Preview Changes vs Richmond

[kaiserchief13]

How is there no thread already?

I'd like to see

Out - Petruccelle
In - Cameron

That is if no injuries

 

[Candiru]

Duggan good to go yet?

 

[greatwhiteshark]

Petch out, Cameron in.

 

[kane249]

In: Rotham, Cameron
Out: Schofield, Waterman

Back line will be too tall and lack mobility in the current setup vs the Tigers. Same reason would drop Waterman, which would be a shame as Waterman played well today.

 

[ep2018]

Duggan good to go yet?

He'll play WAFL this coming week imo.

 

[HoneyBadger35]

Cameron for Petch.

If he wasn’t dropped in the weeks before, he won’t be dropped now, but if it were up to me I’d also do Masten for Waterman and send Hutch to Houli.

 

[eagleskickass]

I think Perch will come good, just not this year. He gets to good places, just needs to develop over another preseason.

Petch for Cameron good with me!

 

[Eagleboy68]

Out: Hutchings, hickey
In: cameron, Williams/brooksby

 

[kaiserchief13]

I think Perch will come good, just not this year. He gets to good places, just needs to develop over another preseason.

Petch for Cameron good with me!

Sure if he works on his kicking he will be a very good player. Until then though he is a liability

 

[InTheWings]

Schoey out for Duggo (if fit) / Rotham /Watson
Waterman out for Cameron

 

[Biggie]

Not sure - Cameron may come in for Petch, not sure Waterman will be dropped.

 

[Tugga27]

Not sure - Cameron may come in for Petch, not sure Waterman will be dropped.

Doubt if Waterman will get dropped after kicking 3.

 

[Candiru]

Can't see the logic behind calls to drop Schofield.

You want McGovern to be responsible for Riewoldt or Lynch?

Tigers are the exact kind of opponent where Schofield is required.

 

[woosha24]

Petch for Cameron.

Fancy Cameron's defensive game over Petch's pure speed for this one, especially if we are going to play no-name opposition forwards into AA form every f*cken game.

 

[West World]

In: Rotham, Cameron
Out: Schofield, Waterman

Back line will be too tall and lack mobility in the current setup vs the Tigers. Same reason would drop Waterman, which would be a shame as Waterman played well today.

Leave Kennedy at home, no way Waterman gets dropped if you want to go small.

If wet then Schofield out for a small, dare I even suggest Masten.

So Out:: Kennedy, Schofield

In: Cameron and Masten

Did anyone stand out for the Beagles? Ah chee,?

 

[West Coast 06]

No changes.

Would like to see the side settled as much as possible from here.

 

[bigmikles089]

Out: Hutchings, hickey
In: cameron, Williams/brooksby

Grow up

 

[numbat06]

Waterman played well, hope he isn't dropped.
In- Cameron
Out- Petch

 

[Eagleboy68]

He has a point

I have an opinion and I need to grow up?

The ones who need to grow up are those who can't handles differing opinions and funny enough, you're one of them.

There are a few on this board who make it their mission to victimize those who express differing opinions to the "status quo"

Well to you I say...go * yourselves.

Hickey should not be in our side in my opinion.

 

[Priddis Is Done]

I have an opinion and I need to grow up?

The ones who need to grow up are those who can't handles differing opinions and funny enough, you're one of them.

There are a few on this board who make it their mission to victimised those who express differing opinions to the "status quo"

Well to you I say...go fu** yourselves.

Hickey should not be in our side in my opinion.

Fair enough

 

[West World]

Can't see the logic behind calls to drop Schofield.

You want McGovern to be responsible for Riewoldt or Lynch?

Tigers are the exact kind of opponent where Schofield is required.

Barrass on Lynch is obvious.

Riewoldt though isnt a good match for Schofield, Sheppard often takes the more modile tall and the yes Gov does his AA zone off and intercept work.

Im worried about three lumbering talls versub the quick tigers smaller / medium forwards.

Rotham or Watson may be a better fit.

What will the weather be also a factor.

 

[amazingjoshy]

No changes

How often is 1v2 not match of the round?

 

[KO_KO]

Out: masten and waterman


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Candiru]

Barrass on Lynch is obvious.

Riewoldt though isnt a good match for Schofield, Sheppard often takes the more modile tall and the yes Gov does his AA zone off and intercept work.

Im worried about three lumbering talls versub the quick tigers smaller / medium forwards.

Rotham or Watson may be a better fit.

If Lynch and Riewoldt isn't an instance where we need Schofield, he should never play. Richmond have two genuine tall forwards. We need two genuine tall defenders, aside from McGovern.

Schofield isn't a "lumbering tall". He's a tall defender who is also a dedicated stopper, which makes perfect sense for an opponent like Riewoldt.

Rotham has played 3 games, Watson has played 2.

 

[West World]

I have an opinion and I need to grow up?

The ones who need to grow up are those who can't handles differing opinions and funny enough, you're one of them.

There are a few on this board who make it their mission to victimize those who express differing opinions to the "status quo"

Well to you I say...go fu** yourselves.

Hickey should not be in our side in my opinion.

But Hickey played another decent game today.

And there is no viable other option.

He's playing better than most expected and as a min holds his own versus non elite rucks.