Changes versus Richmond

finbarr · May 17, 2015

If Kane Mitchell is in the team next week I'm gonna shit. He's just hopeless.

ozph1870 · May 17, 2015

Powerade 08 said:
Anyone who watched the SANFL game is not sure if you are joking or not. He was rubbish.*

* I'd still take him over 5 or 6 guys in the AFL team though.

what... he was one of our best today....

Janus · May 17, 2015

finbarr said:
If Kane Mitchell is in the team next week I'm gonna shit. He's just hopeless.

I would hope you'd shit before then - it's not healthy to keep it backed up like that...

But yes, Mitchell needs to go. He wasn't in the team at the start of the year, but because of Hinkley's instance on running he has managed to keep his spot even though our running game has been stifled and he is useless at the possession style.

ozph1870 · May 17, 2015

port always said:
Heres the reason ...Arch currently does not have the tank to go 4 quarters in the AFL..That is why he didn't get a full game this week ..If you look at his game last week he couldn't move half way thru the last quarter

seriously i have no idea what game you watch, ahchee only played in the last qtr last week, and he played well.

BIG MATTY WHITE · May 17, 2015

finbarr said:
If Kane Mitchell is in the team next week I'm gonna shit. He's just hopeless.

You need more dietry fibre....

Powerade 08 · May 17, 2015

ozph1870 said:
what... he was one of our best today....

Only on the stat sheet.

Ah Chee, Byrne Jones, Young. Moore and Neade in the last qtr. Off the top of my head those guys did well.

The rest were very average against poor opposition.

Julia#13 · May 17, 2015

tribey said:
I like Cameron O'Shea but he had no business being out there tonight on exposed form and delivered exactly what he's currently capable of.

A slap in the face to the fans and Paul Stewart who currently shits all over Cam every day of the week.

Damn right. Stewy has been in the bests nearly every week and deserves his shot.

Out - o'shea, Mitchell, white
in - Stewart, wines, carlisle

Would love to somehow fit in neade and arch But can't see hinkley dropping westy Or being ruthless enough to chop other underperforming players. Reckon amon stays in to replace the run of white

port always · May 17, 2015

ozph1870 said:
seriously i have no idea what game you watch, ahchee only played in the last qtr last week, and he played well.

No more communication with me please

finbarr · May 17, 2015

Janus said:
I would hope you'd shit before then - it's not healthy to keep it backed up like that...

x_les_x · May 17, 2015

tribey said:
Stewart's 191cms. Deserved a game over COS this week. By any measure.

by cos I assume you mean o'shea yes paul did but he wasn't even a travelling emergency, tells you a lot. as was clurey who I think is pretty much gone at the end of the year as is shaw who dgaf in the sanfl anyway that's for the list management thread.

I was responding to more stewart being a replacement for westhoff's forward role.

Everyone wants westhoff out but don't realise we do not have a replacement for him

As previously mentioned shaw doesn't give a single f, butcher's had 3 disposals in the reserves, Harvey could come in but not likely. Looking at the oppo, we take westhoff out replace him with a crumber like neade or an undersized kpp such as stewart. (presumably rance/chaplin to ryder/schulz) Grimes 193cm, mcbean 202cm will pick off marks and we're back to our 2014 forward structure whatever our midfield does will go to shit. Neade at ff against a 190cm+ defender. We're not dropping westhoff

Eddie Dingle · May 17, 2015

I just want to say that I will always hope Kane Mitchell is a superstar.

However, at this point in time if he is in our best 22 we are going nowhere.

BIG MATTY WHITE · May 17, 2015

x_les_x said:
by cos I assume you mean o'shea yes paul did but he wasn't even a travelling emergency, tells you a lot. as was clurey who I think is pretty much gone at the end of the year as is shaw who dgaf in the sanfl anyway that's for the list management thread.

I was responding to more stewart being a replacement for westhoff's forward role.

Everyone wants westhoff out but don't realise we do not have a replacement for him

As previously mentioned shaw doesn't give a single f, butcher's had 3 disposals in the reserves, Harvey could come in but not likely. Looking at the oppo, we take westhoff out replace him with a crumber like neade or an undersized kpp such as stewart. (presumably rance/chaplin to ryder/schulz) Grimes 193cm, mcbean 202cm will pick off marks and we're back to our 2014 forward structure whatever our midfield does will go to shit. Neade at ff against a 190cm+ defender. We're not dropping westhoff

After todays game... no one is above the law

Zakk Wylde · May 17, 2015

finbarr said:
If Kane Mitchell is in the team next week I'm gonna shit. He's just hopeless.

Yeah he is bad...

Him at his best today

ozph1870 · May 17, 2015

port always said:
No more communication with me please

hilarious.

tribey · May 17, 2015

Eddie Dingle said:
I just want to say that I will always hope Kane Mitchell is a superstar.

However, at this point in time if he is in our best 22 we are going nowhere.

Harked back to the bad old days of relying on Matt Thomas, David Rodan and John McCarthy in the guts today.

In today's AFL effort is no substitute for genuine ability.

Porked04 · May 17, 2015

Chaplin will run the Hoff back into form next week if he plays. Chappy's our very own 19th man next week :thumbsu:

I Dont Care · May 17, 2015

finbarr said:

Loved that movie.

finbarr · May 17, 2015

I_Dont_Care said:
Loved that movie.

THE "coming of age" film of my generation.

I Dont Care · May 17, 2015

finbarr said:
THE "coming of age" film of my generation.

Maybe we should watch it again. I need a laugh

edgie · May 17, 2015

ozph1870 said:
butcher had 3 touches today, didnt get a touch in the last half. butch is lucky we cant drop afl listed players to the sanfl reserves, he is struggling big time these days.

I'm aware of this.

I really do think Hoff is playing that poorly in the AFL.

Magpiespower · May 17, 2015

Boxx said:
OUT - WESTHOFF, CORNES, F****** MITCHELL

Haha! Oh man, that is...

Screen shot 2015-05-17 at 8.26.02 PM.png

Zakk Wylde · May 17, 2015

I_Dont_Care said:
Maybe we should watch it again. I need a laugh

Here you go...

port always · May 17, 2015

Sammy Gray has been terrific the last few weeks...Can we upgrade re Polec...He is another wjho is performing and not getting looked at..Dont know where clurey is at the mo ...He is playing as a sweeper which doest help his cause or use his body and tank...

edgie · May 17, 2015

Janus said:
I would hope you'd shit before then - it's not healthy to keep it backed up like that...

I'm not sure that waiting for Kane Mitchell to be omitted is sound dietary advice for a healthy digestive tract...

ROBBBO · May 17, 2015

I want Westhoff and Hartlett dropped, if only just to make a statement

Log In or Create New Account

Rd 5 Saturday + Club Forums »

Rd 5 Reviews + Club Forums »

Changes versus Richmond

Cancelled

Brownlow Medallist

Advocatus Diaboli

Brownlow Medallist

Premiership Player

Brownlow Medallist

Team Captain

All Australian

Cancelled

Premiership Player

Moving chairs

Premiership Player

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

ʎǝlʞuᴉH ʞɔɐS

Norm Smith Medallist

Nothing Matters

Cancelled

Nothing Matters

TheBrownDog

Cancelled

Brownlow Medallist

All Australian

TheBrownDog

Club Legend

Similar threads