Unofficial Preview Changes V Sydney

[Smoky]

Let's face facts, we have now lost so many key players without getting any other than Moore back, that we are in desperate trouble against a Sydney team that has been in decline for weeks. If Howe doesn't come up, there just isn't a suitable placement for our backline losses. Neither Magden nor McLarty inspire any confidence, and only returning players in Elliott and Aish can any strength to a very weakened team. We are now carrying passengers in Murray, Varcoe, Brown, Daicos and Mayne. The last thing we need is yet another player not quite making an impact at VFL level being promoted to the seniors. We probably anticipated a reasonably easy win against Sydney, but not anymore.

We'll beat Sydney next week.

With conviction.

 

[DeGoody]

My changes would be :

Out sharenberg Mayne Varcoe Brown Murray
In: madgen aish Elliot fasolo sier

Maynard madgen crisp
Howe Moore Langdon
Aish Pendles Phillips
Thomas mihocek WHE
Elliot cox Stephenson
Foll: Grundy Sidebottom adams
Inter: greenwood fasolo Sier Daicos

With 4 games to go to get Elliot aish fasolo senior footy fit. and blood madgen with berg going down.

Then in 3 weeks add de goey trelaor reid appleby or Goldsack

With finals team being :

Maynard Reid Crisp
Howe Moore Langdon
Aish Pendles Phillips
Degoey mihocek WHE
Stephenson cox Elliot
Foll: Grundy Sidebottom treloar
Inter: adams Thomas greenwood Appleby or Goldsack

Emergencies/depth Varcoe Mayne sier daicos Brown fasolo murray blair madgen mclarty wills crocker smith Oxley

In the bold still missing from my Sydney team.

We can win the flag with that team but we cannot get any more key injuries!! Our depth now is at breaking point with not much cover left!

 

[Smoky]

You seriously think we will make 7 changes to our side. You ever heard of the term "stability"?

You been drinking mate?

Read my post again.

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

You been drinking mate?

Read my post again.

Nope dont drink. l read your post and you had 6 players, including Howe and Scharenberg out for next week, with Greenwood a possibility. l think you been on the gas mate!

 

[Smoky]

Nope dont drink. l read your post and you had 6 players, including Howe and Scharenberg out for next week, with Greenwood a possibility. l think you been on the gas mate!

Try and read it again mate.

I'll give you one more go.

Is that what "I" said would happen?

I eagerly await your response...

 

[Smoky]

Dead Eye Didak...

Sorry Smoky?

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Dead Eye Didak...

Sorry Smoky?

Sorry?....l read your post mate, wont happen dude. You dont make wholesale changes over a week or two. We are a side sitting in the top 4, why make wholesale changes. The only automatic selections are Reid, DeGoey and Treloar, and even he (Treloar) wont be back till finals. Elliott, Aish, Fasolo etc could be intergrated back in considering VFL form.

 

[domus]

In McLarty, Sier, (Elliott or Fas)
Out Scharenberg, Varcoe, ?
Brown may get dropped as Syd have big bodied mids, thou is on the improve.
Greenwood/ Murray also on thin ice.
Mayne needs to also get more involved.
De Goey def back in if right.

I don't think he will be back for at least another two games.

 

[TradeDraft]

I don't think he will be back for at least another two games.

Club said 2 Games at Least until he is Back

 

[unplugged]

In: Madge
Out: Scharenberg

Out: Daicos or Brown
In: Sier

Howe stays in the side. Otherwise probably Oxley lol

 

[domus]

In: Madge
Out: Scharenberg

Out: Daicos or Brown
In: Sier

Howe stays in the side. Otherwise probably Oxley lol

Surely Elliott goes in if he plays okay and pulls up fine. Are we going to keep playing these blokes in the VFL until the season has been pissed down the drain?

 

[12kilos]

If i was the match committee i would rotate madgen and mccalty between chb and fb , and the one who looks more likely to take shaz's position.

