Unofficial Preview Changes vs Freo: Cloke, Brown and Aish in, team in OP

[manicmagpie]

Nice to see Aish in.

Where did people get who was out?

We have media confirmation via Buckley

Cloke, Brown, Aish in.

Note: if weather gets ugly late changes could happen

Only thing I've seen is on the AFL website:

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-06-23/cloke-brown-and-aish-all-to-play-for-collingwood

Mason Cox will be selected to play but may come out of the side, depending on the weather conditions, while Jack Frost will miss.

 

[The Dawes]

Only thing I've seen is on the AFL website:

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-06-23/cloke-brown-and-aish-all-to-play-for-collingwood

coldest day of the year and Jack Frost is out.

irony?

 

[Unknown Identity]

If it's correct, then Phillips would be unlucky, but I imagine someone must go out for Aish.

Separately I'd punt Blair, but that's being silly isn't it?

Kid put his head over the ball and picked up 15 touches on debut.. not sure what else he could of done.. Smith, Blair and Crocker were not effective.. Crocker has played 1 good game and 5 very ineffectual games.

 

[Soaring Magpie]

If these changes are confirmed its a good move, personally I'd have liked to see Blair dropped to be given a message as he's been poor for weeks.

 

[obleex]

Phillips out...really...?

 

[MightyRoar]

Phillips out...really...?

Not sure, there hasn't been any mention of his name and I'd be suprised if he is!!

 

[jackcass]

Scharenberg has played 4 very ordinary games, Ramsay's played 7 and you include their absence on the injury list as some kind of huge team tragedy that is holding us back. Moore gets 8 touches a game at the moment, Broomhead is not best 22 and a soft fringe player, Langdon is not best 22 yet either and depth. As I said, we've got 4 certain best 22 players injured. Have a look at the injury lists for other clubs. Then get back to me if you still think it's a valid excuse to be using at the moment.

Still you persist with this fixation... I'm not sure what part of me saying it's not an excuse, it's a factor, 1 of many, you can't seem to grasp.

You just can't get away from making up crap or reducing aspects to their basest simplicity or conveniently downplaying the relevance of certain players because it accords with your views.

Just point me to where I've said having Scharenberg or Ramsay on the injury list is some huge team tragedy?

Just point me to the post where I've in any way shape or form dismissed or discounted the injury lists of other clubs?

And you're entitled to your opinion on each of the players you've chosen to dismiss, I mine. Happy to agree to disagree.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Sick to death of terrible selection moves this club is making. On balance its ok this week but only beacuse they are rectifying past mistakes.

Aish and Cloke shouldnt be ins because they shouldnt have been outs in the first place!!! Cloke shoudlnt have been dropped after being recalled, and Aish spent too long in the VFL after being dropped. Good to see them back , although Cloke will probably only get dropped again

Witts shouldnt have been selected in the first place, despite his good form...team balance did not allow it and it showed up big time last start. Not without dropping Cox anyway....that said Cox should have made way for Cloke

Phillips only gets a single game...thats rubbish...I'd rest Crocker or Smith. At least they havent picked Wills. He needs more VFL time

Happy with Brown for Frost but thats also probably overdue.


One more change has to happen. Cox out for probably Goldsack.

 

[jackcass]

If we play Both I would Drop Witts and White for Moore and Cloke

Seriously Dave, you'd drop White. He's clearly been our best performed KPF over the last few weeks.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

coldest day of the year and Jack Frost is out.

irony?

And if Goodyear plays? Sums up our year

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Kid put his head over the ball and picked up 15 touches on debut.. not sure what else he could of done.. Smith, Blair and Crocker were not effective.. Crocker has played 1 good game and 5 very ineffectual games.

All valid points.
All well made.

 

[jackcass]

Phillips out...really...?

If he is he may well get a reprieve given the prospective conditions, Cox may yet be omitted.

 

[The Dawes]

Cox to be withdrawn?



sorry.

 

[Kirby]

Cox to be withdrawn?



sorry.

Too soon?

 

[The Dawes]

Too soon?

probably better than being too late.

 

[TradeDraft]

I keep forgetting there is a game on tomorrow.

I surprised the Media ever Remembered

 

[TradeDraft]

Confirmed.

In- Cloke, Aish, Brown
Out- Witts, Phillips, Frost

I'm actually happy with that.

Phillips bit Stiff as did nothing Wrong BUT Best Selections they have had for a Long Time

 

[TradeDraft]

peter ryan ‏@petryan 4m4 minutes ago

Clubs know best but from outside perspective this seems the most logical selections @CollingwoodFC for a while:

I'm with him...

I Agree Too. The Finally make Selections that make Sense

 

[TradeDraft]

Seriously Dave, you'd drop White. He's clearly been our best performed KPF over the last few weeks.

Yes and White been our best KPF because he been in the Longest

 

[stevebbb]

Where is the confirmation that Phillips is out?

 

[Big Bryza]

So Nat Brown has turned into Matty Scarlett since his little break in the magoos?

I'd be disappointed if T Phlip gets dropped. Showed enough against the Dees to suggest he can play a bit. Mature body and good tank on him so will be handy on a cold, wet and windy night at the G tomorrow.

Can't see more than 25-30k being there.

Will we win? NFI. Not sure how anyone can have a clue on what Collingwood side shows up tomorrow night.

 

[Stoods]

If it buckets down all day tomorrow, is there a possibility of a late change-

Out- cox
In- Phillips?

Got White that could pinch hit in the ruck for a bit.

 

[Ulahoopski]

I can beat that.

I see your Indian inspired disco (ahh, my ears!) and raise you --->

 

[mike123]

So Nat Brown has turned into Matty Scarlett since his little break in the magoos?

No we just realised he's better than Frost, which doesn't take much.

 

[Wooljay]

Phillips would surely be staying in.

Actually thought his ability to find and attack the footy was commendable for a debutant.