Changes vs Geelong

[_RT_]

IMO there should be one change, Pettifer out and either Riewoldt or Meyer in. As the Coburg side does not play for the next 2 weeks we should give another kid a shot. No-one really played badly yesterday but Petts seems to be a little down on confidence and should be given a run in the Coburg side to regain some.

 

[Grechy]

IMO there should be one change, Pettifer out and either Riewoldt or Meyer in. As the Coburg side does not play for the next 2 weeks we should give another kid a shot. No-one really played badly yesterday but Petts seems to be a little down on confidence and should be given a run in the Coburg side to regain some.

Out: Pettifer

In: Meyer

A small forward for another small forward/outside midfielder with 10x more potential. Pettifer is handy when he's kicking goals but when he's off he's pathetic. If not I'd like to see Riewoldt get a run as he's been great in the reserves and provides another tall option up forward.

 

[sante]

I don't think we'll change. Unless they drop Edwards which would be harsh.

 

[_RT_]

Didn't realise another thread was already started would the mods please merge this in with the original thread.

 

[Delidio]

IN: Polo, Meyer

OUT: Edwards, JON

 

[banzai]

We all know Krakouer will come straight back in

 

[Calcium Man]

IN: Polo, Meyer

OUT: Edwards, JON

Why would you want to drop JON??

 

[Richo Rules]

going by what TW has said
krakouer was dropped and not injured
and said meyer would play next week

IN- Meyer - Polo

OUT- Tivendale - Pettifer

 

[sante]

Why would you want to drop JON??

Agree. He is very athletic, got a good vertical leap.

going by what TW has said
krakouer was dropped and not injured
and said meyer would play next week

IN- Meyer - Polo

OUT- Tivendale - Pettifer

Terry won't drop either of them. If Meyer is in as you say then,

IN: Meyer - Polo
OUT: King - Edwards

 

[Truetiger]

Agree. He is very athletic, got a good vertical leap.



Terry won't drop either of them. If Meyer is in as you say then,

IN: Meyer - Polo
OUT: King - Edwards

You have no idea one trend u say Edwards is class? however u want him out of the side. Thats so bloody stupid. Edwards should stay!

 

[polakthetiger]

There is no mention of Browny fitting in here?? Wasn't the word he was 'nearly' right last week but left it one more week??

 

[krustyman]

I want drop the youngster because they are just passengers at the moment and dont use the ball well and need more time
Out: Edwards, King, Jackson, Oakley-Nicholls
In Bowden, Polo, Meyer, White
Emergency: ?

 

[Calcium Man]

You have no idea one trend u say Edwards is class? however u want him out of the side. Thats so bloody stupid. Edwards should stay!

I've thought about it and decide that it would probably be good for edwards to go back to Coburg and get a full 4 quarters of footy. He will hopefully play 10-12 games this season.

 

[Calcium Man]

I want drop the youngster because they are just passengers at the moment and dont use the ball well and need more time
Out: Edwards, King, Jackson, Oakley-Nicholls
In Bowden, Polo, Meyer, White
Emergency: ?

Wouldnt drop either of those two. JON is at a stage where he needs to get AFL games into him. This season is a good chance to have him play 15 matches. Jackson needs a consistent run in the seniors to try and prove whether he is up to AFL standard. I'm not overly impressed with jackson but we need to give him a month of solid AFL football minimum.

P. Bowden is one of the biggest passengers we have ATM. If he wants to play AFL tell him he needs to tear the VFL apart for a month.

 

[_RT_]

I've thought about it and decide that it would probably be good for edwards to go back to Coburg and get a full 4 quarters of footy. He will hopefully play 10-12 games this season.

Thinking about it this makes a lot of sense. Perhaps send Hyde King & Edwards back as Coburg has the bye this week and bring in PB Meyer & Riewoldt. Pettifer gets one last week to step up and show something as he would gain nothing by playing for Coburg's reserves side except a bunch of goals.

Perhaps a line up of:
B: Raines Gaspar(unfortunately) McGuane
HB: Newman Polak JB
C: Tivendale Johnson Deledio
HF: Meyer Hughes Pettifer
F: Richo Schulz Tambling
R: Simmonds Tuck Foley
I: JON Jackson PB Riewoldt

 

[Calcium Man]

Thinking about it this makes a lot of sense. Perhaps send Hyde King & Edwards back as Coburg has the bye this week and bring in PB Meyer & Riewoldt. Pettifer gets one last week to step up and show something as he would gain nothing by playing for Coburg's reserves side except a bunch of goals.

Perhaps a line up of:
B: Raines Gaspar(unfortunately) McGuane
HB: Newman Polak JB
C: Tivendale Johnson Deledio
HF: Meyer Hughes Pettifer
F: Richo Schulz Tambling
R: Simmonds Tuck Foley
I: JON Jackson PB Riewoldt

The only change i would make is Polo for PB. Paddy needs a massive kick up the arse. I would tell him he isnt playing for 4 weeks after that we will re-asses and if he is ripping up the VFL, like he should be, then he can have a recall. Has to prove he wants to be an AFL footballer.

As for gasper as much as it pains me he will get another 3-4 weeks of football until Thursfield gets some game time into his legs at coburg.

 

[carn_the_cattas]

In: Richmond's first win
Out: More of Geelong's hope.

 

[sante]

In: Richmond's first win
Out: More of Geelong's hope.

Yep. Cannot wait...Oh we're from Tigerland

 

[cats2rise]

No chance for Kingsley? I have a Kent Kingsley Krew t-shirt. I love the man!

 

[Calcium Man]

No chance for Kingsley? I have a Kent Kingsley Krew t-shirt. I love the man!

He has just come back from injury. Played coburg ressies on the weekend so doubt he will come back thise weekend. Hopefully if Hughes continues to play the way he did on Sat and Schulz gets his kicking boots back we wont need Kent.

 

[PHX]

No chance for Kingsley? I have a Kent Kingsley Krew t-shirt. I love the man!

lol. Naa he's playing for Coburg though this weekend in his comeback. I'm sure he'd enjoy your support if you went and watched.

 

[rota69]

Must it be heard again

COBURG IN
RICHMOND OUT (BAR DELEDIO)

 

[Bentleigh]

Out

- Tivendale
- Pettifer

In

- Polo
- Meyer


Defending on Geelongs team (Ottens playing?) I'd drop Gaspar for Moore too.

 

[Richo Rules]

Terry won't drop either of them. If Meyer is in as you say then,

yeah sure he wont
we are travelling so well and tivendale and pettifer are leading the brownlow votes so they are untouchable
and i didnt say meyer was in TW did himself
his quote was that Polo may have won the medal but he thought meyer was best on ground that day and will play against the cats

 

[ata40]

Starting to get some depth with Polo, Krakeour, P Bowden, Meyer and even Riewolt putting their names up for selection thios week.

Hopefully over the coming weeks we can add Brown, Pattison, Moore, Howat, Casserley, White, Conners etc. to the above list.

Barring injuries by the end of the season we would be aiming to have a list of about 32 vying for senior selection.