Preview Changes vs Geelong

[TheKanga]

J-Pod out for the Cats i think, he usually kicks a few against us.
I want to win on friday night so bad!

 

[osaka mick]

In: Greenwood, Daw
Out: Swallow, MacMillan

WHY would you drop JMac. Had a great game again.

You are clearly a poster who has it in for him, as do several others. He is one of the keys to our future finals tilt. We need to give him more games.

If you want him out, you are crazy, IMO.

 

[ozzyoslo]

Out: Swallow (achilles)

In: Harper

Move Atley into the guts. Harper to play that link up speedy outside runner.

Of all the games of the year, youd think Scott could have made this move after hearing Swallow had the red vest. His lack of imagination alarms me. I mean, Scott should stop looking at the data machine, feed back reports and look at the game. We had a perfect opportunity to give Atley a run in the guts that last qtr.

 

[NiceCunnington]

In: Greenwood/Jacobs/Harper. Whoever is in the best form as a ball-winning mid.

Jacobs was the one Scott immediately mentioned in his press conference. I'd like to see him get a chance.

 

[Arthur Cloke]

After such a resonating win, I'd be amazed if there were any changes this week.

You can now follow me on twitter - ArthurCloke

 

[Mr. Blonde]

Would love to see Jacobs come in for Spitta. Not sure what his VFL form has been like over the past few weeks, but he seems to have those real leadership qualities that we will miss with Spitta out of the side.

If not Jacobs, then Gysberts really needs to be given a run.

 

[Jack Reacher]

Out: Swallow (inj), Tarrant, Hine
In: Greenwood, Daw, Jacobs

 

[Benno_900]

Out: Swallow (inj), Tarrant, Hine
In: Greenwood, Daw, Jacobs

Why not Hansen?

 

[Istanbul Roo]

Knowing Scott, Swallow to be replaced by a non-midfielder. :sternlook

unfounded criticism as usual ...

 

[Istanbul Roo]

Out: Swallow (inj), Tarrant, Hine
In: Greenwood, Daw, Jacobs

Tarrant took 10 marks as chf. pretty good i reckon

 

[Istanbul Roo]

Out: Mckenzie, Swallow

In: Greenwood, Jacobs

Mckenzie 15 possessions in a half, why drop him?

 

[Tas]

unfounded criticism as usual ...

Round 10 team changes:

Out: Ziebell (suspension), Daw
In: Sierakowski, Hine

Greenwood should have come in for Ziebell.

 

[Psicosis]

Levi, Jacobs or Gysberts to come in for Spitta.

 

[trooroo4life]

Tarrant took 10 marks as chf. pretty good i reckon

Was very good, also had 10 score involvements. But it's still sh!t according to some of the posters "more in the know" then the rest of us all because he kicked three behinds. They are clowns, just ignore them posters there not hard to pick out.

 

[shinboner magic]

As long as Scott doesn't bring in one of his favs .

 

[jclei]

Gotta be Jacobs or Greenwood for Spitta. No other change.

Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 4 Beta

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

OUT: Swallow, Goldstein
IN: Harper, Currie

- Goldy deserves a break, and our season is over, time to play Currie & see just how good he actually is.
- Harper to play midfield all day (obviously rotating to bench), give him a licence to play his natural game to try and reinstate confidence in him again, let him push forward as a mid.

 

[Pykie]

I'd be bringing in Jacobs.

He's a part of the future, and his performances over the last 6 weeks certainly merit it.

As long as they don't **** around with him on a wing or anything, like for like, play him in exactly the same role as Swallow, I think he will do really well.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

As long as Jacobs can run out a game....

 

[Winter]

OUT: Swallow, Goldstein
IN: Harper, Currie

- Goldy deserves a break, and our season is over, time to play Currie & see just how good he actually is.
- Harper to play midfield all day (obviously rotating to bench), give him a licence to play his natural game to try and reinstate confidence in him again, let him push forward as a mid.

Goldstein played his best game of the year and we can exploit Geelong'ss lack of ruckmen, not the time to gift Currie a game after he was outplayed by Mabon in the VFL.

Harper also had 11 disposals and struggled to have any impact.

We won by 122 points and barring Swallow the poorest performer was Thomas who got beaten by Dunn.

Just the one change for me:

Out: Swallow
In: Jacobs

If Greenwood wants in I want him taking Hine's spot.

 

[roos_fanatic08]

Mckenzie 15 possessions in a half, why drop him?

Rotations mates needs a full game to keep up much fitness

 

[DarwinRoo]

OUT: Swallow, Goldstein
IN: Harper, Currie

- Goldy deserves a break, and our season is over, time to play Currie & see just how good he actually is.
- Harper to play midfield all day (obviously rotating to bench), give him a licence to play his natural game to try and reinstate confidence in him again, let him push forward as a mid.

Why would we give Goldy a break when we play the Cats when we could have done it against Melbourne?

 

[Roosurgence]

McMillian? Seriously?

You couldn't drop McMillan on today's performance, but as we all know he is one the best downhill skiers in the game, so expect zero output from him against quality opposition. Still waiting to see him perform against quality, until then will just be another Liam Anthony, good when its running our way and invisible when its not.

 

[TheKanga]

Would a Currie/Goldy two ruck setup be a good tactic for this game?
Given that Geelong have lost their first choice ruckman to injury.

 

[Pykie]

Would a Currie/Goldy two ruck setup be a good tactic for this game?
Given that Geelong have lost their first choice ruckman to injury.

Geelong have plenty of ruck depth.

Blicavs, West, Vardy............

They will just replace Simpson with one of West or Blicavs.

I'd be playing Currie this week, especially if Blicavs plays. Whilst he's not an AA ruckman, he will grind Goldy into the ground in the second half of the game.