Opinion Changes vs Sydney

[El_Scorcho]

I expect he'll bring Marshall back in given Ladhams did nothing to hold his position and isn't a key forward. Marshall wasn't dropped on form and Ladhams wasn't picked on form.

 

[afl2004]

Hinkley said faz was unlikely to play this game , think he misses

 

[ROBBBO]

Raz I read will be another week.
Good to see Williams put together 4 quarters today. Must come in for Gray.
It cannot be Bonner. If he comes in I will honestly ring the club and lose my s**t.
Hayes battled today but would still like to see him in our forward line. Could be such a weapon

 

[Janus]

I've got no problem with Hartlett coming into the side - as soon as Gray got injured it was Jones who was shifted forward. He's not better than Jones, but he's better than Garner or whoever else we would bring in to replace Jones. Plus the game is being played on the smaller Adelaide Oval which can hide his lack of speed.

Fantasia should be right to come in for Gray.

Marshall should come in for Ladhams - the 'advantage' of playing two rucks is negated by the fact that Ladhams isn't a dominant presence around the ground.

Williams I'd include in the side as well, but only as the sub. He doesn't have the tank to get through an entire game of AFL at this stage of his career, but 6 goals should be rewarded with some form of acknowledgement.

 

[glitch01]

I think Ken will bring Hartlett straight back in now that Jones is injured.
Hartlett looked ok coming on as sub and we all know Ken won’t make many changes anyway.
I think we’ll see Jones, Gray and Ladhams out, Hartlett, Marshall and Woodcock in.
Personally would like to see Garner get another shot and from what people have said maybe give Williams a go. Don’t really mind if we keep Ladhams and not pick Marshall, unpopular opinion I know, but I think Ladhams is improving and I think he plays better in tandem with Lycett.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[EskimoPAFC]

That’s how I feel.

I’d love for Williams to kick 7 today and prove me wrong, and Garner to have a blinder and both to come in on merit next week.

So close

 

[Schulzenfest]

Williams I'd include in the side as well, but only as the sub. He doesn't have the tank to get through an entire game of AFL at this stage of his career, but 6 goals should be rewarded with some form of acknowledgement.

That's the worst possible thing we could do with Williams. Ideally I'd like to see him get a proper AFL game, but given the choice I'd much rather see him get a full game at SANFL level than risk him getting no gametime at all.

 

[Arsene Wenger]

I would love to see Williams as much as everyone else, but you know it will be Hartlett and Marshall for Jones and Gray.

Personally, i can handle Hartlett coming back purely because of the players we have out, I am also happy for Marshall to come back (but at the expense of Ladhams), but Williams should come in for Robbie. Its not like Robbie is great at pressure up forward either - its almost the ideal swap.

If i see Woodcock in I will be sick.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

I like the idea of a forward who reduces the need for locking the ball in the F50 by kicking goals.

 

[Lefti93]

I like the idea of a forward who reduces the need for locking the ball in the F50 by kicking goals.

what is this foreign concept you speak of? must be talking about another sport.

 

[jac147]

Not sure where to put this? Due to the COVID outbreaks in Sydney shouldn’t the Swans start thinking about hopping on an Adelaide bound plane post haste.
I could possibly see this game being postponed.
The dogs are already in Perth for their Sunday clash against the WCE

 

[Steve Dore]

I like the idea of a forward who reduces the need for locking the ball in the F50 by kicking goals.

but the team with the most repeat F50 entries wins?

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

I mean Dylan is replacing Gray, it's not like Robbie is a pressure forward lol.

Yes we do need someone in the forward line to pressure defenders but that person should be in addition to Dylan/Gray.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

Hartlett being poor in the seconds and subbing in a game in which we won it in the first quarter being enough to keep his spot doesn't sit right with me.

 

[Ports1870]

I’ve got it as Hartlett, Marshall and Williams for Jones, Ladhams and Gray at the moment.
If Orazio is fit he comes in for Farrell.
If Clurey is fit he goes in for Lienert and McKenzie plays a more half back flanker type role.

 

[PowerBaz]

I like the idea of a forward who reduces the need for locking the ball in the F50 by kicking goals.

Malcolm Blight 'simple'...... crazy talk.....

We seem to make everything look so hard don't we.

 

[PowerBaz]

Hartlett being poor in the seconds and subbing in a game in which we won it in the first quarter being enough to keep his spot doesn't sit right with me.

Kem was itching to get Hartlett back in - we owe it to him.

 

[PatientMental]

Kem was itching to get Hartlett back in - we owe it to him.

We owe * nothing to Hartlett.

Never delivered on talent and never will.

 

[Enviable Tradition]

I’ve got it as Hartlett, Marshall and Williams for Jones, Ladhams and Gray at the moment.
If Orazio is fit he comes in for Farrell.
If Clurey is fit he goes in for Lienert and McKenzie plays a more half back flanker type role.

I think we are going to have another go at the tall forward line.

Im expecting Marshall to come in and Ladhams to stay.

Williams will be asked to back it up and could then come in for Ladhams or Marshall.

From Bassetts comments it seems like they thing of Williams as more a tall than a small.

On SM-G960F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[PowerBaz]

I think we are going to have another go at the tall forward line.

Im expecting Marshall to come in and Ladhams to stay.

Williams will be asked to back it up and could then come in for Ladhams or Marshall.

From Bassetts comments it seems like they thing of Williams as more a tall than a small.

On SM-G960F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Like Garner 'stay in the 'SANFL' until you cop an injury...

 

[Buget]

Not sure where to put this? Due to the COVID outbreaks in Sydney shouldn’t the Swans start thinking about hopping on an Adelaide bound plane post haste.
I could possibly see this game being postponed.
The dogs are already in Perth for their Sunday clash against the WCE

Considering the outbreak is in eastern suburbs, where most of the Swans players live…. You raise a very interesting point.

 

[PowerBaz]

With our players missing this one will be tough.

 

[El Zorro]

The biggest loss by having Gray out is his centre clearance work. Who's replacing that? No one I guess.

 

[RossFC]

Starting midfield group: Lycett, Wines, Boak, Drew.

Rotation: Ladhams, Powell-Pepper, Rozee, Houston, Amon.

 

[Rigs]