Preview Changes vs Sydney

[BIG MATTY WHITE]

If you guys...and anyone at the club is serious.....

Jonas HAS to go....he has been bad this year but this game was worse than anything I have seen from any player this year....

 

[Jakksynn]

Jonas won't be dropped. That's not how Ken does things. He'll be played until he finds form. Same with Hartlett and Schulz.

I miss the Hitman. What happened to him over the summer

 

[BIG MATTY WHITE]

Jonas won't be dropped. That's not how Ken does things. He'll be played until he finds form. Same with Hartlett and Schulz.

I miss the Hitman. What happened to him over the summer

If we accept that performance from anyone....no wonder why we are in the steaming pile we are in...

Actually you are probably right westhoff hartlett keep getting game so why not...

But downright without a shadow of a doubt that was the worse performance by any player that has played this year

 

[rogerjames]

Out: forwards that play like defenders
In: forwards that lead and play IN FRONT and keep their feet

Is Monfries the forward equivalent of Chappie?

 

[Jakksynn]

If we accept that performance from anyone....no wonder why we are in the steaming pile we are in...

Actually you are probably right westhoff hartlett keep getting game so why not...

But downright without a shadow of a doubt that was the worse performance by any player that has played this year

Admittedly I missed the first three quarters so I don't know how bad he was, he does need to be dropped though. I honestly don't remember his last good game.

We're carrying enough out of form players as it is. Clurey is a good swap. Will Ken do it though?

Doubtful.

 

[philthy05]

Jonas - Ryder
Mitchell - Amon

The moves I think should be made.

Understand Moore didn't have a great one but feel like he needs time to get into afl intensity and might pay off.

If lobbe doesn't offer us a great deal when Ryder comes back I would drop lobbe for butch/ harvey

 

[philthy05]

I don't thnk we really need to swap like for like with Jonas and bring in another tall. Although I do like clurey.

 

[Schulzenfest]

This isn't a week for wholesale changes. You don't really want to make wholesale changes two games in a row, and anybody we promoted from the SANFL would be coming off of a 4 day break.

In Ryder , Amon
Out Mitchell , Jonas

Put me down for one of these. Amon to sub.

Ryder for Jonas isn't exactly like for like but we've got too many half back flankers as it is.

 

[Andre]

Outs : Jonas, Mitchell, Carlile
Ins: Ryder, Amon, Clurey

Moore wasn't great, but he also wasn't in the bottom 5 players. Give him and Ah Chee time in the middle from the opening bounce until the end of the year. In and out of the side isn't going to show us anything. Only a run of games will do that.

I've said it before Mitchell is Sam Gray Lite. Great at SANFL level, but just not big enough to bring that to AFL. Along with like Sam, flaws in his game you can get away with at a lower level, but not against the size, speed and disposal of AFL. Amon is faster, has better disposal and isn't afraid to go for the hard stuff. No brainer who to pick when both are fit.

Carlile is an out, as for about the third or fourth time in the last few weeks his back is obviously playing up. Our season is shot, we want to get games into Clurey, don't play Carlile whilst he's under duress. One way to make the season worse is to turn a recurring niggle for Bobby into a long term injury. Give him weeks off to fully heal.

Post Sydney, once Ryder has a game under his belt I'd drop whoever is performing worst of Schulz and Lobbe for Harvey.

 

[glitch01]

Am I right in assuming that if the guys played today they can't play SANFL next week over the bye?
Would be nice if the likes of Jonas and Hartlett could have a run instead of a rest.....might be the wake up call that is needed.

 

[bacharach]

Wont even bother watching this. Will go to the movies. Be surprised if we get within 50 pts

Yep. There's this movie called Thin-skinned, Overdramatic and Pathetic. You should definitely go and see it!

 

[FallingLiefs]

Out: Mitchell, Moore
In: Amon, Ryder

Sub: Ah Chee if dry, Amon if wet.

Krak forward.

 

[scottjr]

Ah Chee has earned a start. He's the only inside mid we have had come on and consistently pulled his weight with the game time he has had. Ah Chee looks to be part of the solution long term he must get game time.

 

[Dave Omsby]

Definitely Arch for a full game , the bloke has shown more signs than a Las Vegas boulevard that he might have a skill set up to AFL level , if he can't run the game out well ... Sub him off at 3/4 time , he's shown more than any of the fringe players in the last 6 weeks so Ken .... Full game for AhChee please . Amen

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Hinkley is way to loyal too his best 22. Will never drop a Jonas or a Schulz no matter how they are playing.

 

[Grandaddy J]

If Arch doesn't get a full game I'll fully support him on his journey out the door come year's end.

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

Out - Mitchell

In - Ryder

Jonas, Schulz on notice

Still on notice?

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

Out hinkley, Jonas, Mitchell, Monfries, Schulz, lobbe
In hocking, Clurey, Amon, neade, Ryder, Harvey

 

[Waspy79]

Out: Lobbe, Jonas, Mitchell,
In: Ryder, Butcher/Harvey, Amon (sub)

 

[edgie]

Jonas won't be dropped. That's not how Ken does things. He'll be played until he finds form. Same with Hartlett and Schulz.

I miss the Hitman. What happened to him over the summer

 

[AJJPAFC]

If we accept that performance from anyone....no wonder why we are in the steaming pile we are in...

Actually you are probably right westhoff hartlett keep getting game so why not...

But downright without a shadow of a doubt that was the worse performance by any player that has played this year

Lobbe last week was worse.

 

[Holden Hillbilly]

Out: Jonas, Schulz, Mitchell

In: Ryder, Amon, Clurey

 

[Nemisis]

What will happen
OUT: Mitchell
IN: Ryder

What should happen - hey the seasons over
OUT: Mitchell, Jonas, Monfries, Schultz
IN: Ryder, Harvey, Clurey, Amon/Butcher

Moore was poore yesterday but hopefully more games = improvement/draft pick

 

[QPower]

Who cares! The season is cooked.

 

[Jim Dixon]

Out- Jonas, Mitchell
In- Ryder, Cluery

Normally I'd be pushing for Mitch Harvey but the SCG against the rampaging Swans is a bloody hard place to debut- I'd rather wait a week and launch the good Ship Harvey at home against Collingwood.