Changes vs Collingwood

[ozph1870]

Amon for gray makes sense too...

 

[PowerLil]

Farrel for gray.
Jonas for lienert if fit.

The bloke that is so close to debuting is garner. Not sure if it's this week but I wouldn't be surprised.

100% this.

 

[PAFC66]

No we aren't..

Letting 5 goals go through in under 10 minutes against the worst team in the competition doesn't lead us we'll into next week against the likes of Collingwood and Degoey. We clearly missed Jonas , he's a general down back and we won't win without him.

 

[Janus]

Id be amazed if Hinkley picked Frampton. Wouldn't pick him last year when we desperately needed a ruck.

Frampton isn’t a ruck.

I think we need a contested marking tall far more than we need an agile small at a narrow ground like Marvel. We need to create space ourselves.

If Dixon was available, he’d be playing.

 

[Rexie J]

How's ken in the presser..

" Yeah we are healthy, no injuries"

They are your words not Hinkley's.

Ken said, "No, not as yet but hopefully there's not......."

 

[PAFC66]

We definitely need another tall. Ken would win a lot of respect if he went slightly left field for once and picked Frampton. Make players like Howe and Moore accountable.

 

[ozph1870]

Letting 5 goals go through in under 10 minutes against the worst team in the competition doesn't lead us we'll into next week against the likes of Collingwood and Degoey. We clearly missed Jonas , he's a general down back and we won't win without him.

Letting 5 goals in late means absolutely fk all and has no bearing on Friday nights game.
Id be way more confident if it was at the g, in fact I'd back us there with no hisitation.

If there's no Jonas Clurey on Degoey Howard on Cox. Houston on mihochek. Dbj on Elliott, we match up ok still.

 

[PAFC66]

They are your words not Hinkley's.

Ken said, "No, not as yet but hopefully there's not......."

Whocares. Robbie has clearly been playing injured for over a month..

 

[philthy05]

I imagine clurey or Jonas take degoey if he is deep and doogs goes to him if he pushes up towards chf.

 

[Iwish]

So im hearing dixon is running well without discomfort from his injury which is great news. But as others have said he still needs match simulation contact etc. Lets not rush him if he comes back about 6 weeks out from finals it would be a good result

 

[PAFC66]

Letting 5 goals in late means absolutely fk all and has no bearing on Friday nights game.
Id be way more confident if it was at the g, in fact I'd back us there with no hisitation.

If there's no Jonas Clurey on Degoey Howard on Cox. Houston on mihochek. Dbj on Elliott, we match up ok still.

Clurey on de goey? Like last year where he tore us apart?

 

[PAFC66]

So im hearing dixon is running well without discomfort from his injury which is great news. But as others have said he still needs match simulation contact etc. Lets not rush him if he comes back about 6 weeks out from finals it would be a good result

We have to make finals.

 

[ozph1870]

Clurey on de goey? Like last year where he tore us apart?

We are in a different spot this year. Vastly different team.

 

[philthy05]

I think all of Frampton, Farrell and Amon should be strongly considered for this weekend to replace Robbie. Each player is worthy of being picked.

Farrell is the one I’m really excited to see at afl level at some stage

 

[Janus]

I'd be very surprised if he's only one month away when he's just started running... No contact stuff yet or match simulation, he most likely will play for Magpies first. He'd still be a long way off surely

Dixon didn’t do a shoulder. He doesn’t need to worry about contact stuff. Two weeks of running on grass, two weeks in the SANFL, back for the Shanghai game or directly after the bye (probably more likely).

I just think if they’ve got a timeframe on Charlie and with Robbie out, it’s a perfect time to get the setup right and back to what we wanted to play with Westhoff doing his roaming that he loves to do. Rather than wait for Dixon to come back in and have a few weeks of stupidly bombing it forward like we did when we first put him into the team.

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

Motlop was garbage yesterday & his bludging and loafing around sets a shit example.

 

[PAFC66]

We are in a different spot this year. Vastly different team.

Defence is basically the same mate. De Goeys influence on this game depends on if Jonas is available or not in my opinion. Howard was a monster last week but really who did he have to contend with besides Brown.

 

[ozph1870]

Defence is basically the same mate.

You can't see the difference in the way we are going about it this year compared to last year??? Bloody hell..

 

[PAFC66]

Motlop was garbage yesterday & his bludging and loafing around sets a shit example.

Fair enough. He's no chance to come in then.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Clurey on de goey? Like last year where he tore us apart?

Jonas was on De Goey last year. De Goey kicked 2 goals in his 14 disposals.

Hardly tore us apart.

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

Fair enough. He's no chance to come in then.

Hinkley

 

[PAFC66]

You can't see the difference in the way we are going about it this year compared to last year??? Bloody hell..

Not really our style of play is 100% more watchable for sure. We've knocked off a few bottom 4 teams by a few goals , lost to a couple we beat last year and had a great win in Perth. Sample is too small so far. We were 11-4 last year and missed finals , forgive me for not being sucked in yet. We are still miles off sides like Collingwood especially without key players available

 

[PAFC66]

Hardly tore us apart.[/QUOTE]

Jonas was on De Goey last year. De Goey kicked 2 goals in his 14 disposals.

Hardly tore us apart.

Clurey and Jonas both had him at times. I remember specifically being annoyed when he kicked a couple they were on Clurey.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Common sense says Amon most likely.

Past experience says Motlop.

Third wish on the genie says #playframpton

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Hardly tore us apart

Clurey and Jonas both had him at times. I remember specifically being annoyed when he kicked a couple they were on Clurey.

Kicked his first goal on Jonas. Stop making stuff up to suit your #fakenews.