That settles it we need two Yoes. That would be a Yoe Yoe or a player that goes up and down. Yea.
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Preview Changes Vs Dorkers Round 3
- Thread starter kane249
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
I'm actually dropping Bennell for the height of McInnes. As for Butler the simple answer is the goal scoring power of Freo's small forwards.
Heaven help us if Bennell was sent to shut down Ballantyne or Walters
Carbine Chaos
TK Defender
- Apr 1, 2009
- 67,914
- 107,150
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth FC, Everton, Delhi
Bennell stays in as far as I'm concerned.
Based on? Just interested in what you think. I get that his attacking mindset is great to have but i question he can do it both ways?
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Carbine Chaos
TK Defender
- Apr 1, 2009
- 67,914
- 107,150
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth FC, Everton, Delhi
His attacking mindset is enough for me, I think it is very valuable. Nelson is doing a great lock down job on the smalls at the moment which means we can afford it as well. I think Jamie didn't play his best game last night but continued to dash out of defence and did a reasonable job at setting up several attacks. Not to mention that I thought Butler was terrible in Round 1 and doesn't deserve a spot any more.
Unfortunately I can't have an opinion on Butler's R1 game as I didn't see the game but if as you say he was terrible against the Bulldogs smalls, the chances that Fremantle's speedy smalls will do the same to him need to be considered.
From 2016 I definately see Nelson regularly playing that Butler role. I just see him with his experience especially against a team with dangerous small forwards as a necessary player. If we take a similar back line in as we had last night I reckon 4 of our back six in Gov, Yeo, Nelson and the other small defender, without knowing exact figures, I reckon they would have played less than 10 derbies between them.
The difference in pressure between a regular season derby and a NAB Challenge derby or game against the Bulldogs and Blues is significant
RookiePick
Hall of Famer
- Aug 13, 2014
- 30,652
- 55,510
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Who was on Hurn last night? Shut him out of the game more or less.
A real shame about Tunbridge, one of his best efforts I thought. I guess I must take some responsibility for making the "Tunners to dominate" call pre-match!
Out: Tunbridge (inj)
In: Lamb
Ellis and Scooter have to come back via WAFL IMO and the new defensive set-up deserves a chance to gel - chopping and changing unnecessarily is going to be counterproductive. I really thought the spoiling to the boundary and the effort to help each other in a contest was good last night albeit under minimal pressure after the first quarter. The better forwards and better service they will get from the Dockers mids will give us a good handle on how resilient we can be down back.
McGinnity was poor last night, even by his standard but against Freo I just don't see any merit in the alternatives - Hill, Karpany and ???
If only Hill had McGinnity's attitude
A real shame about Tunbridge, one of his best efforts I thought. I guess I must take some responsibility for making the "Tunners to dominate" call pre-match!
Out: Tunbridge (inj)
In: Lamb
Ellis and Scooter have to come back via WAFL IMO and the new defensive set-up deserves a chance to gel - chopping and changing unnecessarily is going to be counterproductive. I really thought the spoiling to the boundary and the effort to help each other in a contest was good last night albeit under minimal pressure after the first quarter. The better forwards and better service they will get from the Dockers mids will give us a good handle on how resilient we can be down back.
McGinnity was poor last night, even by his standard but against Freo I just don't see any merit in the alternatives - Hill, Karpany and ???
If only Hill had McGinnity's attitude
- Sep 28, 2009
- 25,450
- 38,088
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Reading FC
Will be little changes with a big win. Mcginnity maybe dropped but who to play a defensive forward role? Possibly Ellis?
Tunbridge out and Duggan to play a full game. Ellis to sub.
Tunbridge out and Duggan to play a full game. Ellis to sub.
McGinnity was woeful. Was not in the same postcode as Yarran in the first half as a lock down player, and was moved off him in the second half and was pretty much just a forward flanker. He didn't do anything as an offensive player either. Has not had a good fortnight, and is not good enough to play at this level. I'd rather play a young runner.
RookiePick
Hall of Famer
- Aug 13, 2014
- 30,652
- 55,510
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Who is the young runner?
Didn't hear much from the Priddis fan boys last week, interesting.
The number one, single reason Priddis gets so many hard ball gets and clearances (if you can call a 1 metre sideways handball to a teammate under pressure a clearance?) is because 95% of the taps are straight down to his feet, you could put almost anyone in the middle in his position and focus 95% of the taps to him and he'll lead us in hard ball gets and clearances. Priddis is rubbish and our ruckmen need to show some more variety with their tap work.
Miguel Sanchez
Snide Shooter
So you want to send McInness to Ballantyne or Walters?
Miguel Sanchez
Snide Shooter
I'd have thought Freo was one side where our lack of key defenders won't hurt us. They still haven't got anyone but Pav have they?
Gov takes Pav, Schofield takes Clarke, Yeo might even get to play on someone his own size for once. Or even move into the middle!
Gov takes Pav, Schofield takes Clarke, Yeo might even get to play on someone his own size for once. Or even move into the middle!
With the 9 day break, we will be nicely freshened up for the purple flogs. We should be a good chance to do them.
I hope the 9 day break will give Tunners time to get up for the clash. We will need his versatility and mongrel.
I hope the 9 day break will give Tunners time to get up for the clash. We will need his versatility and mongrel.
We wont have the space and time to set up and deliver the dispisals , Freo have a way of shutting games down and WCE disposal falls in a heap , followed by the kick over the top to a free running Ballantyne / Walters/ Pavlich .
Hopefully not this time .....hopefully we have turned the corner !
Last edited:
- Sep 16, 2006
- 37,005
- 37,451
- AFL Club
- West Coast
I want to see how they go against Geelong first but I reckon they will play better football this year than they did last year. We could honest to god be smacked this time around.W e wont have the space and time to set up and deliver the dispisals , Freo have a way of shutting games down and WCE disposal falls in a heap , followed by the kick over the top to a free running Ballantyne / Walters/ Pavlich .
Hopefully not this time .....hopefully we have turned the corner !
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Yet we hear from the haters every single week the same come rain, hail or sunshine. He can't do anything right according to the haters
Still don't see why Colledge would do a better job than Priddis in that role
No. As I said before he goes to one of the three talls. But if Bennell is forced to play a accountable role in defence where stuffed which is why Butler should play. Bennell and Butler rotated in and out of the best 22 each week depending on the opposition?
The only tall addition in there best available team would be Taberner as a CHF.
- Sep 28, 2009
- 25,450
- 38,088
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Reading FC
They will have a resting ruckman and Taberner which means we will have to use someone like Yeo on Pav.
- Aug 22, 2009
- 24,555
- 29,452
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Tabs = Yeo/Hurn
Pav = Schoey
Resting ruck = Gov
Walters/Ballantyne = Nelson/Bennell
Ellis and Shep also spending time down back, maybe Rosa too.
Pav = Schoey
Resting ruck = Gov
Walters/Ballantyne = Nelson/Bennell
Ellis and Shep also spending time down back, maybe Rosa too.
