Preview Changes V St.Kilda

[DREAM TEAM BUFF]

Who comes in & who goes out ?

 

[JP Sauce]

Crouch in for Porps is a must.

Drop Sauce?

 

[Wood_Duck]

Do you get a free sticker or something for starting threads?

 

[King Elvis]

Crouch for Porps.

Martin for Mackay.

Sauce plays, but I'd consider subbing him off next week for a rest.

 

[AFC979810]

Crouch for Porps.

Martin for Mackay.

Sauce plays, but I'd consider subbing him off next week for a rest.

Sub off Sauce against McEvoy?

Should have given Sauce a rest this week. Nothing to gain by playing him this week... Hasn't impressed - looks tired and sluggish.

For me - no changes.

Put Lyons as starting 22 and put Porps as the sub..

Give Crouch a game back in the SANFL and bring him in the following week.

 

[JP Sauce]

Sub off Sauce against McEvoy?

Should have given Sauce a rest this week. Nothing to gain by playing him this week... Hasn't impressed - looks tired and sluggish.

For me - no changes.

Put Lyons as starting 22 and put Porps as the sub..

Give Crouch a game back in the SANFL and bring him in the following week.

I'd rather drop Porps and make Crouch the sub in that scenario.

 

[AFC979810]

I'd rather drop Porps and make Crouch the sub in that scenario.

Wouldn't be too angry, however just feel the game will be a bit closer than people think.

In the dewy second half of a close game I would prefer Porps to come on. With his experience he has more of a chance of impacting the game as coming on as a sub than Crouch.

I think if we play Crouch - we play him for a whole game....

 

[King Elvis]

Are you taking the Mickey?

Porps experience is irrelevant if he's playing like crap and can't get his hands on the footy.

Crouch will give us more than Porps will, same as Lyons has shaded his full game in less than a half today.

 

[DREAM TEAM BUFF]

Do you get a free sticker or something for starting threads?

A badge

 

[1970crow]

Crouch for Porps.

Martin for Mackay.

Sauce plays, but I'd consider subbing him off next week for a rest.

Agree 100%. Just hope there's something wrong with porps that can be repaired.

 

[alex_is_on_fire]

Crouch for Porps

Lynch for Scott Stevens

 

[Paladin]

In Hendo
Out Porps

Crouch 1 game in the SANFL then straight back in.

 

[Dewy006]

Wouldn't be too angry, however just feel the game will be a bit closer than people think.

In the dewy second half of a close game I would prefer Porps to come on. With his experience he has more of a chance of impacting the game as coming on as a sub than Crouch.

I think if we play Crouch - we play him for a whole game....

lolwhut Have you been actively watching Porps lately? Porps would struggle to impact a Snaffle ressies game at the moment, I love the bloke but he offers zero at the moment, must go out, if not for Crouch than Callinan, Hendo or Jaensch.

 

[Hendersloane]

Think they'll give Crouch a week back in the SANFL. Porps needs to go back and have a good month or so with West.
If there are no injuries I think we'll see:

Out Porps
In Henderson

 

[alex_is_on_fire]

Think they'll give Crouch a week back in the SANFL. Porps needs to go back and have a good month or so with West.
If there are no injuries I think we'll see:

Out Porps
In Henderson

Jason Porplizia isn't out of form, he isn't well. I strongly believe his stomach ulcer is still quite bad.

He need to come out of the side, get that right, and then have a very mini pre season. Then spend 2 to 3 weeks at West and then come back for AFL selection.

That's what I would like to see happen.

 

[Glenno23]

1 change only

Out: Porps
In: Hendo (green vest)

Lyons to get a full game

 

[Hendersloane]

Jason Porplizia isn't out of form, he isn't well. I strongly believe his stomach ulcer is still quite bad.

He need to come out if the side, get that right, have a very mini pre season and then spend 2 r 3 weed at West and then come back for AFL selection.

That's what I would like to see happen.

If that is the case I agree, he should have some time off to recover and then go back to West.

 

[Hell Boy6669]

Lyons must start in the guts, future stoppage king

 

[OrdinaryJoel]

IN - Hendo
OUT - Porps

 

[Mismatched]

Yep, Hendo for Porps, that is it.

 

[FR0GGY]

Jason Porplizia isn't out of form, he isn't well. I strongly believe his stomach ulcer is still quite bad.

He need to come out of the side, get that right, and then have a very mini pre season. Then spend 2 to 3 weeks at West and then come back for AFL selection.

That's what I would like to see happen.

Do you have info or is it just a feeling?

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

Crouch in for Porps is a must.

Drop Sauce?

Definitely Crouch in for Porps

Re Sauce, it wasn't a stoppage type of game today and he did what he had to do, not yet back to his best but he was genuinely ok

 

[Carmo]

Lyons must start in the guts, future stoppage king

Of course thats behind Aiden Riley right?

Riley is the only player who carved up all last year in SANFL and still hasn't had much of a gig this year. Arguably better at clearances than the Lyons/Crouch/Laird/Lynch/Martin (the other guys who get a lot of clearances in SANFL).

I know he's injured, but just saying, if you think Lyons is good, lets see Riley given a decent gig.

 

[Hell Boy6669]

Of course thats behind Aiden Riley right?

Riley is the only player who carved up all last year in SANFL and still hasn't had much of a gig this year. Arguably better at clearances than the Lyons/Crouch/Laird/Lynch/Martin (the other guys who get a lot of clearances in SANFL).

I know he's injured, but just saying, if you think Lyons is good, lets see Riley given a decent gig.

I'd like to see Riley get an extended run in the side as well. Who would you take out currently though?

 

[alex_is_on_fire]

Do you have info or is it just a feeling?

Just a feeling as he's too good to be out if form this long and it occurred on the eve of the season.

I fear for his long term future and place at the club if its simply poor form.