 

[TKiL]

That side would beat Carlton

faint praise indeed

 

[unplugged]

Surely Elliott goes in if he plays okay and pulls up fine. Are we going to keep playing these blokes in the VFL until the season has been pissed down the drain?

I was going to say we wouldn't want him coming back 6 days after his first game back, after travelling interstate. I actually forgot he played last week!

Not even sure who he would directly replace? Varcoe?

 

[TKiL]

Roll up, Roll up... There are two spots left in the Collinjurwood team of the year...
View attachment 534231

Well done (?) on a graphic post - first time I've seen a tragedy in Excel....

 

[EddiesBigBucks]

Get this man in and stick him in the goal square.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Out scharenburg Mayne
In Magden aish

Elliott for brown possible too. Running out of time to have the luxury of vfl match practice.

 

[Axl the great]

A lot of hate for Oxley here, he's had a lot of injuries but has played some good games in the seniors and has been pretty good in the seconds. I reckon he's a half decent replacement personally.

 

[PieLebo87]

Out: Murray and Shaz
In: Aish and McLarty or Magden

Varcoe for Elliott if Elliott is ready.

 

[KillerMagpies]

Out: Shaz ..... In: Magden
Out: Murray; he was absolutely racid.... In: Oxley; apparently he’s been killing it down back.
Out: Mayne; was he even out there? In: Josh Smith to the wing.

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

See how the vfl team goes first, need quite a few to good games

Not much point naming names till after the VFL plays. My laptop screen stopped operating yesterday but was fixed this morning at a computer store in Battambang, meaning I missed watching the stream of our game. I did see a little on the phone but tomorrow's VFL game is streamed so hopefully Elliott, Aish, McLarty and others push strongly for selection. But it is kind of hard to name 'ins' before seeing the VFL first.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Get this man in and stick him in the goal square.

I’d rather Blair.

Can’t stand dim wits masquerading their egos as players, pretend or otherwise.

That and he’s not very funny.

Does get a point or two for being a Collingwood supporter.

 

[Collingwoodity]

Surely Elliott goes in if he plays okay and pulls up fine. Are we going to keep playing these blokes in the VFL until the season has been pissed down the drain?

This times 1000%


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Saintly Viewed]

It’s calm planning and all things considered there has been no appetite this season for wholesale or multiple changes at selection.

On that basis, expect only a few changes at most. Hence you’d think three would be maximum but that would only be forced changes. Otherwise two would be a fair guess.

What we know for certain:

Matthew is going to be out, and Howe is doubtful (concussion is not treated lightly anymore).
Possible soreness of ankle is Mihocek but looks ok overall.

Hence can see two changes being:

Scharenberg and Howe out injured. (Very very very sad.)

In: let’s look at who is realistically available:

McLarty, Madgen, Oxley, Smith,
Crocker, Sier.

Maybe ready but no risks taken include, Elliott, Aish.

Hence I’d suggest two players to join the team.
As we’ve lost two backs especially one playing a key role I’m thinking Madgen will get a first game and Sier will slot in too. It will be Varcoe and Greenwood to assist the backs if required.
Note if Mihocek misses it will be McLarty joining the team.

B. Langdon Moore Maynard
HB. Crisp Madgen Murray
C. Phillips Sidebottom Mayne
HF. Hoskin-Elliott Mihocek Varcoe
F. Stephenson Cox Thomas
R. Grundy Pendlebury (c) Adams
I. Sier Daicos Brown C Greenwood

E. McLarty Oxley Smith Crocker

In. Sier Madgen
Out. Scharenberg (injured) Howe (concussion)
New. Madgen

 

[ottoman]

Not much point naming names till after the VFL plays. My laptop screen stopped operating yesterday but was fixed this morning at a computer store in Battambang, meaning I missed watching the stream of our game. I did see a little on the phone but tomorrow's VFL game is streamed so hopefully Elliott, Aish, McLarty and others push strongly for selection. But it is kind of hard to name 'ins' before seeing the VFL first.

Gave this a like for the town name Battambang.
I want to say I live in Battambang.
How cool a name is that.