Changes vs Brisbane

[Flawed Genius]

Not sure if I'd make any changes.

If Pratt is suspended, opportunity for Pedersen/Tarrant arises.

 

[Firebat]

Really want Speight to start. I'd bring in Tazza for Pratty, anyone know how Liam went today? Does Cunners come straight back in?

 

[Shinboner Schem]

Not a great game for Hansen I thought*. Send him to the back line


*my thought was impaired by alcohol though

 

[roos_fanatic08]

Out: Atley

In: Cunnington

Atley was a little bit too quiet today. 8 posessions is not enough and cunnington is due to have a bit more impact. Let atley go back to the 2's and dominate a few games.

 

[scooby1279]

Out : Gartlett
In: Cunnington (since he was only out due to illness).

Atley as sub next week.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Really want Speight to start. I'd bring in Tazza for Pratty, anyone know how Liam went today? Does Cunners come straight back in?

agree with tarrant in for pratt.

other than that no other changes. give cunners some time in the vfl.

anthony plays 2moro

 

[Roomagic]

Out : Gartlett
In: Cunnington (since he was only out due to illness).

Atley as sub next week.

Why would you dropped garlett again he played really well today

 

[Works atErrol St]

No change

 

[Teffy]

In: Bring in Tazza and send him to Brown.

Out: Dunno yet.

 

[riddler4848]

Thomas has to go. 6 disposals and 1 goal 18 over the last couple weeks is just not good enough. gives too many frees away and does not have any urgency. always on the outside of packs throwing his arms out....how can he get a game each and every week? does he have naked pics of scotts wife or something.?? Him and hansen are the 2 who should not be in the side week in week out.

 

[shintemaster]

McMahon's form recently a bit of a concern IMO.

 

[Errol Street]

McMahon's form recently a bit of a concern IMO.

Not a good game, made heaps of noticeable errors.

 

[The Nostradamus]

McMahon's form recently a bit of a concern IMO.

agree
pratt or mcmahon need to make way for tarrant

 

[theduckfan]

Pratt will get weeks so his out.. Pederson In.
Thomas Out, Warren in.

Thomas was useless today, didn't contest marking situations when kicked to him in a pack.


Make him earn his spot like Edwards was made to last week.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Pratt will get weeks so his out.. Pederson In.
Thomas Out, Warren in.

Thomas was useless today, didn't contest marking situations when kicked to him in a pack.


Make him earn his spot like Edwards was made to last week.

i want thomas to play next week, plays well against the lions.
he wasn't great today but he did apply good forward pressure, give him 1 more week

 

[tazaa]

Cunnington needs game time. Though im not fussed if he misses again.
Tarrant to help Grima chop out Brown.
Greenwood needs a recall too. Dont forget!

B: Rawlings Grima Firrito
HB: MacMillan Tarrant Wells
C: Adams Ziebell Greenwood
HF: Edwards Hansen Harvey
F:Thomas Petrie Wright
R: Goldstein Swallow Garlett
I: Atley Cunnington Speight McMahon

IN: Cunnington Greenwood Tarrant
OUT: Pratt (susp) Harper (for Levi) Thompson (team balance)

 

[Flawed Genius]

Will Greenwood be right for next week?

I would drop Garlett before Harper.

 

[benbanjo]

i want thomas to play next week, plays well against the lions.
he wasn't great today but he did apply good forward pressure, give him 1 more week

i think ur right.... drives me nuts and is what i would call soft.... but untill we have someone who can come in and provide something diffirent he needs to stay... flash might presure him when hes good to go....
out probably pratt by the MRP... in tarrant....need big boddies for brown and clark next week....

 

[Teffy]

Will Greenwood be right for next week?

Werribee have the bye.

I wonder if Cunners will strip for NB?

 

[Joshen]

Out: Pratt (suspended), McMahon, Atley (go back to the twos and get a bit more of the ball)
In: Pedersen, Tarrant, Cunnington or Greenwood

 

[Gen Y]

Just because Thomas didn't get much of the ball himself today doesn't mean he wasn't a vital cog in the win.

Had 5 forward line tackles in a team that killed Melbourne due to forward line pressure. Game was played in our half after quarter time and the pressure on Melbourne coming out of defense was a massive factor in that.

Personally think calls to drop him show a lack of footy knowledge.

 

[Mav]

Thomas has to go. always on the outside of packs throwing his arms out..

thats why hes called The Shag. Some thing it's because he's FiretrUCKED but no, its because he's just always standing there with his wings out drying.

i want thomas to play next week, plays well against the lions.

FFS people have been saying that for 3 years to see one good game. It's over, he's no good, just accept the fact. You know what, maybe Mav was right all along.

 

[The Nostradamus]

thats why hes called The Shag. Some thing it's because he's FiretrUCKED but no, its because he's just always standing there with his wings out drying.



FFS people have been saying that for 3 years to see one good game. It's over, he's no good, just accept the fact. You know what, maybe Mav was right all along.

did u watch the game?
his forward pressure was very good and the fact is he gets lots of scoring shots on goal so when he starts converting more then he will be a force

 

[Mav]

Just because Thomas didn't get much of the ball himself today doesn't mean he wasn't a vital cog in the win.

Had 5 forward line tackles in a team that killed Melbourne due to forward line pressure. Game was played in our half after quarter time and the pressure on Melbourne coming out of defense was a massive factor in that.

Personally think calls to drop him show a lack of footy knowledge.

no no and no. This post show lack of footy knowledge. ANYONE can put forward pressure on, its a mind set. You dont need skill or talent just a willingness to work. A forward needs to kick goals. He needs to set up goals. Forward pressure is a given, every player should do it and just because The Shag has done it doesnt mean he played well. It means he did the minimum of what is required.

 

[Mav]

did u watch the game?
his forward pressure was very good and the fact is he gets lots of scoring shots on goal so when he starts converting more then he will be a force

no haven't watched yet, replay starts soon! read my post above. He's always been a bad shot on goal and is getting no better. If any other player in our team had such poor disposal they would have his head ripped off.

I've always said, the only goals The Shag kicks are from inside the goal square, thats because he cant miss from there.