Changes v Melbourne

[Adz2332]

IN
Bonner Palmer Lobbe

Out
Ah Chee Broadbent Amon

 

[Steve Dore]

NEVER THOUGHT THIS TO BE TRUE, BUT KEN READS THIS BOARD:

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-08-06/hinkley-to-focus-on-youth-and-skills-with-an-eye-to-2017

Because an AFL coach could never have worked that out on his own?

 

[PAFC66]

Lobbe has to come in after last week... But do we throw him up against Hogan in form? Trengrove did well last time.

 

[schmuttt]

We're pretty good at playing you guys into form, be interesting to see what happens on Saturday night. I'm tipping us to have a downer after beating the Hawks, Port by 35.

 

[PAFC66]

We're pretty good at playing you guys into form, be interesting to see what happens on Saturday night. I'm tipping us to have a downer after beating the Hawks, Port by 35.

Nah we are putting players back in the shed. You'll in.

 

[port always]

Lobbes inclusion would irk me...he has a shocker and diinterested when we needed him against Adelaide...and pulls out a good one against Gaza....symptomatic of our year

 

[OneGreatClub]

Lobbes inclusion would irk me...he has a shocker and diinterested when we needed him against Adelaide...and pulls out a good one against Gaza....symptomatic of our year

Nah, we need him in, need to sort out what the hell we want to do ruck wise next year and Jacko needs a bit of a break surely.

 

[Quadzilla]

Lobbe has to come in after last week... But do we throw him up against Hogan in form? Trengrove did well last time.

Do u mean Gawn?

 

[Alberton Proud]

In: " we just have to turn up to work and work really hard and take the brave kick and work really hard"
Out: " we just have to turn up to work and work really hard and take the brave kick and work really hard"

 

[port always]

Nah, we need him in, need to sort out what the hell we want to do ruck wise next year and Jacko needs a bit of a break surely.

If you think that then you are part of the problem

 

[OneGreatClub]

If you think that then you are part of the problem

No, people who are part of the problem are those who think we shouldn't play Lobbe to either hopefully get his trade value up or see if he has got rid of his yips. Did you watch his game yesterday? Yes it was only SANFL and only one game but it was impressive against one of the best SANFL rucks.

 

[SureBuddy]

IN: Lobbe and White
OUT: Stewart and Amon

 

[OneGreatClub]

IN: Lobbe and White
OUT: Stewart and Amon

Did White earn a spot?

 

[port always]

No, people who are part of the problem are those who think we shouldn't play Lobbe to either hopefully get his trade value up or see if he has got rid of his yips. Did you watch his game yesterday? Yes it was only SANFL and only one game but it was impressive against one of the best SANFL rucks.

Was at the game ..and my overall thought was that this was his best GAME for 2 years and why he didnt do that last week when we needed it...will he do better than trengove...no

 

[port always]

Did White earn a spot?

Stewy in best players...how does he lose his spot

 

[Chachi]

Andrew Capel, who I rate, said on the adelaidenow podcast that Chad doesn't think Palmer is ready which surprised me. 1. that he would tell Capel this and 2. that he actually thinks that.

 

[PAFC66]

Do u mean Gawn?

Sorry yes.

 

[manureid]

Heh.. girlfriend asked me my plans for this weekend... daughters netball saturday morning.. apart from that, nothing. Her: not going to the footy? Me: oh shit, we have a home game this week!? Didn't even remember. So yeh....

 

[PAFC66]

If we want Lobbe next year there would be absolutely no reason why we shouldn't play him this week.

 

[PAFC66]

Heh.. girlfriend asked me my plans for this weekend... daughters netball saturday morning.. apart from that, nothing. Her: not going to the footy? Me: oh shit, we have a home game this week!? Didn't even remember. So yeh....

Yeah I'm genuinely worried we'll get under 20k this week

 

[SureBuddy]

Did White earn a spot?

25 touches, 6 clearances. Was probably the 3rd best behind Mitchell and Lobbe.

He is also the kind of player who has plays better with better players around him.

 

[OneGreatClub]

25 touches, 6 clearances. Was probably the 3rd best behind Mitchell and Lobbe.

He is also the kind of player who has plays better with better players around him.

Best stay in the SANFL then

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Lobbe's promotion also has the knock on benefit of letting Frampton lead the Magpie rucks.

 

[Portia]

If Lobbe comes back in the side I'll spew up

 

[edgie]

If Lobbe comes in this week, so be it. He was in good form yesterday.

Truth be told, it's how Schulz should have been managed. He came in too soon and it has likely meant that we've seen the last of him at AFL level.

I dunno about that. The issues being a KPF in the SANFL are well documented. His game before AFL selection was, given that, reasonable enough to select him on.

Perhaps selecting him for a cold wet night though wasn't the best idea.