Changes v Sydney

[LFC2010]

Is it? Why?

Last night Impey was terrific... If they both go missing in large part of games then that'll become a major problem IMO.

please don't get me wrong, I love Neade as a player, he just needs to improve his consistency.

 

[Power Pete]

Obvious one is Butcher out for Lobbe

next one would be Neade out for Krakouer.
It was obvious last night we can't play both Impey and Neade.

Neade goes missing for large part of games. He needs to improve the gap between his bad and good, otherwise he'll keep on getting exposed at AFL level.

Someone has to go on the long-term injury list for Krakouer to play... he's a rookie listed player.

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

Butcher only comes out if Lobbe is available.

Outside of that:

Out: Neade
In: Young

White Sub.

 

[Jim Dixon]

Someone has to go on the long-term injury list for Krakouer to play... he's a rookie listed player.

Billy Frampton's on the LTI.

http://www.portadelaidefc.com.au/news/2015-04-06/injury-update-round-1

 

[Jack Foster]

Neade tries hard and I like him but he cost us crucial momentum on two occasions last night.

I think he needs to develop more at the magpies.

Young has to be rewarded for his good pre-season. Good solid player.

 

[Tibbs]

It was obvious last night we can't play both Impey and Neade.

Is it? Why?

I second that ... Why the hell not? ... Do they play in the same position?

 

[Jack Grange]

Yep! x2

out: Butcher, Neade (far to many costly turn overs + easy shot for goal)

in : Lobster and Young with Youngy as sub. Monfries must play full game as he is not a sub type player

 

[PJ Power]

Butcher only comes out if Lobbe is available.

Outside of that:

Out: Neade
In: Young

White Sub.

Can the White as sub rule please be enforced until further notice. It should have been for David Rodan in the past, and for Kane Mitchell whenever he has played.
Wingmen/HFs who never play four quarters, but can tear a game apart in one, would seem perfect for the role.

 

[scotty13]

Three changes needed:

In: Lobbe, Young, Adelaide Oval and 50k fans
Out: Butcher, Neade, Subi and 38k ferals

Sub: either White/Monfries with potentially the other being the subbed out player depending on circumstances.

 

[Jack Grange]

out: Butcher, Neade (far to many costly turn overs + easy shot for goal)

in : Lobster and Young with Youngy as sub. Monfries must play full game as he is not a sub type player

Even replying to my own comment...correction
White as sub with Youngy playing FULL game. He as in Youngy is very good inside player which is a must against Swans as has unique ability to drift fwd and kick a goal.
White is off at the moment and a spell as sub will not do him any harm. Will add fresh leg speed when subbed on as he is an impact type player

 

[Power Pete]

Billy Frampton's on the LTI.

http://www.portadelaidefc.com.au/news/2015-04-06/injury-update-round-1

Thanks for that SP. Now all the club has to do is elevate Nathan Krakouer... or will Sam Gray be the one?

 

[finbarr]

Sam Gray is a downgrade on Jake Neade.

 

[Doctor Feel]

Out: tentative chippy chippy, shit midfield work
in: clearances and attacking football

 

[Schulzenfest]

Sam Gray (at AFL level) is a downgrade on Simon Phillips. At least Phillips was quick.

 

[PJ Power]

Sam Gray (at AFL level) is a downgrade on Simon Phillips. At least Phillips was quick.

That's brutal on Sam Gray. Brutal but almost fair. Phillips was a fumbling rabbit at AFL level. Sam Gray doesn't fumble anywhere near as much, but he does two grab everything and definitely lacks Phillips' pace.

 

[Schulzenfest]

On the other hand, that speccy Gray took against the Crows last year was worth the cost of a rookie pick alone. I rated that mark higher than Wingard's.

 

[Pedro59]

I'm a fan of Jakey Neade but Im also not against him improving his craft in the SaNFL
At his best he is a F50 spark but I reckon he needs to be able to hold a tackle

 

[Long live PAFC]

How nasty was Bobby's quad strain? Does Clurey/O'Shea come in?

In: Young, Lobbe, Clurey

Out: Neade, Butcher if Lobbe fit, Carlile if quad at risk.

Emerg: Butcher, Moore, O'Shea.

Sub: White.

Moore, O'Shea to have runs in SANFL before pushing claims - currently Young and Clurey are ahead of them.

Monfries to start as he is a terrible sub.

 

[Smartys Power]

How nasty was Bobby's quad strain? Does Clurey/O'Shea come in?

In: Young, Lobbe, Clurey

Out: Neade, Butcher if Lobbe fit, Carlile if quad at risk.

Emerg: Butcher, Moore, O'Shea.

Sub: White.

Moore, O'Shea to have runs in SANFL before pushing claims - currently Young and Clurey are ahead of them.

Monfries to start as he is a terrible sub.

Carlile just had cramp.

 

[woffy]

How nasty was Bobby's quad strain? Does Clurey/O'Shea come in?

In: Young, Lobbe, Clurey
Out: Neade, Butcher if Lobbe fit, Carlile if quad at risk.
Emerg: Butcher, Moore, O'Shea.
Sub: White.
Moore, O'Shea to have runs in SANFL before pushing claims - currently Young and Clurey are ahead of them.
Monfries to start as he is a terrible sub.

Agree with this. I'll chuck in something else to ponder - Kornes out, Krak in? Kane seems to be getting slower if that's possible.

 

[klem22]

Thanks for that SP. Now all the club has to do is elevate Nathan Krakouer... or will Sam Gray be the one?

CRIKEY if S Gray is preferred over N Krakour you would have to question the sanity of Ken surely!

 

[ozph1870]

Agree with this. I'll chuck in something else to ponder - Kornes out, Krak in? Kane seems to be getting slower if that's possible.

insanity, cornes played on hill who is one of the quickest players in the league, hill had zero impact on the game.

 

[woffy]

insanity, cornes played on hill who is one of the quickest players in the league, hill had zero impact on the game.

I'll have to watch the game again, but I can only recall Kornes denying Hill a couple of times - just because Hill didn't get may touches doesn't mean it was purely because of Kane.

 

[ozph1870]

I'll have to watch the game again, but I can only recall Kornes denying Hill a couple of times - just because Hill didn't get may touches doesn't mean it was purely because of Kane.

cornes has been slow and beating opponents for 12 years, nothing has changed.

 

[Long live PAFC]

Agree with this. I'll chuck in something else to ponder - Kornes out, Krak in? Kane seems to be getting slower if that's possible.

Kornes will get a rest later in the season. Krak isn't quite ready for AFL yet, needs 5-10 SANFL games yet.