get back on topic.

If you've got any other remarks to make - I have a wall - hit it up.

 

[CowboyFromHell]

They were different, and you twisted them to fit your agenda.

As I said earlier - It's called right of reply. Sorry lil fella - had to be done.

Now instead of arguing with me here - allow the discussion to get back on topic.

If you've got any other remarks to make - I have a wall - hit it up.

Replied a day ago to the posters who matter... lil fella.

And I didn't go off topic - you did.

 

[Blackas87]

About as much chance of Scully not being a dog as there is of Jurrah playing this week. These threads shit me sometimes, the amount of stupid ins borders on insanity.

Any reasons why you think he is no chance. Yes he is unfit at the moment but an unfit Jurrah played pretty well on the weekend and would already be a fair bit fitter from the hit out.

The highest score we have kicked this year is 11.12.78. We have struggled to kick a score this year. Mitch Clark is the only player we have that has kicked more than 2 goals in a game this season. We need someone else to step up and there is no better goal kicker on our list than Jurrah. And the opposition would be worried about him and that could open up the game for our other forwards, Clark, Watts and Howe. Jurrah in the side could make a dramatic difference to our forward line.

Casey coach Brent Lovett said He'll be strong contender for next week provided he pulled up well.

 

[CowboyFromHell]

Any reasons why you think he is no chance. Yes he is unfit at the moment but an unfit Jurrah played pretty well on the weekend and would already be a fair bit fitter from the hit out.

The highest score we have kicked this year is 11.12.78. We have struggled to kick a score this year. Mitch Clark is the only player we have that has kicked more than 2 goals in a game this season. We need someone else to step up and there is no better goal kicker on our list than Jurrah. And the opposition would be worried about him and that could open up the game for our other forwards, Clark, Watts and Howe. Jurrah in the side could make a dramatic difference to our forward line.

Casey coach Brent Lovett said He'll be strong contender for next week provided he pulled up well.

It's a shame Lovett has close to no say on selections though.

I'd love Jurrah back in the side more than anything but he is still very unfit and he can't provide the second and third efforts that Neeld requires of the players. Watts being dropped is a strong indication of that. Even Jurrah himself said he needs more time at Casey to get his fitness back.

If he plays very well next week before the two week VFL break then he MAY be an outside chance, but certainly not this week... as much as we would like to see him back in the side!

 

[Demon JP]

Super sub Jurrah - one can wish

 

[SuburbanMe]

Replied a day ago to the posters who matter... lil fella.

And I didn't go off topic - you did.

Mate - I do matter - And who the F--- are you to say I don't?

You've Always gotta have the last say huh?

For a teacher, you could learn a thing or two. You're gonna back chat the wrong person one day.