Remove this Banner Ad

changes vs bombers.

  • Thread starter Thread starter checker
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

checker

Senior List
Joined
Mar 31, 2008
Posts
197
Reaction score
0
Location
melb
AFL Club
Collingwood
In- Iles Stanley cook/cox wood


Out- Thomas johnson Goldsack fraser

i think we need new running midfielders that are effective, it woud suck to see thomas dropped but it would make him earn he's spot by playing well in the 2's. and johnson yes obvious reasons. Goldsack not sure why he's playing senior footy, was brilliant last year, sadly gone far backwards this year. wood unlucky, someone has to go for fraser. these changes are unrealistic though because of MM favourites just play week in week out which will start costing us matches, actually already has started to cost us matches.

realistic- no change/ wood- fraser.
 
im surprised isles hasnt got a go this year. i thought he showed a bit last year in the few games he did have.
 
In: Cox, Fraser, Iles/Stanley/Cook
Out: Goldsack, Wood, Johnson

I what I would like to see.

Wood is going to get cut up by a more cunning ruckman like Hille and he was lost in so many areas last week, didn't use his body wisely, got in the way, poor off the ball positioning, poor decision making. He can't seem to get it all together and struggles to know where to run at the moment. If Fraser isn't ready to ruck don't change him for Wood I suppose.

Play Thomas as the high HFF/winger and tell him not to worry about accountability too much just to get the ball.
 
im surprised isles hasnt got a go this year. i thought he showed a bit last year in the few games he did have.
very much agreed,like to see how he goes, and stanley seems to have improved this year in the ressies.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

IN : Davis and Stanley
OUT:Johnson and Maxwell
Fraser has to build strength around his knee and learn how to jump off his 'wrong' leg. If he comes back in the near future it will most likely be as a forward.
 
I reckon you cant drop Thomas but MM has to put him in the midfield and not just leave him in the forward pocket.
Out: Johnson
In: Cook
I also cant see Davis or Fraser for at least 2 more weeks.
 
IN:Fraser, Dawes, Davis, Prestigiacomo


Out: Goldsack, Bryan, Wakelin, Johnson

But you've got 3 coming back from injury there - they'll be limping all over the ground.:eek:

Out: Maxwell and Johnson, to allow them to rest and refocus
Wood

In: Davis & Fraser, if possible. Stanley, for a look-see.
 
I say this again,bring in Chris Dawes.This will be the perfect game for him to debut.
Forget Davis and Fraser,both are clearly not ready yet.give them both more time to get fully fit.Don't drop wood ,get bryan to dop the bullocking work against hille while wood rests forward,and pinch hits in the ruck for this game.
So the bombers have afew injury worries so Dawes is the tall option to become the foil for cloke.All he has to do is bring the ball to ground for the smaller forwards.But he will surprise if given the chance.
I am gouing to stoick my neck pout and say once this kid settles into the seniopr side and builds his upper bidy abit more we will have a young Jonathan Brown in the making ffs give him a go,MALTHOUSE.
Cloke,Dawes and Anthony could become the replacements for Rocca,Rusling .
Cloke at CHF
Dawes in the pocket smashing opponents and Jack Anthony as the leading forward like rusling but has a bit more grunt.
At their feet didak,medhurst,davis,thomas.
 
I say this again,bring in Chris Dawes.This will be the perfect game for him to debut.
Forget Davis and Fraser,both are clearly not ready yet.give them both more time to get fully fit.Don't drop wood ,get bryan to dop the bullocking work against hille while wood rests forward,and pinch hits in the ruck for this game.
So the bombers have afew injury worries so Dawes is the tall option to become the foil for cloke.All he has to do is bring the ball to ground for the smaller forwards.But he will surprise if given the chance.
I am gouing to stoick my neck pout and say once this kid settles into the seniopr side and builds his upper bidy abit more we will have a young Jonathan Brown in the making ffs give him a go,MALTHOUSE.
Cloke,Dawes and Anthony could become the replacements for Rocca,Rusling .
Cloke at CHF
Dawes in the pocket smashing opponents and Jack Anthony as the leading forward like rusling but has a bit more grunt.
At their feet didak,medhurst,davis,thomas.
Actually i agree im now changing my choices.
In: Dawes, Cook
Out: Goldsack, Johnson
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Maxwell has to go. I've never been a Maxy hater but he was shocking against the roos, no defense at all and very poor disposal.
 
something smelly will hit the fan this week if you can't beat a bomber team without Fletcher, Lovett, Davey, McVeigh, Monfries, Neagle and Welsh
 
Maxwell was better than Goldsack.
In: Fraser, Davis
Out: Goldsack, Johnson

Can't drop Wood at this stage because Fraser can't ruck yet due to his knee problem. We need Leon fit to stretch their lack of defensive smalls.
 
IN: Fraser, Davis
OUT: Goldsack, Thomas

I would love to see thomas get dropped, then he would have to work for his spot again.
 
B: H. Shaw - Wakelin - Maxwell

HB: Lockyer - Brown - O'Brien

C: R. Shaw - Burns - Pendlebury

HF: Didak - Cloke - Thomas

F: Davis - Anthony - Medhurst

FL: Bryan - Swan - Clarke

INT: Stanley - O'Bree - Wellingham - Wood

OUT: Johnson and Goldsack​
 
B: H. Shaw - Wakelin - Maxwell

HB: Lockyer - Brown - O'Brien

C: R. Shaw - Burns - Pendlebury

HF: Didak - Cloke - Thomas

F: Davis - Anthony - Medhurst

FL: Bryan - Swan - Clarke

INT: Stanley - O'Bree - Wellingham - Wood

OUT: Johnson and Goldsack​

Are your ins Stanley and Davis ?
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I'd be suprised if Fraser was ready to ruck too.

Thomas to the middle it needs to happen for longer periods of time. He plays his best footy there, can break the lines etc.

I am really struggling for ins and outs. Both Goldsack and Maxwell have been poor and should be out, I can't see the defenders to replace them though without moving Anthony back and for now at least he is too valuable as a foward as we are short on them too. Even BJ has been playing as a small defender so no real point replacing him with a midfielder.
 
I'd be surprised if Johnson or Maxwell are dropped. MM seems to love them! I think they both would benefit from the drop though.

Leon straight back in, Wellingham keep his place.
 
In: Davis, Stanley
Out: Maxwell, Johnson

Know it won't happen as they are MM's favourites but they deserve to be dropped.

Stanley has been in ripping form in the 2's and needs to be rewarded by playing him and by giving him a run in the midfield not at HFF or HBF
 
In: Cox, Fraser, Iles/Stanley/Cook
Out: Goldsack, Wood, Johnson

I what I would like to see.

Wood is going to get cut up by a more cunning ruckman like Hille and he was lost in so many areas last week, didn't use his body wisely, got in the way, poor off the ball positioning, poor decision making. He can't seem to get it all together and struggles to know where to run at the moment. If Fraser isn't ready to ruck don't change him for Wood I suppose.

Play Thomas as the high HFF/winger and tell him not to worry about accountability too much just to get the ball.

Well Bryan did not much Better than Wood.
 
IN: Davis, Dawes, Stanley


Out: Hackwell, Goldsack, Johnson
 
Bryan was down, but not sure he should be dropped. Wood either. It was only 1 game after all...and I think this will save some of the others who deserve a 'rest'. It will be viewed as down just one game.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom