Changes v West Coast

[OneGreatClub]

You guys shouldn't drop Neade, small/medium forwards always kill us. Either he, Wingard or Gray will kick 4+, I guarantee it.

You won, we lost, I don't feel like playing with you tonight

 

[Blaggut]

Out: O'Shea, Neade, Ah Chee, Stewart
In: Austin, Toumpas, Gray, Palmer (first option Howard, but I worry he will get weeks from the SANFL)

I know it'd be throwing two young lads in the deep end but that game was sickening, we need to shake it up. There's no point in being conservative in selections given the way we're going.

 

[Mangus Onfries]

Struggling to care at this point. We've become the antithesis of what we expect and the values the PAFC stand for. Might start to care more as the week rolls on. Who knows.
Where is the side from 2 years ago?

 

[port always]

You took issue with his post because he had Stewart dropped for Butcher or you would've singled out a number of others who have named Butch as an in.

Just don't think you should bite everyone's head of every time they say a bad word about Stewart, he's 29 in 2 months & part of the 22 that's letting this club down he's not immune from criticism.

Age is the main concern for most but he has played less games and still constantly puts his body on the line for the club at sanfl and afl level..just wish orhers would do it..if we are concerned about age and looking only at the future then Boak Westy Gray Schulz white carlile wtc are the same age or older ...so lets drop them all..guys like rob murphy etc still go at 34...depends on their body and want

 

[Jonts]

Out
Amon, neade, Oshea and Ah chee

in
gray toumpas/s gray Carlile and one of butcher/Howard

 

[OneGreatClub]

Out
Amon, neade, Oshea and Ah chee

in
gray toumpas/s gray Carlile and one of butcher/Howard

Seeing S Gray and Ah Chee's names there..what the hell has happened to them over the off season?

 

[TredreaWilbur]

OUTS: Neade, O'Shea, Ah Chee, Stewart
INS: Palmer, Toumpas, Colquhoun, Howard(If suspended - Austin)

 

[finbarr]

Age is the main concern for most but he has played less games and still constantly puts his body on the line for the club at sanfl and afl level..just wish orhers would do it..if we are concerned about age and looking only at the future then Boak Westy Gray Schulz white carlile wtc are the same age or older ...so lets drop them all..guys like rob murphy etc still go at 34...depends on their body and want

Rob Murphy is a gun. Paul Stewart is not.

 

[finbarr]

OUTS: Neade, O'Shea, Ah Chee, Stewart
INS: Palmer, Toumpas, Colquhoun, Howard(If suspended - Austin)

Because we need another small, slow plodder who can barely kick 40 metres?

 

[Us against the rest]

Because we need another small, slow plodder who can barely kick 40 metres?

In Butcher, Howard, Hoon, Palmer.

 

[JayPea14]

OUTS: Any slight hint of optimism
INS: IDGAF

 

[Jim Dixon]

I just look at the West Coast line up with all those big guys and I just crawl into the fetal position. We don't have anywhere near the cattle... Trengove vs NicNat and Lycett in the ruck.... then they have Darling and Kennedy up forward.

No point complaining though, our esteemed club does all these 'list management' things, and Ken Hinkley knows that structure's a nonsense and stupid 20th century thinking. I'm glad these clever chaps with their GPS data and heat maps and gizmos are in charge! Backup in case Ryder got rubbed out, what was I thinking?

 

[OneGreatClub]

I just look at the West Coast line up with all those big guys and I just crawl into the fetal position. We don't have anywhere near the cattle... Trengove vs NicNat and Lycett in the ruck.... then they have Darling and Kennedy up forward.

No point complaining though, our esteemed club does all these 'list management' things, and Ken Hinkley knows that structure's a nonsense and stupid 20th century thinking. I'm glad these clever chaps with their GPS data and heat maps and gizmos are in charge! Backup in case Ryder got rubbed out, what was I thinking?

Yes I am quietly terrified of next week's game lol.

 

[Us against the rest]

Will it make any difference.

 

[JayPea14]

I just look at the West Coast line up with all those big guys and I just crawl into the fetal position. We don't have anywhere near the cattle... Trengove vs NicNat and Lycett in the ruck.... then they have Darling and Kennedy up forward.

No point complaining though, our esteemed club does all these 'list management' things, and Ken Hinkley knows that structure's a nonsense and stupid 20th century thinking. I'm glad these clever chaps with their GPS data and heat maps and gizmos are in charge! Backup in case Ryder got rubbed out, what was I thinking?

Read your post and thought "Hopefully it's raining to counteract the line-up size differential but...



Some spud like Josh Hill will kick 5 and I don't want to imagine what else is going to occur

 

[JAlexG]

Just bring in another tall forward please. For goodness sake, IDGAF who, just bring someone in.
We would of played Schulz, Ryder, Dixon, Westhoff and Jackson in the same side, so what gives?
Carlton defenders, who were down a kpd for most of the match mind you, just taking marks inside our 50 without a contest.
I know the service into the 50 wasn't so good, but we are actually getting decent inside 50 numbers. With our make shift ruck we need another focus point inside 50 because geez we've seen when we've tried to hit up a small bloke with a 'chisler' and just hit a ****ing dark blue jumper.

 

[OneGreatClub]

Just bring in another tall forward please. For goodness sake, IDGAF who, just bring someone in.
We would of played Schulz, Ryder, Dixon, Westhoff and Jackson in the same side, so what gives?
Carlton defenders, who were down a kpd for most of the match mind you, just taking marks inside our 50 without a contest.
I know the service into the 50 wasn't so good, but we are actually getting decent inside 50 numbers. With our make shift ruck we need another focus point inside 50 because geez we've seen when we've tried to hit up a small bloke with a 'chisler' and just hit a ******* dark blue jumper.

Good point. Our game plan seems to rely on getting the ball as often as possible in our inside 50, but we don't have the players to capitalise.

 

[chachi11]

We had 6 marks i50 lol

In- Someone over 5 foot..Butch, Austin a bean pole..give us something Ken!
Out- I would say Plodders but that would leave us with only 6 players on the field.

 

[PAFC66]

Carlile was quite average for the Magpies. Not sure I'd bring him in vs a side coming off a 100pt win against a side we hardly beat. I know they have a huge forward line but seems like clutching straws bringing him back after one game. Rather go small down back than up forward where we struggle to take more than 5 marks. Bring in Howard or Butcher.

 

[Waspy79]

You just know this week will be the week the flat track bully tag is shed by the Coasters, as it was in 2015 against us, and we play the Eagles into the form that takes them to the 2016 grand final.

 

[BornPort]

You guys shouldn't drop Neade, small/medium forwards always kill us. Either he, Wingard or Gray will kick 4+, I guarantee it.

Neade doesn't kick goals though he's there to almost apply tackles.

 

[PAFC66]

You just know this week will be the week the flat track bully tag is shed by the Coasters, as it was in 2015 against us, and we play the Eagles into the form that takes them to the 2016 grand final.

Not sure beating us away is something to jump up and down about.

 

[Waspy79]

Not sure beating us away is something to jump up and down about.

Agree but it was probably their catalyst for belief last year.

 

[PAFC66]

Agree but it was probably their catalyst for belief last year.

Was that their last away win lol?

 

[OneGreatClub]

Agree but it was probably their catalyst for belief last year.

They said as much. Beating us last year gave them belief.