Opinion Changes Vs Carlton

[Milux]

WEITERING VS SCHACHE MAKE IT HAPPEN

Unfortunately footy isnt played that way any more.

 

[royboys4eva]

Rocky in for Bastinac.
Walker in for Martin who needs a week on the beach.
Green for Keays. Give the young fella a rest and i wouldn't bother playing him in reserves. Bring him back for Freo game.
Bewick for Lester.

 

[DanT7]

Rocky in for Bastinac.
Walker in for Martin who needs a week on the beach.
Green for Keays. Give the young fella a rest and i wouldn't bother playing him in reserves. Bring him back for Freo game.
Bewick for Lester.

Why would you bring Green in? Sorry but he's in the twos for at least a month.
Outplayed by Jansen, CBeams and Paparone in the reserves.

 

[royboys4eva]

Why would you bring Green in? Sorry but he's in the twos for at least a month.
Outplayed by Jansen, CBeams and Paparone in the reserves.

Give up on Claye Beams he was averaging about 8 disposals a week. He needs a solid month in reserves more than anyone. No point playing with 4 talls up forward and no one to tackle when the ball hits the ground and the opposition backs stream out of defence. Taylor and Bell need help and so i think Green needs to come back in. I think give Keays a week off and let him rest. If Green plays poorly i'm all for dropping him back to the reserves. But he has played two solid games in the seconds now.

BTW now sure how he was outplayed by them when he had 30 disposals and 2 goals. Paparone didn't even make the best players.

 

[Cockliff38]

Serious work needs to go into Gibbs. He's in AA form at the moment.

I've said this before but I think we're too top heavy in attack, which could get found out against a solid Carlton back six. Docherty and Simpson have been playing great footy as rebounders. We can't let them counter from defence with only Schache/West/Freeman applying defensive pressure. If West gets cleared by the MRP I'd rest Martin and get Freeman to relieve in the ruck. Based on current form Kreuzer will give Stef a bath. At least with West we'll get some solid hit-outs to advantage.

In: Rocky
Out: Martin

 

[F_therest]

Unfortunately footy isnt played that way any more.

True but im sure we'll see some contests between the 2 throughout the day which will be exciting

 

[dlanod]

True but im sure we'll see some contests between the 2 throughout the day which will be exciting

Geelong v GWS probably.

The rest of the games on Saturday definitely don't inspire.

 

[Milux]

Geelong v GWS probably.

The rest of the games on Saturday definitely don't inspire.

He is talking about schache vs weiters

 

[Milux]

True but im sure we'll see some contests between the 2 throughout the day which will be exciting

Hopefully the first of many great duals between the 2. Got a feeling weiters will have his measure for a few years.

 

[dlanod]

He is talking about schache vs weiters

I know.

 

[James North]

Unfortunately footy isnt played that way any more.

Please report that to the guy sitting next to me who yells at Merrett every time he finds himself in a one-on-two and leaves one of them to meet the contest.

 

[Milux]

I know.

Thought so. But my sarcasm radar seems to be faulty. That emoji seemed to fix it though.

 

[a mayes ing]

Dunno why Keayes needs a rest. Think he is fine and l doubt Leppa will rest him yet.

Out: Martin, ?? maybe Bastinac
In: Rocky, Bewick

 

[Quigley]

I would like Keays to get more work if anything. We are going nowhere this year and he will ultimately be a midfielder so why not get him the minutes now to move his development along.

 

[Cockliff38]

I would like Keays to get more work if anything. We are going nowhere this year and he will ultimately be a midfielder so why not get him the minutes now to move his development along.

Keays came off the HBF into the centre as our extra at stoppages against the Hawks. I think more of the same is a good way of getting him involved

 

[Len S]

Keays came off the HBF into the centre as our extra at stoppages against the Hawks. I think more of the same is a good way of getting him involved

In , Green, Walker, Rocky. Out , Bastinac, Freeman,Lester. Side is hopelessly top heavy and lacks speed endurance. ..Paparone may be in line also on that basis. Stef would go in that case.

 

[ShaunWDT]

Your MC should just play West as a Solo Ruck, he is probably the worst forward to ever get on an AFL List.

 

[M Malice]

Your MC should just play West as a Solo Ruck, he is probably the worst forward to ever get on an AFL List.

agree it is either west or martin not both, both have very little ability as forward options.

 

[Cockliff38]

Your MC should just play West as a Solo Ruck, he is probably the worst forward to ever get on an AFL List.

Yeah but coming off some injuries he probably doesn't have the tank to go one-out in the ruck. Has been the better pure tap-ruck though - unquestionably

 

[Fitzey]

Just from a fantasy perspective, no chance of Stef rucking on his own this week?

 

[royboys4eva]

Just from a fantasy perspective, no chance of Stef rucking on his own this week?

Just from my perspective i couldn't give a rat's toss about fantasy football and if a player is injured or out of form and what bearing that has on peoples fantasy teams!

 

[dlanod]

Just from a fantasy perspective, no chance of Stef rucking on his own this week?

From a fantasy perspective, there's a stickied thread that's intended for questions exactly like this.

https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/2016-supercoach-dt-fantasy-questions-here.1120757/

 

[royboys4eva]

Trent West cleared. So to was Jordan Lewis but that's hardly a surprise now is it.

 

[WhiteLionFeva]

Please report that to the guy sitting next to me who yells at Merrett every time he finds himself in a one-on-two and leaves one of them to meet the contest.

Don't tell me, at various intervals he also sings out "Who's on him?", "Kick the bloody thing" (or words to that effect), "Grab him" and "Who's that to?".
I know somebody close to me with the same repertoire .

 

[Darlingun]

I just don't see any real upside so would rather drop him than the younger more talented guys. Think his play today was OK but still not in our top 7, and that's his best game in 3 years.

I would give Freeman another week, maybe bring in walker for West or Martin who may need a rest.

Did you actually watch the game , I thought Robbo was one of your better players .
At least he flys the flag & I would of thought he is one of your younger players.