Changes vs Melbourne

[Leslie_Chow]

Out;

Mundy

In;

Barlow


Palmer needs a few more weeks in the Wafl to qualify for finals

 

[Scham]

Barlow in for Mundy, Hinkley as sub again.

 

[electricfeel]

In: BARLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (that many exclamation marks are necessary)

Out: Mundy, apparently Ballaz hurt his hamstring late in the game?

 

[Higs]

In Barlow, Palmer (?)

Out Mundy, Balla (hammy?)

 

[silverscope]

In: Barlow, Palmer

Out: Mundy, Ballantyne

One of Barlow/Palmer/Hinkley as the sub.

 

[Seppo]

Let's give Barlow the start and go Palmer as sub.

The rate we are going with injuries we can't have those two on at the same time...

 

[Latro]

Why would we bring in Palmer for Ballantyne if he is injured. Palmer is a shit forward. Mellington should be brought in if Balla is injured.

 

[paccraig]

Fyfe has a big engine & ticker, but he does look tired. Wouldnt want a rest, but must be tempting.

ps - in post match interview interesting he is now 190cm, from 186cm last year

 

[DCFCFAN84]

Why would we bring in Palmer for Ballantyne if he is injured. Palmer is a shit forward. Mellington should be brought in if Balla is injured.

Agreed Mellington should come in if balantyne is out.

 

[Scham]

Agreed Mellington should come in if balantyne is out.

He's not your small dynamic FP, but yeah, I'll "third" that.

 

[markfarmer]

Don't forget about Walters..

 

[more_of_bito]

apparently after last week Crichton was certain to be dropped, good to see he's retained his spot. Palmer has earned a spot for his efforts in WAFL. Barlow, of course can't wait to see him at the G.

 

[Danny82]

IN: Barlow, Palmer, Walters
OUT: Mundy (inj), Clarke, Hinkley

If Ballantyne is injured, then Hinkley retains his spot.

 

[E Shed]

Fyfe has a big engine & ticker, but he does look tired. Wouldnt want a rest, but must be tempting.

ps - in post match interview interesting he is now 190cm, from 186cm last year

I love what Gerald Heally said (I'm watching a replay now).

"Last year Freo were worried Nathan Fyfe was too small to play AFL, well he looks like he's put on about half a kilo and he's dominating the competition!"

 

[free at last]

out : mundy,hinkley

in:barlow,palmer or osso buco

if bailey can play scully through the midfield,can't see why harvs can't play palms through the midfield .both players are heavily linked to GWS.

 

[36Crazyfists]

In: Barlow
Out: Mundy

If Ballas is struggling and doesn't get up for next sunday I too wouldn't mind seeing Mellington come in.

 

[Latro]

out : mundy,hinkley

in:barlow,palmer or osso buco

if bailey can play scully through the midfield,can't see why harvs can't play palms through the midfield .both players are heavily linked to GWS.

Because Scully is ten times the player of Palmer and in the top3 midfielders at the club.

 

[more_of_bito]

I love what Gerald Heally said (I'm watching a replay now).

"Last year Freo were worried Nathan Fyfe was too small to play AFL, well he looks like he's put on about half a kilo and he's dominating the competition!"

apparently Fyfe was coaching the bombers on the sidelines last quarter... oh wait up that was James Hird... TBC

 

[free at last]

Because Scully is ten times the player of Palmer and in the top3 midfielders at the club.

im not saying palms is better than scully.both are mids.i just want to see palms played through the midfield to confirm to me whether or not he is able to recapture 2008 form.i will be able to accept it better if palms performs solidly now,than next year at GWS, he shines again.

 

[Mockcockpit]

So if the WAFL has a bye this coming weekend what do we do about SNOS and Wodger the wascally wuck wover? Both played ressies this week and would obviously benefit from an extra hitout like Barlow but because it's at the MCG I'd be tempted to play Hayden for Myra.
Edit- it's Myra Hindley not Hinkley, way to ruin a perfectly good nickname google.

 

[TheLoris]

In: The Messiah
Out: Mundy

Would love to see Palmer come in but I don't like dropping players from a winning team, so sorry Rhys, you may have to wait until next year.

 

[TIME IS NOW]

Im going to get shut down here, but Keplar wouldn't be a instant pick right now.

He's just gone off a little I think and his back up ruckman duties aren't as important now.

Holds his spot obviously but a couple of quiet games and he may find himself struggling when Sandi comes back in.

 

[Freodoc]

Im going to get shut down here, but Keplar wouldn't be a instant pick right now.

He's just gone off a little I think and his back up ruckman duties aren't as important now.

Holds his spot obviously but a couple of quiet games and he may find himself struggling when Sandi comes back in.

Obviously Keps looked a bit wonky after that collision and basically buggered late in the 4th. Maybe he should have a rest..

 

[Rob]

Long range forecast is showers, max 15.

If it is raining, then i'd be tempted to go in with 1 less tall, that obviously being Clarke. Although if Ballantyne doesn't come up, his replacement might be a tad problematic.

 

[TheLoris]

Long range forecast is showers, max 15.

If it is raining, then i'd be tempted to go in with 1 less tall, that obviously being Clarke. Although if Ballantyne doesn't come up, his replacement might be a tad problematic.

I thought Balla looked ok after the game, Mayne would be the one who might struggle to come up.

If you drop a tall...........Clarke or Griff..........both playing well, Clarke better around the ground but we'll need a genuine ruck so I'd play Griff.