Preview Changes vs Carlton

[malpaso]

Candidates: D.Pearce, Sutcliffe, Sheridan, Suban

1. I don't understand the love for Sheridan, poor positioning, can't kick long or on the run, looks inept imo.
2. D.Pearce is useless now
3. I don't know what to make of Sutcliffe as there were bonehead skills and decision making all over the place. Think Tucker should come in down back and move Sutty up to wing.
4. Suban should go play WAFL for the rest of his career.

OUT: D.Pearce, Suban
IN: Tucker, Mundy

 

[salim malik]

Mora wont come in but his strength and run of half back makes Sherro look like a little leaguer.

 

[ImperialPurple]

Can't see Grey coming in - he has dodgy disposal... that's supposedly what's keeping him out of the team now.

Mayne will stay in. 14D, 6M, 7T and a goal. I thought he was actually okay today.

Suban was poo. DPearce was poo. Sutcliffe was poo. Barlow was borderline poo, but did some good things in patches.

Tabs and Croz need to do more - Tabs esp looked like he's a bit scared of his own shadow. But I'd give them both another go next week.

APearce
Weller

Blakely, Sandi, Bennell, Yarran, Morabito won't be available. Mundy should be.

de Boer, Mzungu, CPearce, Hannath - Do. Not. Want.

Sooooo........

In: Mundy, Tucker
Out: Suban, Sutcliffe

 

[hoss]

Think Barlow will be out despite being 1st in tackles and 2nd in clearances. Was given only 68mins game time and I think he's injured. RTB can't find a position for him anyway. Pointless dropping him for a de Boer or Crozier though. Suban and D Pearce did nothing at all. Sheridan (and the starting mids ) were crap for the first 15 mins, no leadership or accountability during that first 4 goal blitz.

 

[FreoBulldog]

Time to 'play the kids' now.

 

[E Shed]

yeah I think Barlow is gone. Ibbotson must be on thin ice. Suban never gets dropped so pointless speculating.
Tucker should come in, possibly Blakely. I would actually play Morabito. He had one of the best pre-seasons of any player and he showed in his first hit out for Peel that he hasn't missed a beat. Just play the guy.
Crozier to get another chance even though he was disappointing today. He can play.
Taberner is a lost cause IMO. But every time I say that he does something so who knows.

 

[WilloTree]

Out: Suban, D. Pearce
In: Mundy, Tucker

Crozier should stay, just to see if he can adjust. Can't just bring him in and out and expect him to magically pick up the tempo.

He's played 34 games. Hardly just bringing him in. Down the road McGovern has played 37 and he seems to go OK. He's done. Tucker IN

 

[meima]

yeah I think Barlow is gone. Ibbotson must be on thin ice. Suban never gets dropped so pointless speculating.
Tucker should come in, possibly Blakely. I would actually play Morabito. He had one of the best pre-seasons of any player and he showed in his first hit out for Peel that he hasn't missed a beat. Just play the guy.
Crozier to get another chance even though he was disappointing today. He can play.
Taberner is a lost cause IMO. But every time I say that he does something so who knows.

Brady is the one we should play he can't be worse than Lin jong of Western bulldog.

 

[Dirty_banchez]

Brady is the one we should play he can't be worse than Lin jong of Western bulldog.

His disposal is suspect. Can we carry another poor kicker?

 

[meima]

His disposal is suspect. Can we carry another poor kicker?

We already carry suban,Barlow and co for so long, further more if we want good kick kid we need to tank for at least 3 years plus . time to play kids to let them learn the new game plan.

 

[dominguez]

Out - D Pearce (omitted) Pavlich (rest)

In - Mundy, Tucker

 

[salim malik]

yeah I think Barlow is gone. Ibbotson must be on thin ice. Suban never gets dropped so pointless speculating.
Tucker should come in, possibly Blakely. I would actually play Morabito. He had one of the best pre-seasons of any player and he showed in his first hit out for Peel that he hasn't missed a beat. Just play the guy.
Crozier to get another chance even though he was disappointing today. He can play.
Taberner is a lost cause IMO. But every time I say that he does something so who knows.

