Prediction Changes vs Lions

[Doggy]

 

[Testekill]

Okay but our reserves are also playing at Moreton Bay on Friday so it's not exactly a confirmation.

 

[Doggy]

Okay but our reserves are also playing at Moreton Bay on Friday so it's not exactly a confirmation.

That was with 20 senior players .. not with VFL players. It's in the twitter comments

 

[doggiesin08]

That was with 20 senior players .. not with VFL players. It's in the twitter comments

If he’s flying with 20 senior players we’ll still be 1 short.

 

[Testekill]

If he’s flying with 20 senior players we’ll still be 1 short.

Sam Darcy flew up as well. Bailey Dale said that Caleb is crook and stayed down in Melbourne.

 

[dogwatch]

Sam Darcy flew up as well. Bailey Dale said that Caleb is crook and stayed down in Melbourne.

This game is sounding worse and worse all the time.

Unavailable: English, Daniel, B Smith, Richards, Duryea, Bruce, Wallis, Vandermeer, McLean (needs time in VFL), Hannan (ditto), Martin. At least 7 of those would be walk up starts in the seniors if available.

 

[Libba39]

Okay but our reserves are also playing at Moreton Bay on Friday so it's not exactly a confirmation.

Are we playing the Figs or the Bugs this week?

 

[Testekill]

Are we playing the Figs or the Bugs this week?

Bugs obviously.

 

[Testekill]

This game is sounding worse and worse all the time.

Unavailable: English, Daniel, B Smith, Richards, Duryea, Bruce, Wallis, Vandermeer, McLean (needs time in VFL), Hannan (ditto), Martin. At least 7 of those would be walk up starts in the seniors if available.

It's going to take a big game to win, we're missing a significant chunk of our preferred backline.

 

[Norm De Guerre]

Team selection is a really weird crumbling hill that people are choosing to commit their Bigfooty Seppuku on.

 

[BrisDog]

So MD, Virgin Dog and BrisDog are all the same person?

I am slowly coming to the conclusion there are only myself and one other poster on here, and we just use lots of alts each.

View attachment 1435656

Hang on - do I sound like MD? I f**king loved Jongy and reckon Bailey Dale is our best half back since Rohan Smith!

 

[doggies ftw]

Team selection is a really weird crumbling hill that people are choosing to commit their Bigfooty Seppuku on.

You reckon we still lose the Geelong game if we pick a proper football team? Team selection matters big time, probably trivial which C graders fill the bench whether it’s McComb, McNeil, Roarke etc who gives a s**t - but team selection has lost us games this year no doubt about it. It’s not really forgivable considering the position we find ourselves in now

 

[ScragCity]

but team selection has lost us games this year no doubt about it.

I doubt your counterfactuals.

 

[Norm De Guerre]

You reckon we still lose the Geelong game if we pick a proper football team? Team selection matters big time, probably trivial which C graders fill the bench whether it’s McComb, McNeil, Roarke etc who gives a s**t - but team selection has lost us games this year no doubt about it. It’s not really forgivable considering the position we find ourselves in now

I dont know. Like you, I am not privy to the machinations as to why the match committee select who they select.

What I do know is that the Bigfooty trope where posters say with absolute certainty that if player whoever was selected then we win to be laughable. There are way too many variables at play during any game for it to be a provable fact.

 

[Doggiesfan14]

Daniel out (knee cartilage), Hunter in as per channel 7

 

[doggies ftw]

I dont know. Like you, I am not privy to the machinations as to why the match committee select who they select.

What I do know is that the Bigfooty trope where posters say with absolute certainty that if player whoever was selected then we win to be laughable. There are way too many variables at play during any game for it to be a provable fact.

Why certain players were picked we have no idea of course yet we can look at results. Obviously there’s variables but there’s variables in everything so we may as well discuss nothing I suppose?

I think it’s pretty fair that a lot of people here think team selection has harmed our chances of winning more games, if you’re not interested in talking team selection that’s fine but I’m not sure why you’re in a changes thread on team selection night then lmao

 

[The Inbetweener]

Daniel out (knee cartilage), Hunter in as per channel 7

Cool. More best 22 players injured.

 

[Snarls Barkley]

Changes seem fine.

Will be interesting to see who goes back. My guess is JJ and Scott. Williams named at half back but I don’t think I want him playing back again

 

[weltschmerz]

If we’re winning this one it’s gotta be because our midfielders go absolute beast mode.

 

[Charlie Bucket]

Big Craig Darcevich named in the emergencies Wowweee!!

Maybe closer to a call up than first thought.

 

[weltschmerz]

Love to see Darcy on the emergency list, even if it’s just for match day experience plus in case Sweet dies in the warmup.

 

[ThePhreshOne]

Changes seem fine.

Will be interesting to see who goes back. My guess is JJ and Scott. Williams named at half back but I don’t think I want him playing back again

I would’ve thought our backline would be something like:

JJ - O’Brien - Williams
Crozier - Keath - Gardner

 

[Golden_6]

Changes seem fine. Will be interesting to see who goes back. My guess is JJ and Scott. Williams named at half back but I don’t think I want him playing back again

I think it’ll be Scott & Williams back with Hunter/Bedendo/McComb as the wing rotation.

Daniel’s injury is a bit of a concern. Knee cartilege issues usually require some sort of surgical intervention.

 

[doggies ftw]

That’s a lot of drive missing from our backline - really interested to see how we set up.

Don’t love Hunter & Scott on both wings, very very bland. Hopefully Bedendo spends some time there if Williams goes back.

Tbh I don’t want to move Williams or JJ back, and Scott doesn’t fill me with much confidence either but we may have to considering we didn’t pick Cleary or something

 

[Doggy]

More injuries to best 22 allows Brisbane to downhill skii a bit more.

They're a nothing side who can't get it done when it really matters