Changes vs Eagles

[Andy_Mac]

Yeah cos our ruck unit of Jamar/Martin is in horrible form.



Lynch, Darling and Kennedy... you are seriously worried by them?


Worsfold is the one that will have grey hairs this week wondering who to put on Jurrah.

Their forward line would have to be considered ideal for Rivers, Chip and Garland to match up on.

Lecras is a massive loss IMO. We don't really have a naturally suited player for him.

As for Cox/Nat vs. Jamar/Martin again i'm hardly worried. Jamar has destroyed NicNat the past few matches.

 

[Andy_Mac]

\


He has kicked the 2nd most goals behind Jurrah , with 7 so far.

Hes a hard body who plays role well.

No chance he gets dropped, nor should he.

A massive return given who we have played the past 2 weeks and the fact he plays mainly inside forward 50.

 

[Tulip]

No shoe in for we spooners. Davey seen as difficult to man up, how has he been going?

Davey will hopefully be played forward as he has been the last week or two. Really looks more valuable there than in the midfield being tagged

 

[Dez!]

People cannot and should not look at goal return for Lynden Dunn, he's been very good the past few weeks as a workhorse who always creates a contest.

Dunn has been doing all the 1%s which it doesn't seem people are noticing but he is playing well, it would be good if he had a couple more goals to his name but people asking for him to be dropped I find it baffling.

 

[THE STING2]

Out Dunn

He deserves his spot ahead of Watts that is for sure.

 

[Pjkimber]

B: Bartram Frawley Garland

HB: Grimes Rivers Tapscott

C: Gysberts Trengove Bail

HF: Green Watts Sylvia

FF: Wonna Jurrah Davey

R:Jamar Jones Moloney

I: Petterd Martin Morton

Sub: Bennell

Out: Dunn

In: Petterd

Watts on notice...If Dunn tears it up at Casey and Watts has a stinker against WCE, they are a straight swap the week after.

 

[Ausyid]

Davey will hopefully be played forward as he has been the last week or two. Really looks more valuable there than in the midfield being tagged

Davey is still predominantly a midfielder. Has just been having spells forward this year to help him become a harder player to match up on and help him lose his tag as many taggers won't be able to go with him if he's in the forward line. Also with one less on the bench many players need spells elsewhere on the ground rather than sitting on the bench.

 

[Andy_Mac]

He deserves his spot ahead of Watts that is for sure.

On merit he does for sure. But it still doesn't take away from the fact that for Melbourne to be in a flag winning position in 3-4 years time we need Jack Watts to play a be a big part of that side. Carrying him now will pay dividends in the future.

 

[Eth]

In: Petterd
Out: Watts

'Nuff said.

 

[Bartram_Class]

No-one can seriously suggest Dunn and then argue its because he hasn't been in good form, whilst ignoring Watts.

 

[KTLK]

Sorry all,

I have different idea:

In: Petterd (Need more goal kicking power)

Out: Jones (Give him a rest because Subiaco ground does not suit his style)

Note: I would try Watts as full time FF for 4 quarters and see what he is capable of.

B: Bartram Garland Frawley
HB: Tapscott Rivers Grimes
C: Gysberts Moloney Morton
HF: Sylvia Dunn Jurrah
F: Green Watts Petterd
Ruck: Jamar Trengove Davey
Inter: Martin Wona Bail Bennell (Sub)
Emer: Jones Bate Strauss

 

[Crimson Azure]

Note: I would try Watts as full time FF for 4 quarters and see what he is capable of.

I would really like to see that, good or bad just take the chance. I don't know about the entire game but give him a half & if he is not in the game let him push up the ground in the third.

I just want them to try something different with him.

 

[KTLK]

I would really like to see that, good or bad just take the chance. I don't know about the entire game but give him a half & if he is not in the game let him push up the ground in the third.

I just want them to try something different with him.

Thanks Crimson for your suggestion and agreement on Watts.

How about Petterd for Jones?

 

[proka123]

Sorry all,

I have different idea:

In: Petterd (Need more goal kicking power)

Out: Jones (Give him a rest because Subiaco ground does not suit his style)

Note: I would try Watts as full time FF for 4 quarters and see what he is capable of.

B: Bartram Garland Frawley
HB: Tapscott Rivers Grimes
C: Gysberts Moloney Morton
HF: Sylvia Dunn Jurrah
F: Green Watts Petterd
Ruck: Jamar Trengove Davey
Inter: Martin Wona Bail Bennell (Sub)
Emer: Jones Bate Strauss

Jones won't be dropped for any reason.

 

[KTLK]

Jones won't be dropped for any reason.

Correct. However, you have to understand that Subiaco (Fast and Large ground) won't suit Jones.

 

[Tempy Tiger]

I like your line-up KTLK but I'd swap Bail for Jones and use him as the sub, have Bennell on the interchange. Can't wait for the game, two weeks is a long time between drinks.

 

[Theseventhhamster]

+1 on the you can't drop Dunn and keeps Watts in. I want to give Watts every chance but if you keep retaining him while dropping more in-form forwards the team chemistry will start fraying.

 

[SkulZ]

No change for me.

I was at training today for around 15 min before I was asked to leave. I noticed Mckenzie and Campbell joining In the main session and moving well. Obviously wont play this week but was good to see them both up and going.

I'd love to see Blease debut on a big ground like Subi but cant see him getting a game yet.

 

[proka123]

Correct. However, you have to understand that Subiaco (Fast and Large ground) won't suit Jones.

I still think Jones is capable of getting out in the open spaces and using some (some) of his leg speed. He also has a pretty decent hoof on him and long goals from 50m+ are usually the norm in Perth (I just can't bring myself to call it Patersons yet, to early lol).

 

[THE STING2]

Carrying him now will pay dividends in the future.

We don't know that, making him earn his spot could also pay dividends.

I think Casey having the bye is the only thing that could save him, Newton and Maric haven't played in 2 weeks, Bate and Petterd played their first good game for some time last week.

Being the sub against the Gold Coast says it's just a matter of time before Watts gets dropped if he doesn't pull his finger out.

 

[THE STING2]

I'd love to see Blease debut on a big ground like Subi

I would too. It would be great to see Bailey take a risk for once.

 

[BigSexc]

I would too. It would be great to see Bailey take a risk for once.

why? why play players that arent ready when we have ready made players playing the same position?

on your logic we should take a risk with 'fitzy' and gawn and cook all those other shit players we picked up this year.

ridiculous. blease wont play a game this year barring catastrophic injuries.

and stop posting on multiple accounts, or at least change your writing style with each different one

 

[ThePuppetMaster]

Why you mad BS?

 

[BigSexc]

i aint even mad

 

[ThePuppetMaster]

you be trippin' BS