Preview Changes Vs Dorkers Round 3

[Dugg]

he's in my fantasy team like half of this board so hopefully not

Screw your fantasy team mate, the match is more important

Out: Tunbridge (if injured) & McGinnity/Bennell
In: Hutchings/Selwood (If fit) & Ellis

McGinnity & Bennell would have to be the bottom 2 this weekend, even though McGinnity tried his guts out and Bennell was good after half time.

Ellis in would help release Yeo and Hurn a bit more, while Hutchings/Selwood will allow us to tag Mundy, Barlow or Neale...assuming that Rosa goes to Fyfe after his efforts tonight.

I thought Tunbridge put in 100% effort to every contest, and although it didn't come off every time he did some good things. Reminded me of Sheed's efforts last year and look where that has taken Sheed. The fact that the bloke played almost 3 quarters after getting an ankle injury in the first quarter says enough about his attitude.

 

[94_Eagles]

Who comes in, who goes out?

Ins: Lamb
Outs: Tunbridge (Injured/shithouse)

If he's fit then Selwood for McGinnity

Tunbridge was not shit tonight you Charlatan

 

[Cammo46]

Who comes in, who goes out?

Ins: Lamb
Outs: Tunbridge (Injured/shithouse)

If he's fit then Selwood for McGinnity

Mate, Tunbridge was one of the reasons we got back into the game! He has size, strength, great pace, good contested mark for his height and a beautiful left foot kick. Effected a brilliant chase down from behind a Carlton player on the wing on won a HTB decision. Put his body on the line a number of times and took a great contested mark a CHF followed by a lace out pass to Kennedy. Had you actually seen much of him play in the WAFL/NAB cup before you grace us with your thoughtful opinion? Tunbridge is exactly the type of player we need..

 

[eaglesfan84]

Agree with the Lamb change but would actually keep McGinnity (I feel dirty for saying that). He wasn't bad tonight - would be lining up on Ballantyne. Rosa to Fyfe.

Rosa would be a good match up on Fyfe, can run all day and can match him in the air with his height.

Outs: Tunners (He wasn't shithouse, he was quite good and was working his way into the setup, he hasn't been given much of a chance previously to work his way into it), Priddis (still shit), Masten (still super shit)

Ins: Lamb, Colledge, Xellis

Colledge to fulfill Priddis role and Xellis to go as sub, Duggan to get full game on the wing

 

[eaglesfan84]

Ideally:

Out: McGinnity,
In: Ellis

Probably:

Out: Bennell (omitted), Tunbridge (injury)
In: Ellis, Lamb

Id treat Duggan like Gaff was in 2011.

Bennel would be the best match up for Walters no?

 

[ep2018]

I got a good feeling about this one!! Lets smack them.

 

[Prem87]

IN: Ellis Lamb
OUT: Tunbridge Duggan

 

[salo]

you couldn't play mcginnity ahead of a healthy ellis.

in: lamb, ellis
out: tunbridge (inj?), mcginnity

 

[dajesmac]

Hill might be the one in. Would infinitely prefer Lamb though.

OUT: Tunbridge (sob), Bennell (unfairly omitted for Ellis)
IN: Lamb, Ellis

 

[Eastern Rangers]

Bennel would be the best match up for Walters no?

For pace sure. For strength and arial ability not exactly.




Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[eaglesfan84]

For pace sure. For strength and arial ability not exactly.




Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Lets just bring butler back in then shall we?

 

[Turboman1994]

Errr am I missing something I thought bennell had a reasonable game. Few mistakes and not tight enough but loved his drive and skills need to utilise him as a winger more

 

[Dugg]

Errr am I missing something I thought bennell had a reasonable game. Few mistakes and not tight enough but loved his drive and skills need to utilise him as a winger more

First quarter was abysmal. Improved as the game went on.

 

[Sammy J]

Outs: Tunbridge, McGinnitty
Ins: Ellis, Newman

 

[dajesmac]

Outs: Tunbridge, McGinnitty
Ins: Ellis, Newman

wat

 

[Patron]

Big game, we will probably go in as heavy underdogs, at least they don't have a tall forwardline, Pav could be a worry, wonder if schofield or mgovern will take him.