I'm not so sure Croz can play , 30 odd games in 4 years and hasn't taken any by the scruff of the neck. The calls to replace him for Mayne have been fanciful to say the least. Time to bring Collins in,Pearce back to the forward half and Ross did say Clark would be ready. Mora is a no brainer but they will sit on him for a few more at Peel.

 

[dominguez]

yeah I think Barlow is gone. Ibbotson must be on thin ice. Suban never gets dropped so pointless speculating.
Tucker should come in, possibly Blakely. I would actually play Morabito. He had one of the best pre-seasons of any player and he showed in his first hit out for Peel that he hasn't missed a beat. Just play the guy.
Crozier to get another chance even though he was disappointing today. He can play.
Taberner is a lost cause IMO. But every time I say that he does something so who knows.

Barlow struggled. Ibbotson was terrible, as was Hill's first half. Two key players really down on confidence.

Blakely and Mora need a couple more games in the WAFL.

 

[meima]

I'm not so sure Croz can play , 30 odd games in 4 years and hasn't taken any by the scruff of the neck. The calls to replace him for Mayne have been fanciful to say the least. Time to bring Collins in,Pearce back to the forward half and Ross did say Clark would be ready. Mora is a no brainer but they will sit on him for a few more at Peel.

Salim put grey and crozier close together you will see the difference. Need more fresh face , some ploder try to keep their place to make croz look bad.

 

[malpaso]

His disposal is suspect. Can we carry another poor kicker?

We are carrying 20 at the moment (Walters, Hill excl.)

 

[Righteo]

We are carrying 20 at the moment (Walters, Hill excl.)

The guy in your sig is going ok. Plus that old Croatian dude.

 

[clivenator26]

Crozier was quiet but should get another game, others get 1 1/2 seasons of bad games.

In the gun, DPearce, Barlow & Subes, I reckon Mayne saved his skin for another week with a good outing.

In the mix, Grey, Tucker & The usual spudspects.

 

[meima]

Crozier was quiet but should get another game, others get 1 1/2 seasons of bad games.

In the gun, DPearce, Barlow & Subes, I reckon Mayne saved his skin for another week with a good outing.

In the mix, Grey, Tucker & The usual spudspects.

Collins?

 

[im_a_lazy_sod]

Out: Suban, D. Pearce
In: Mundy, Tucker

Crozier should stay, just to see if he can adjust. Can't just bring him in and out and expect him to magically pick up the tempo.

That matt Tabener effect I think it's called

 

[go_the_dockers]

We are carrying 20 at the moment (Walters, Hill excl.)

Ballas was great today. Gee Barlow and Suban were sloppy even with handballed.

 

[clivenator26]

Collins?

Yep, had to forgot one. That will depend on Carlton's fwd line, but Norf's is tall and we matched up ok at times. Zac,MJ & Alex should be enoughuess Alex goes forward for Tabs and then Collins can slot in.

 

[Fat Nyfe]

Barlow is so down on confidence. Hesitates every time he is near the ball, it's sad because I do like him. He should stay in for now, I guess.

Mayne was ok today but still on thin ice overall.

D Pearce frustrates the hell out of me, but will stay.

Suban? I just don't know anymore. He wasn't awful but his free pass is a bit bizarre. He has to be given a WAFL spell sometime. Far better players than him have been dropped for less.

Crozier and Taberner were poor, but as someone else said they need to stay in for consistency. This season is all about getting games into the young guys and adjusting to a new game plan.

Weller was terrific, biggest positive of the day. I hope he plays every game this season.

Anyway,

Out: Suban
In: Mundy

 

[meima]

Yep, had to forgot one. That will depend on Carlton's fwd line, but Norf's is tall and we matched up ok at times. Zac,MJ & Alex should be enoughuess Alex goes forward for Tabs and then Collins can slot in.

Actually knowing mora and Yarran play for peel, don't mind grey and croz,Tucker and colli s play for peel this week.

 

[ydraw]

Crozier and Taberner have to stay in otherwise there's no point in selecting them in the first place. Langdon and Weller have been persevered with despite average performances in the first 3 rounds, today it finally started to click for them and they added a whole new dimension to our team.

Agreed. Taberner especially has to stay because he's literally our only key forward once Pav retires. Apeness may never get right and you can't count on players who aren't on our list yet.

 

[wayToGo_]

In: Mundy, Hughes, Tucker
Out: I don't know, just make it happen