Opinion Changes vs Carlton

Eth · May 19, 2012

There's bound to be a few.

Seems like all the senior players bar probably Rivers who's been alright and Jamar because he's Jamar is on serious notice.

What do we all think, fellas?

CowboyFromHell · May 19, 2012

In before the usual:

In: Casey

Out: Melbourne

posts.

No idea what changes need to be made but surely Davey, Sylvia and Morton are gone at the very least.

LeverPuller · May 19, 2012

Out: Davey, Sylvia, Morton, Bennell
In: Martin, Couch, Tapscott, Taggert

AllenJakovich13 · May 19, 2012

Striker475 said:
Out: Davey, Sylvia, Morton, Bennell
In: Martin, Couch, Tapscott, Taggert

this, is jurrah injured ?

LeverPuller · May 19, 2012

AllenJakovich13 said:
this, is jurrah injured ?

wait and see, if so add out Jurrah and in Dunn

tynanshinin · May 19, 2012

In: Davis, Taggert, Martin, Tapscott
Out: Bennell, McDonald, Sylvia, Davey..

Mcdonald has a crack but hes kicking is absolutely horrible... if he's going to play... throw him forward and see what he can do as a CHF.
Really want Tynan back in but he wont be even considered until he's had a few at Casey so at least a month...

Go-Ricky15 · May 19, 2012

Eth said:
There's bound to be a few.

Seems like all the senior players bar probably Rivers who's been alright and Jamar because he's Jamar is on serious notice.

What do we all think, fellas?

Not sure Rivers deserves a reprieve. He has talent which we all know but i dont believe he gives 100% ever, and seems to put the cue in the rack earlier than most.

jurrahcane_24 · May 19, 2012

Unleash the kids

Dump all the old deadwood, plus Trengove whos been pathetic all season

In -

Couch, Taggert, Davis, Fitxpatrick, Cook, Petterd, Tapscott

Out -

Sylvia, Moloney, Davey, Rivers, Trengove, Morton, Jamar

THERE IS NO POINT HAVING SENIOR PLAYER IN THE TEAM IF THEY ARENT LEADERS AND DONT EVEN LEAD BY EXAMPLE

Go-Ricky15 · May 19, 2012

Go-Ricky15 said:
Not sure Rivers deserves a reprieve. He has talent which we all know but i dont believe he gives 100% ever, and seems to put the cue in the rack earlier than most.

Ohh forgot.
Out: Sylvia, Morton, Moloney, Rivers
In: Petterd (aparently was awful but everyone else sems to get another crack), Couch, The Gys (broken jaw and all will still be harder than the above four), J. mcDonald <<shudders>>

Tomnat Tigers · May 19, 2012

Taggert is injured guys and will probably not play again this season.

Eth · May 19, 2012

Tomnat Tigers said:
Taggert is injured guys and will probably not play again this season.

Go on?

CowboyFromHell · May 19, 2012

Go-Ricky15 said:
Not sure Rivers deserves a reprieve. He has talent which we all know but i dont believe he gives 100% ever, and seems to put the cue in the rack earlier than most.

You're kidding, right? Rivers has been terrific all season in a backline that is under intense pressure week in, week out. If it weren't for he, Garland and Frawley we would lose by far more each week.

Bartram_Class · May 19, 2012

jurrahcane_24 said:
In -
Couch, Taggert, Davis, Fitxpatrick, Cook, Petterd, Tapscott

Out -
Sylvia, Moloney, Davey, Rivers, Trengove, Morton, Jamar

RandB · May 19, 2012

AllenJakovich13 said:
this, is jurrah injured ?

Doc Larkins just said he will need scans on his left ankle, landed awkwardly after a marking attempt.

I think his wrist also may have been aggravated as well but not fully sure on that one.

Can't see him playing next week.

Tomnat Tigers · May 19, 2012

Eth said:
Go on?

His got a stress fracture in his back again i think its on the left side of his back this time.

CowboyFromHell · May 19, 2012

Tomnat Tigers said:
His got a stress fracture in his back again i think its on the left side of his back this time.

Source?

jurrahcane_24 · May 19, 2012

Bartram_Class said:

why not?

Give me one reason why Trengove should stay in the side.

Darksidepoints · May 19, 2012

I never want to see Sylvia play for us again. Im done with him.

You can add Morton to that list.

And Davey.

And Green.

Oh, Beamer - you too.

Russian is about a game away from joining them.

Put in as many young kids as possible. I really dont give a shit if we lose by 200 points - if they WANT to be there next year, put them in. It simply cannot get any worse than the crap we are serving up now.

CowboyFromHell · May 19, 2012

Darksidepoints said:
I never want to see Sylvia play for us again. Im done with him.

You can add Morton to that list.

And Davey.

And Green.

Oh, Beamer - you too.

Russian is about a game away from joining them.

Put in as many young kids as possible. I really dont give a shit if we lose by 200 points - if they WANT to be there next year, put them in. It simply cannot get any worse than the crap we are serving up now.

It's sad but it almost seems like it is getting that way. Each week those same guys don't get nearly enough of the footy or have any influence on the game and it hurts us big time.

I think there is almost no doubt that this list needs one of the biggest shake ups in league history. It's the only positive out of all of this.

CowboyFromHell · May 19, 2012

jurrahcane_24 said:
why not?

Give me one reason why Trengove should stay in the side.

You say play the kids and then drop one of the most important ones we have.

Tomnat Tigers · May 19, 2012

CowboyFromHell said:
Source?

Myself.

No this is what happened. Yesterday i was at school(saint pats) and i had re and my re teacher is saint pats football coach and he had coached taggert last year. And taggert who was on his way home to horsham dropped into school and told us all about his injury, and what melbourne was like.

Eth · May 19, 2012

Tomnat Tigers said:
Myself.

No this is what happened. Friday last week i was at school(saint pats) and i had re and my re teacher is saint pats football coach and he had coached taggert last year. And taggert who was on his way home to horsham dropped into school and told us all about his injury, and what melbourne was like.

Friday last week?

He played last Saturday, so bang goes your story.

Edit: MelbourneFooty on Twitter saying injury concerns to Jurrah and...Nathan Jones.

Tomnat Tigers · May 19, 2012

Eth said:
Friday last week?

He played last Saturday, so bang goes your story.

Edit: MelbourneFooty on Twitter saying injury concerns to Jurrah and...Nathan Jones.

well yesterday is what i meant.

lose · May 19, 2012

Tomnat Tigers said:
Myself.

No this is what happened. Yesterday i was at school(saint pats) and i had re and my re teacher is saint pats football coach and he had coached taggert last year. And taggert who was on his way home to horsham dropped into school and told us all about his injury, and what melbourne was like.

out of interest wat did he say about Melbourne?
And is Howard still coaching St Pats?

Theseventhhamster · May 19, 2012

The short bus kids here would be all over Rivers' nuts if he was 20 rather than 27. He's easily one of our best players.

Log In or Create New Account

World Cup game 1: Ned v Pakistan - Game 2: Scot v W.I.Game 2:

Guest - BigFooty Tipping 2026 - Get on! - $500 first prize - Weekly Prizes - Click to Join

Opinion Changes vs Carlton

For sale

Witchtripper

BigFooty Tanker

Club Legend

BigFooty Tanker

Team Captain

Senior List

Debutant

Senior List

Norm Smith Medallist

For sale

Witchtripper

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Witchtripper

Debutant

Norm Smith Medallist

Witchtripper

Witchtripper

Norm Smith Medallist

For sale

Norm Smith Medallist

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Similar threads