Out: Tunbridge (Calf) Mginnity (omitted)
In: Lamb, Anyone (hutchings/ellis)

I want yeo to the midfield. I think Rosa should definitely be tagging fyfe after this weeks performance. Has the height in the air as well.

Duggan for a full game

Edit - thread already made please merge.

 

[Smotie]

Mate, Tunbridge was one of the reasons we got back into the game! He has size, strength, great pace, good contested mark for his height and a beautiful left foot kick. Effected a brilliant chase down from behind a Carlton player on the wing on won a HTB decision. Put his body on the line a number of times and took a great contested mark a CHF followed by a lace out pass to Kennedy. Had you actually seen much of him play in the WAFL/NAB cup before you grace us with your thoughtful opinion? Tunbridge is exactly the type of player we need..

Good first post.
Agree wholeheartedly

 

[twce13]

Screw your fantasy team mate, the match is more important

Out: Tunbridge (if injured) & McGinnity/Bennell
In: Hutchings/Selwood (If fit) & Ellis

McGinnity & Bennell would have to be the bottom 2 this weekend, even though McGinnity tried his guts out and Bennell was good after half time.

Ellis in would help release Yeo and Hurn a bit more, while Hutchings/Selwood will allow us to tag Mundy, Barlow or Neale...assuming that Rosa goes to Fyfe after his efforts tonight.

I thought Tunbridge put in 100% effort to every contest, and although it didn't come off every time he did some good things. Reminded me of Sheed's efforts last year and look where that has taken Sheed. The fact that the bloke played almost 3 quarters after getting an ankle injury in the first quarter says enough about his attitude.

In what world is hutch a walk up start to the afl team. So overrated on this board, let him play wafl, hopefully much down the pecking order. Don't need his type at all.

 

[Dugg]

In what world is hutch a walk up start to the afl team. So overrated on this board, let him play wafl, hopefully much down the pecking order. Don't need his type at all.

So you'd prefer McGinnity?

 

[Godfather32]

So you'd prefer McGinnity?

I thought McGinnity was in the team because he's fast and has a bit of mongrel. Can't count the number of times he tried to tackle someone tonight only to barely touch their heel and fall flat on his face.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Out: Tunbridge (inj)
In: Lamb

B: Bennell, McGovern, Sheppard
HB: Hurn, Schofield, Yeo
C: Gaff, Priddis, Masten
HF: Wellingham, Kennedy, McGinnity
F: Cripps, Lycett, LeCras
R: Naitanui, Shuey, Rosa
I: Nelson, Sheed, Lamb
S: Duggan again
E: McInnes, Colledge, Hill

Ellis to play for East Perth if he's fit, ditto Butler. Not sure Selwood will be back, would rather not risk him anyway.

 

[Dugg]

I thought McGinnity was in the team because he's fast and has a bit of mongrel. Can't count the number of times he tried to tackle someone tonight only to barely touch their heel and fall flat on his face.

Exactly my thoughts. Couldn't fault the guy on his effort, but just not up to speed (Excuse the pun).

In his defence there were a few good efforts he pulled off, just not enough to lock him in the 22.

 

[Dark Sharks]

I think some people are a little bit slow to realize Tunbridge is in most people OUTS due to injury not form.

If he's fit, i'd certainly give him another crack. He's never had continuity at AFL level. Same as we did for Sheed this week, keep him in.

 

[Shupe]

Thought Bennell was pretty good. Doesn't deserve to be omitted.

 

[wotdoiput]

I thought McGinnity was in the team because he's fast and has a bit of mongrel. Can't count the number of times he tried to tackle someone tonight only to barely touch their heel and fall flat on his face.

Or the number of times Yarran got the ball and McGinnity wasn't in the shot and when the camera panned out he was still no where to be seen.

Didn't matter after qtr time, but my wife was nearly going to come home to a smashed tv after that first quarter.