Carbine Chaos
Rut Deflector
- Joined
- Apr 1, 2009
- Posts
- 68,977
- Reaction score
- 109,746
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth FC, Everton, Delhi
Was about 20m from the Richards hit, he's gone. Definitely helps.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Was about 20m from the Richards hit, he's gone. Definitely helps.
The West Australian will say on Monday Barrass was outstandingSeen it and while he zones well enough he's too slow to watch a fast forward. If McGovern is out it's afait accompli that Barrass plays. How Sinclair and Naitanui are used when they're not rucking is another question and it's probably smart to play a ruck in defense rather than compromise our run at ground level.
Did you and the other players get stuck into him? Not watching the game.Was about 20m from the Richards hit, he's gone. Definitely helps.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Barrass may not be the only choice as Sinclair to Tippett makes sense. McInness in as 2nd ruck and hopefully no Pyke.
), HutchingsTed Richards could be in trouble
Would rather bring in Barrass to be honest. Has been in great form, and defence is his natural role.What do people think about trying Darling down back?
Don't really want to bring in key position players who aren't ready.
We can still have Kennedy, Hill/Lecras and a resting ruck forward as targets. Seemed to work pretty well early in the year when Darling was out.
Or potentially throw a resting ruck into defence. Sinclair offers nothing as a forward anyway. Granted his marking quite good. That could be better used to save us down back.
I'm going to choose my words carefully Re Sinclair because he took several good marks today. But if he was to stay in the WAFL until he learned a) how to kick for goal & b) kick over the man on the mark that would be fantastic.
As for changes:
Out: Gov (inj) Sinclair (above) Selwood
In: Barass, Mcinnes, anyone Butler maybe?
Barass 9 marks in defence today, ready to be tested against the big boysUnless we throw McInness back, we have no choice
Sydney board have the following outs:
Richards, Bird & Tippet.
Possible Jetta
Tippet out would be a huge equaliser. Huge.
Woah Woah..everyone's getting too quick to pull the trigger on Selwood ! I think he should still be played because.....nup got nothing.

Glad I'm not the only one who saw this. Tough little AFL ready nugget he is.Hutchings played really well. Forgotten how nippy and creative he was.
This will be unpopular, but I don't think Selwood was that bad today. That being said, Hutchings was really impressive when he came on.
Hope Gov gets up, seems unlikely. It's Barrass time!!!!