changes vs slime

[hamush]

OUT IN

foster walters

mundy anyone


mundy was an absolute discrace as usual

 

[Chris25]

Hard to say given all the injuries, but assuming a lot, I would go...

Out: Foster (inj), Tarrant (inj), Campbell, Ruffles, Peake

In: Pavlich, Sandilands, Headland, Schammer, Walters/Pratt

McPharlin keeps his spot only because of Tarrant's injury, and without him we would have no other tall options down back. Mundy keeps his spot too, if we didn't have so many players out then maybe he would be dropped, but we can't drop everyone who has an average match.

 

[Plugga]

OUT:
Foster (inj)
Tarrant (inj)
Bradley (don't need him if 211 fit)
Mundy (poor form)

IN:
Pavlich (if fit)
Sandilands
Headland (if fit)
Schammer (if fit)

 

[hoss]

McPharlin and Mundy are the two certainties that SHOULD be dropped.

But they won't be.

 

[Bradesmaen]

McPharlin and Mundy are the two certainties that SHOULD be dropped.

But they won't be.

/facepalm.

Mundy had 7 tackles, McPharlin was shit. Problem being is we don't have the cavalry to drop them. Nor did Mundy play bad enough to be dropped. He's not a midfielder, he's a makeshift midfielder due to the lack of depth we have in our midfield. I do not think Harvey expects him to get Gary Ablett numbers, nor should we expect him to get that.

 

[Lach72]

McPharlin and Mundy are the two certainties that SHOULD be dropped.

But they won't be.

Luke should go back to CHB and the great man goes forward.

Mundy, I'd drop him at Peel with a sign around his neck

 

[purplepassion82]

In - Pav, Sandi, Schammer, Walters.

Out - Ruffles, Foster, Bradley and Tarrant.

I really hope tazza is a miracle healer. He is our rock in the back line. If he is out then McPharlin MUST go back and Pav MUST go forward.

I'd really LOVE to see mundy and McPharlin dropped however we simply dont have the players to cover them.

 

[Rob]

I'd shoot Mundy in the head just to make sure he never plays another game for us again. I counted 5 times that he refused to go in and get the ball by pulling up short from a contest. The guy is a deadset squib, and a slow squib at that.

While Campbell has absolutely no chance of playing for us next year, i'd prefer him over Murphy, and we need someone there.

 

[Cameron_K]

My favourite Mundy moment came in the last, ball is 15 metres out from the Freo 50 and he stands there watching while Haselby slings his body across the wet floor. Was quite comical

 

[pinkus maximus]

what about Hill out? He looks really jaded to me, we dont want to be running him into the ground

 

[Bradesmaen]

My favourite Mundy moment came in the last, ball is 15 metres out from the Freo 50 and he stands there watching while Haselby slings his body across the wet floor. Was quite comical

They both went to go, Mundy stopped because Hase went. So what you are saying basically, is you want both guys to dive in at the same ball, lose the ball, get injured and concede a goal. Ok

 

[Clay Davis]

They both went to go, Mundy stopped because Hase went. So what you are saying basically, is you want both guys to dive in at the same ball, lose the ball, get injured and concede a goal. Ok

Mundy was closer, stopped, watched, and thankfully Hase dived in to get it.

If Hase wasn't there, it would have been an easy Brisbane ball.

 

[Rob]

what about Hill out? He looks really jaded to me, we dont want to be running him into the ground

He can be jaded in 6 weeks all he likes, he's paid to play. If we had even remotely close to a full list maybe he can have a rest. But we've got at least 3 players that are just not up to playing AFL football out there (outside of the D.A.B), let alone not having anyone playing in the WAFL that can step up.

 

[fitzmantle]

if only we get rid of mundy, we will win all our games?

ffs guys get a new hobby

 

[ImperialPurple]

My favourite Mundy moment came in the last, ball is 15 metres out from the Freo 50 and he stands there watching while Haselby slings his body across the wet floor. Was quite comical

My 12 y.o son got pushed over by his 10 y.o sister just before, and then had a whinge about it... his father rolled his eyes and muttered... "jesus, we'll have to start calling him David Mundy"...

 

[freo grover]

OUT - Mundy (a 5 year old girl is tougher than him), Peake (back to WAFL reserves), Foster, Taz (if unfit)

IN- Pav, Sandi, Scham, Headland?/Walters

 

[Lach72]

if only we get rid of mundy, we will win all our games?

ffs guys get a new hobby

Nah just perhaps another player who looks like he wants to play for the jumper.

Watch the young fellas throwing their skinny bodies on the lone and then watch him.

If you want that, good luck to you

 

[sumavich]

He can be jaded in 6 weeks all he likes, he's paid to play. If we had even remotely close to a full list maybe he can have a rest. But we've got at least 3 players that are just not up to playing AFL football out there (outside of the D.A.B), let alone not having anyone playing in the WAFL that can step up.

He doesn't get paid as much as others !

 

[pinkus maximus]

He can be jaded in 6 weeks all he likes, he's paid to play. If we had even remotely close to a full list maybe he can have a rest. But we've got at least 3 players that are just not up to playing AFL football out there (outside of the D.A.B), let alone not having anyone playing in the WAFL that can step up.

Palmer was rested last year and he is as mature a first year player as you can get. Hill will be rested it's just a matter of when

 

[dominguez]

Tarrantino tried to come back on so I assume there's nothing structurally wrong and he should be fine.

A couple of people have Bradley as an ommission but wasn't he better than Campbell? I thought Kiwi had a shocker.

I like the idea of resting Hill, straight swap for Son Son.

Mundy won't be dropped and while Ruffles didn't get much of the ball what he did was pretty good.

Out - Foster Campbell Hill
In - Pavlich Sandilands Walters.

 

[Scham]

Is Clarke 100%? I've got a feeling he may've pulled up a bit crook as well?

OUT: Taz, Foster, Clarke?
IN: Pav, Walters (or Schama if he's fit) and Sandi.

 

[fitzmantle]

Tarrantino tried to come back on so I assume there's nothing structurally wrong and he should be fine.

A couple of people have Bradley as an ommission but wasn't he better than Campbell? I thought Kiwi had a shocker.

I like the idea of resting Hill, straight swap for Son Son.

Mundy won't be dropped and while Ruffles didn't get much of the ball what he did was pretty good.

Out - Foster Campbell Hill
In - Pavlich Sandilands Walters.

Campbell could of won us the game if those arse clowns had a brain. How the F was that not a mark?

 

[fitzmantle]

Nah just perhaps another player who looks like he wants to play for the jumper.

Watch the young fellas throwing their skinny bodies on the lone and then watch him.

If you want that, good luck to you

I dont think our young blokes do that at all. We have one guy called Dean Sollomon who does that.

The fact Mundy has resigned for us a couple of times suggests he does care for the jumper? Clearly he is a defender playing out of position in the midfield because we dont have any others?

 

[Lach72]

I think I've just about heard it all now

 

[Clay Davis]

No way does Hill look jaded. What a stupid thing to say.

This was a heavily contested game, and his body isn't big enough to match it with the big boys. He did seem very tired at the end, so he might not come up for next week.

Would love to see Mundy dropped, but sadly that ain't going to happen